Slowtwitch Forums: Triathlon Forum: Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD

Calendar Coaches Fitters Retailers Triathlon Clubs Stack & Reach Custom Geometry Calculator Training Log
		MAIN INDEX	RULES & LEGEND	LOG IN

Search for (options)

Newsletter Signup

Slowtwitch Forums: Triathlon Forum:
Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD

red_and_black

Oct 31, 09 12:37

Post #1 of 8 (200 views)

Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD	Can't Post

I'm building up a pretty basic road bike. I bought a braze-on FD before I bought the frame(105, if it matters). The frame accepts a clamp-on FD. So my options are:

1. Shell out $15 for an adapter.
2. Sell the FD I have now and pick up a clamp-on.

I really have no problem doing either, as far as finances go. I've had good luck getting good deals on most of my parts, so an extra $15 wouldn't break me. At the same time, I have a guy who would buy the FD from me if I don't want it, and FD's really aren't a huge expense(at least, compared to other components). So what I'm wondering is, from a performance/durability/overall quality standpoint, is it better to have a clamp-on, or a braze-on with an adapter. Common sense would tell me that putting a clamp-on derailleur on a frame that accepts clamp-ons is probably my best bet, but I don't really have any data or experience or logic to back that up. Will I have issues with an adapter?

Also, here's a picture of a furry animal.

ironcouple

Oct 31, 09 12:51

Post #2 of 8 (195 views)

Re: Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD [red_and_black] [In reply to]	Can't Post

i've never had an issue using an adapter with a braze-on fd. to tell you the truth, i never even thought about it making any difference...
____________________________________________________________
"I'm happy when life's good,
and when it's bad I cry.
I've got values but I don't know how or why."
- The Who

KEAU

Oct 31, 09 12:53

Post #3 of 8 (189 views)

Re: Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD [red_and_black] [In reply to]	Can't Post

buy the adapter

Konovalovas 7:2,53-91s
www.bartape.net

Barchettaman

Oct 31, 09 13:29

Post #4 of 8 (170 views)

Re: Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD [red_and_black] [In reply to]	Can't Post

The adaptors work well, it�ll be fine.

red_and_black

Oct 31, 09 15:46

Post #5 of 8 (140 views)

Re: Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD [red_and_black] [In reply to]	Can't Post

There seems to be consensus on the issue. No dissenting voices?

Darrell

Oct 31, 09 18:10

Post #6 of 8 (126 views)

Re: Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD [red_and_black] [In reply to]	Can't Post

Get the adapter. Fewer and fewer frames still have a round seat tube so the braze on FD will be compatible with more frames in the event you upgrade the frame or want to sell off the component later.

.
-Darrell
http://www.FrontOfThePack.com
15% code: ST2009 (online orders only)

FIST certified retailer of Cervelo, Kuota, Guru, HydroTail, SRM, De Soto and other fine equipment.

Zeriman

Nov 2, 09 11:35

Post #7 of 8 (80 views)

Re: Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD [red_and_black] [In reply to]	Can't Post

An adapter will work just fine. The only advantage to a clamp on is a very tiny weight savings versus using an adapter.
-------------------------------------
Paulie meets triathlon: http://givingitatri.blogspot.com

jyeager

Nov 2, 09 12:13

Post #8 of 8 (58 views)

Re: Wrenches: Braze-On FD w/Adapter vs. Clamp-On FD [red_and_black] [In reply to]	Can't Post

Thanks for the furry animal pic. It should be a requirement with all posts!