Bike Shops
Coaches
Fitters
Race Calendar
*NEW* Running Stores
Stack & Reach
Training Log
Triathlon Clubs
MAIN
INDEX
RULES &
LEGEND
LOG
IN
Search
this forum
this category
all forums
for
All words
Any words
Whole Phrase
(
options
)
Newsletter Signup
Slowtwitch Forums
:
Triathlon Forum
:
What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes??
1
2
3
View All
Tri Forum
Classifieds
Lavender Room
Jobs
The Womens
Print Thread
BIGZACH
Nov 3, 09 5:06
Post #51 of 68 (459 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [SeasonsChange]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
weirdasses do ride them. theyre always giving you that pedi-smile and they cant steer worth poop.
Yea, and they always wear something Neon in color.........I don't even like them, they aren't even people...haha...JUsssst Kiddding
renegade027
Nov 3, 09 5:12
Post #52 of 68 (457 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [RChung]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
I remember reading that the Varna Diablo II (
http://www.hi-id.com/?p=553)
- the vehicle used to establish some of the past land speed record has a CdA of just under .15 and that other versions of the Varna which also compete at Battle Mountain (mostly designed by George Georgiev) are about .16.
I think he uses pictures to establish frontal area, but not sure what exactly he does to calculate his CdA numbers.
A couple of years ago, Mr Georgiev seemed to think that a CdA of .14 was possible with improvements of the current design. The new vehicle (Varna Tempest) is probably around there CdA wise (82.819 MPH 1/4 mile avrg. speed and 56.295 MPH 1 hour effort this year)
http://timetogetnaked.com/...2009/07/dsc_6575.jpg
A camera-and-screen solution could theoretically lower CdA even further - but handling and tyre blowouts are a major issue at these speeds.
I am pretty sure you can contact George Georgiev and, if you explain who you are, he'll probably be happy to tell you more about his methodology.
Sam Whittington, the guy who rides Mr. Georgiev's vehicles, is a former national level Canadian track cyclist. I am pretty sure he has a good idea of the power numbers during his record attempts and will be happy to share some files with you.
RChung
Nov 3, 09 6:59
Post #53 of 68 (449 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [renegade027]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
I remember reading that the Varna Diablo II (
http://www.hi-id.com/?p=553)
- the vehicle used to establish some of the past land speed record has a CdA of just under .15 and that other versions of the Varna which also compete at Battle Mountain (mostly designed by George Georgiev) are about .16.
I think he uses pictures to establish frontal area, but not sure what exactly he does to calculate his CdA numbers.
A couple of years ago, Mr Georgiev seemed to think that a CdA of .14 was possible with improvements of the current design. The new vehicle (Varna Tempest) is probably around there CdA wise (82.819 MPH 1/4 mile avrg. speed and 56.295 MPH 1 hour effort this year)
http://timetogetnaked.com/...2009/07/dsc_6575.jpg
A camera-and-screen solution could theoretically lower CdA even further - but handling and tyre blowouts are a major issue at these speeds.
I am pretty sure you can contact George Georgiev and, if you explain who you are, he'll probably be happy to tell you more about his methodology.
Sam Whittington, the guy who rides Mr. Georgiev's vehicles, is a former national level Canadian track cyclist. I am pretty sure he has a good idea of the power numbers during his record attempts and will be happy to share some files with you.
Thanks. Yeah, I believe some of Varna designs have been in the wind tunnel. An oddity of the streamliner hpv world is that (on those occasions when they do know their CdA) they report in ft^2 not m^2, so that .15 you refer to is .15 ft^2 (around .015 m^2). I know Sam occasionally uses an SRM in training but it's not clear he uses one in the high speed runs. I have an e-mail in to him but haven't yet received a reply whether they ever do field testing.
Cassie
Nov 3, 09 7:10
Post #54 of 68 (446 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [jackmott]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
they are in fact, often weirdos
but in a good way I think
not we like aren't
My husband wants to get one but I told him I would divorce him if he did because they look so weird.
He just raised his eyebrows in disbelief at me. Yes, apparently he thinks I am already weird with all my gear, so I guess that's the end of that conversation, lol!
FJB
Nov 3, 09 8:38
Post #55 of 68 (426 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [Cassie]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
He just raised his eyebrows in disbelief at me. Yes, apparently he thinks I am already weird with all my gear, so I guess that's the end of that conversation, lol!
I used to race triathlons and now just do touring and I have to laugh at myself now over the way I used to look doing triathlons. On tours I wouldn't be caught dead in cylcing shoes, anything spandex and god forbid, cycling jerseys. To me, watching a group of cyclists/triathletes stop at a store with their clicking shoes and matching outfits makes me laugh, so I know where your husband is coming from.
