Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE
Quote | Reply
Today is probably the launch of the new S-Works Shiv Disc 2019.

Below you can find the first pictures as well the description.
What is your opionion???








Well, I guess the paintjob is great.
The storage on the downtube is interesting and I am curious about their explanation on the sail in back.

I love it.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The thing in the back bothers me, but it looks to be removable. I think I'd be OK if it was level with the top tube such as on Trek's SC or QR's PR6, et.

The aerobar looks interesting, one picture shows it angled down while the other shows it level. I assume there's also the ability to tilt it up.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Take a closer look at the picture from the front. The fork looks really interesting.
I kind of like it. My question would be if the "sail" is only for hydrtion or does it also fit other stuff...
Last edited by: Chris_Mint: Oct 7, 18 23:15
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I like it.
Go ahead, flame suit is on already.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pbnz] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pbnz wrote:
I like it.
Go ahead, flame suit is on already.

OMG look at it:



So monostem seems to be the next big thing in tri bikes...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andres] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pretty sure the rear container is for 2L of fluids

wovebike.com | Wove on instagram
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Very first thing was ā€œI like it, if you remove the sailā€ because it reminds me HUGELY of my old, flip/flop green purple GT vengeance, from ā€˜98, like Mark Allenā€™s bike from 96.
Not sure about the aesthetic of the twin-foil fork, but Iā€™m sure Wilier will be pleased to say, ā€œwe did that 5 years agoā€!

'to give anything less than the best is to sacrifice the gift'...Pre
Last edited by: undies: Oct 8, 18 12:39
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
https://www.specialized.com/...?color=264700-171376

Go for one of the 500 limited editions. Sounds cheap :D
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm sorry, but the hydration rear sail is hideous. I wonder will different sizes of the hydration box be available, I'm guessing frame sizes/saddle height needs will mandate it.

It's a shame, as the front end looks great, with foldable basebar and removable cockpit. Storage in downtube looks good too, hopefully will be accessible enough in practice.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [milesthedog] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
milesthedog wrote:
pretty sure the rear container is for 2L of fluids

Whatever it is, not into it.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [MichaelB88] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
MichaelB88 wrote:
https://www.specialized.com/no/en/s-works-shiv-disc-limited-edition/p/171376?color=264700-171376

Go for one of the 500 limited editions. Sounds cheap :D

I guess what we are looking at is the limited edition. The standard colour for this will be "satin white"
i guess 13k for the standard and 15k for the SE
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Plotted Reach,stack of Shivs, included P3 MKII as that is indicative of where the majority of manufacturers are at



So the new bike has moved to the market norm, rather than following the high stack philosophy of Gen 1.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jeez that thing is ugly! I'm a card-carrying Specialized fan but everything about that bike is hideous, from the tri-foil front end and beefy shoulders on the basebar to the uber-low chainstays out the back! The shonky looking in-frame storage on the downtube and tail bolted on to the back don't do much to help it aesthetically either.

But I guess that's not the point at all, it's all about how many seconds they'll claim you can save over the old Shiv and I'm sure we'll see some stats from the tunnel in due course.

So, is this a tri-specific model, or would this be UCI-legal too, given the recent changes that they made to the regulations? Assuming that hideous tail on the rear could be removed of course...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Can't be UCI legal with that fork - the Headtube/nose is too deep
seatstays too low on seattube as well - so it won't be legal with a different fork either
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
awenborn wrote:
beefy shoulders on the basebar..

Yeah, they do not look aero.

29 years and counting
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [cyclenutnz] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
cyclenutnz wrote:
Can't be UCI legal with that fork - the Headtube/nose is too deep
seatstays too low on seattube as well - so it won't be legal with a different fork either

I thought as much.

This bike will not help in trying to improve the image-problem and credibility of triathletes amongst cyclists!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Reminds me of something...

Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
awenborn wrote:
cyclenutnz wrote:
Can't be UCI legal with that fork - the Headtube/nose is too deep
seatstays too low on seattube as well - so it won't be legal with a different fork either


I thought as much.

This bike will not help in trying to improve the image-problem and credibility of triathletes amongst cyclists!


How many triathletes do you know that care about their image among cyclists?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
awenborn wrote:
This bike will not help in trying to improve the image-problem and credibility of triathletes amongst cyclists!

You mean the millions of MAMILs who can't ride without stopping for a coffee, and average 27kph in a group ride? Or Pros?

What the other guy said about who cares :-)

29 years and counting
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [cyclenutnz] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
well that's certainly an improvement from a fit perspective for the smaller sizes but for the larger sizes I'd worry about running out of reach.

cyclenutnz wrote:
Plotted Reach,stack of Shivs, included P3 MKII as that is indicative of where the majority of manufacturers are at



So the new bike has moved to the market norm, rather than following the high stack philosophy of Gen 1.

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

ā€œYou are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.ā€
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Not impressed by the first impression. It looks like they ā€œimprovedā€ upon the Wiler Twin Blade and $13-$15k price tag...šŸ¤Ŗ. It better be fast because itā€™s not winning any beauty contests. That luggage in the back also looks like a late addition or after thought.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericMPro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
how do you take it apart for travelling ?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Gross!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ZenTriBrett] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ZenTriBrett wrote:
Reminds me of something...