I now where sandals or hiking type shoes with recessed clips, real shorts with padding and shirts designed for hot/cool weather without having so many bright colours. I'm sure triathletes laugh at me as they fly by my fully loaded bike but that's okay, I've been there and think someday they too will see the light :)
jackmott
Nov 3, 09 8:46
Post #56 of 68 (422 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [FJB]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
speaking of recessed clips
does that exist for look style pedals?
----
What is good in life? - To crush your enemie's dreams, see them dropped behind you, and to hear the lamentation of their women!
Sunglasses:
http://www.framesdirect.com/sunglasses
Tri Gear:
http://www.atctrishop.com
Cheap Disc Wheel -
http://www.wheelbuilder.com
Tire Crr Data -
http://www.biketechreview.com
FJB
Nov 3, 09 11:06
Post #57 of 68 (398 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [jackmott]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
does that exist for look style pedals?
I'm not sure....I'll try to find out later today.
renegade027
Nov 4, 09 2:13
Post #58 of 68 (360 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [RChung]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
Another possibility is that maybe the number is only Cd since the A would be quasi constant to him once the basic parameters of the model are set - George can tweak only shapes. Looking at pictures of his vehicle assembly process, it seems he has the chassis built first and then designs and molds a top and a bottom 'skin'
I don't know - it just looks like even with total CdA (m2) of .10-11, Sam needs to make upwards of 3000W for the last 10 sec. - kind of a tall order even for a national level sprinter.
If these figures are for Cd only then with reasonable A assumptions I can see how Sam is able to crank this thing up to such speeds with a more humanly 1600-2000W 10 sec. output - still quite a lot according to Allen-Coggan power-duration chart, but imaginable.
gerard
Nov 4, 09 3:22
Post #59 of 68 (350 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [RChung]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
In Reply To:
It seems like you loose so much power because you can't really engage your core muscles.
Errr, no. The world human powered speed record is generally set by people riding in this position.
You'll have a hard time finding power numbers for riders in those record attempts. Top speed is a function of both power and drag and we know the drag is lower (though how much lower is also hard to know) so it's not clear what happens to top end power.
I've just spent some time asking on recumbent forums how they measure aerodynamic and rolling drag. I wasn't asking what that drag was, I was just asking how they do it. In general, they don't and several people got angry that I asked. The consensus was that measuring was either impossible or impractical or useless.
[Edit:] BTW, I wasn't criticizing that point of view -- I was surprised by it.
Actually, it's quite easy to find that sort of data, the HPV world is filled with very smart people approaching design in a very scientific way, measuring everything. But maybe the problem is (and that would be a general problem) that you're trying to find useful info on a forum. If you check the IHPVA newsletters, or old issues of Cycling Science, then you will find drag numbers, wattages, etc. Slightly off-topic but super-interesting is the book "The fullness of wings" about the Daedalus project. The research done there on nutrition gave birth to Shaklee energy drinks, and eventually to the pro cycling team of the same name. But more than a tech story, it's a very well-written human story.
Gerard
Cervélo SA
Note: This forum is not my Inbox. Please choose: Slowtwitch cust. service or
Cervélo customer service.
garageman
Nov 4, 09 4:07
Post #60 of 68 (342 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [gerard]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
Pretty sure there will be more weirdos on recumbents when cervelo makes one.
RChung
Nov 4, 09 6:50
Post #61 of 68 (305 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [renegade027]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
I don't know - it just looks like even with total CdA (m2) of .10-11, Sam needs to make upwards of 3000W for the last 10 sec. - kind of a tall order even for a national level sprinter.
Yeah, that's why I think the CdA you quoted was for sq. ft., not m^2. Battle Mountain is around 1500m ASL, the timing section is (I think) 200m long, and there's a 3km run-in to the speed trap. If you stick in a CdA in m^2 of something like .015ish, you'll get more human-like power numbers.
RChung
Nov 4, 09 7:04
Post #62 of 68 (295 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [gerard]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
In Reply To:
I've just spent some time asking on recumbent forums how they measure aerodynamic and rolling drag. I wasn't asking what that drag was, I was just asking how they do it.
Actually,
it's quite easy to find that sort of data
, the HPV world is filled with very smart people approaching design in a very scientific way, measuring everything. But maybe the problem is (and that would be a general problem) that you're trying to find useful info on a forum. If you check the IHPVA newsletters, or old issues of Cycling Science,
then you will find drag numbers, wattages, etc.
You're surely right about asking on forums. Nonetheless, this was the forum that is frequented by several of the builders making record attempts, and I wasn't looking for the
data
, I was asking
how they did it
. I've checked all the back issues of the IHPVA.org journal but only a couple from Cycling Science and I didn't see much info about testing methods and protocols, especially in the field.
Andrew Coggan
Nov 4, 09 7:37
Post #63 of 68 (283 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [gerard]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
the HPV world is filled with very smart people approaching design in a very scientific way, measuring everything.
Like Matt Weaver:
http://www.speed101.com/
In Reply To:
Slightly off-topic but super-interesting is the book "The fullness of wings" about the Daedalus project. The research done there on nutrition gave birth to Shaklee energy drinks, and eventually to the pro cycling team of the same name. But more than a tech story, it's a very well-written human story.
I once had the immense pleasure of hearing the late Ethan Nadel give an after-dinner talk at a Gatorade sports science conference about the Daedalus project. As you indicated, a great human interest story, and one that Dr. Nadel presented wonderfully, especially given the mixed audience (ranging from scientists to corporate executives to spouses/significant others). I wasn't aware of the book, though - will have to look for it now.
Andrew Coggan
Nov 4, 09 7:45
Post #64 of 68 (279 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [RChung]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
In Reply To:
In Reply To:
I've just spent some time asking on recumbent forums how they measure aerodynamic and rolling drag. I wasn't asking what that drag was, I was just asking how they do it.
Actually,
it's quite easy to find that sort of data
, the HPV world is filled with very smart people approaching design in a very scientific way, measuring everything. But maybe the problem is (and that would be a general problem) that you're trying to find useful info on a forum. If you check the IHPVA newsletters, or old issues of Cycling Science,
then you will find drag numbers, wattages, etc.
You're surely right about asking on forums. Nonetheless, this was the forum that is frequented by several of the builders making record attempts, and I wasn't looking for the
data
, I was asking
how they did it
. I've checked all the back issues of the IHPVA.org journal but only a couple from Cycling Science and I didn't see much info about testing methods and protocols, especially in the field.
I don't think your survey is really typical of the way the serious competitors approach such questions. For example, Lim learned of the regression approach from those in the HPV world, and HPVers also were the first to measure relative wind speed (and direction) with instrumentation on the bicycle.
RChung
Nov 4, 09 7:57
Post #65 of 68 (268 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [Andrew Coggan]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
In Reply To:
You're surely right about asking on forums. Nonetheless, this was the forum that is frequented by several of the builders making record attempts, and I wasn't looking for the
data
, I was asking
how they did it
. I've checked all the back issues of the IHPVA.org journal but only a couple from Cycling Science and I didn't see much info about testing methods and protocols, especially in the field.
I don't think your survey is really typical of the way the serious competitors approach such questions. For example, Lim learned of the regression approach from those in the HPV world, and HPVers also were the first to measure relative wind speed (and direction) with instrumentation on the bicycle.
Perhaps not, but I've searched the literature so the next step was to ask people who I expected would have an incentive to do measurement. A couple had been in the wind tunnel, and one or two had (in the past) done the regression approach but said they weren't doing it any more. BTW, no one admitted to testing rolling drag.
Andrew Coggan
Nov 4, 09 8:01
Post #66 of 68 (262 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [RChung]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
no one admitted to testing rolling drag.
Considering the speeds that are achieved, I'm not sure that low Crr should be one's first consideration when it comes to choosing tires. ;-)
RChung
Nov 4, 09 8:16
Post #67 of 68 (248 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [Andrew Coggan]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
In Reply To:
no one admitted to testing rolling drag.
Considering the speeds that are achieved, I'm not sure that low Crr should be one's first consideration when it comes to choosing tires. ;-)
No one admitted to testing tires for any characteristic.
Nicko
Nov 24, 09 13:31
Post #68 of 68 (150 views)
Re: What's up with wierdos on recumbent bikes?? [Andrew Coggan]
[
In reply to
]
Can't Post
In Reply To:
In Reply To:
no one admitted to testing rolling drag.
Considering the speeds that are achieved, I'm not sure that low Crr should be one's first consideration when it comes to choosing tires. ;-)
err.. you got the physics backwards there.
the faster you go with a fixed power, the more important rolling resistance becomes.
1
2
3
View All
Print Thread
Are equipment rules important?
What organization's rules do you seek to comply with before you purchase bikes, wetsuits, etc.?
UCI
USA Cycling
UCI/USAC
WTC
USAT
WTC/USAT
ITU
All
None