Last edited by: MattyK: Oct 8, 18 4:16
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
im not sure i would want 2 entire liters of fluid on the bike with me starting out. thats a lot of weight, and im curious how that weight would feel so high up on the bike and at the rear.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
does it have disc brakes? i'm told that i need disc brakes. i don't know why, but i do. i'll pay whatever they're asking.

____________________________________
https://lshtm.academia.edu/MikeCallaghan

http://howtobeswiss.blogspot.ch/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The fork has grown on me. The base bar shoulder... not so much. I want to see the rear hydration in the largest frame size before I pass overall judgement. For race day it appears to be a practical solution.

...the price, sheesh
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [iron_mike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I was just about to ask where BryanD was, but I see you're filling in admirably...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The added weight on the rear would be less noticeable than weight on the front end. It is a good design, its just not very attractive.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [arby] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
arby wrote:
The added weight on the rear would be less noticeable than weight on the front end. It is a good design, its just not very attractive.

thats what i keep thinking. i know how my bike feels with 30oz of fluid between the bars versus zero. im a big fan of the feeling of zero.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
...the price, sheesh

Yeah but it's the same every time with Specialized; the S Works Tarmac SL6 Ultralight and the new Venge Disc, both had price tags well north of $10k.

It's marketing 101, release a headline-grabbing top-of-the-line product at an eye-watering price and garner as much attention as possible. Then 6-9 months later, release a the regular range of models for the masses, sporting 105/Ultegra components, maybe a model with some cheap wheels and generally at less than half the price. Everyone falls over themselves to buy it, thinking they're basically getting a 15k bike for 8k, and don't question the lower price-tag too much!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So years ago when Wilier were destroyed for their interesting fork effort they were wrong...but now spesh are right?!

Hateful machine
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pk] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm sure it fits quite easily in the luggage compartment of the private jet you probably have if you are dropping $15k on this.

***
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
awenborn wrote:
I was just about to ask where BryanD was, but I see you're filling in admirably...

i mean, someone had to say it.

____________________________________
https://lshtm.academia.edu/MikeCallaghan

http://howtobeswiss.blogspot.ch/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
im not sure i would want 2 entire liters of fluid on the bike with me starting out. thats a lot of weight, and im curious how that weight would feel so high up on the bike and at the rear.

Probably not a lot different than most bikes with two bottle behind the saddle and one between the arms
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Today is probably the launch of the new S-Works Shiv Disc 2019.
ā€¦ and maybe we'll finally hear who's riding this at Kona (five/six pros?)
Chris_Mint wrote:
I am curious about their explanation on the sail in back.
"It tested better in the Win Tunnel" :D
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
awenborn wrote:
I was just about to ask where BryanD was, but I see you're filling in admirably...
LOL

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [MichaelB88] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
MichaelB88 wrote:
https://www.specialized.com/no/en/s-works-shiv-disc-limited-edition/p/171376?color=264700-171376
Well, that went 404 fast.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
As with the the SC and the 9.0 carbon, the Sworks will not be worth it for 98% of folks. And the price break is significant.

I wonder how hard it is to get liquid all the way from back there thru the straw. The old one was not super easy.

The bike's success will come down to wind tunnel data and price point.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DBF] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DBF wrote:
I wonder how hard it is to get liquid all the way from back there thru the straw. The old one was not super easy.

Perfect bike for those who are extra good at sucking.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [turningscrews] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
hahahahahahahahahahah
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
My guess that the fork design is an attempt to improve the crown aerodynamics now that they are not limited by having a brake there. I'd love to know how well that works.

The rear sail will take some getting used to but if it's faster...

Looking forward to a good independent test.

-------------
Ed O'Malley
www.VeloVetta.com
Founder of VeloVetta Cycling Shoes
Instagram ā€¢ Facebook
Last edited by: RowToTri: Oct 8, 18 6:07
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
awenborn wrote:
I was just about to ask where BryanD was, but I see you're filling in admirably...

We have not seen a comment yet from him? Must still be asleep in NC.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm here!

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It hurts the eyes.

Overunder on absolutely terrible disc brake takes is 5. I am hammering the Over.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [RowToTri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yes. However, I don't really see (and I'm no aerodyanmics expert) how having two more vertical bars (i.e. more frontal area) that the air has to wrap around will make it better. Specifically when other manufactueres are trying to reduce the number of solids that the air has to wrap around. Specialized didn't want to jump on that bandwagon and said, "we'll add more!"
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pro_Sandbagger] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You might be right. It can be hard to improve overall aerodynamics by improving viscous effects in a way that increases frontal area- but it is not unheard of.

And actually frontal area may not be that much bigger here.

-------------
Ed O'Malley
www.VeloVetta.com
Founder of VeloVetta Cycling Shoes
Instagram ā€¢ Facebook
Last edited by: RowToTri: Oct 8, 18 6:36
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pro_Sandbagger] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That whole front end looks bigger and bigger every time I look at it!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pro_Sandbagger] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Reminds me of the Avanti track pursuit bike team New Zealand has been riding. Just check out that headset bearing compared to a standard 1 1/8ā€





Alex Arman

Strava
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [iron_mike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
iron_mike wrote:
does it have disc brakes? i'm told that i need disc brakes. i don't know why, but i do. i'll pay whatever they're asking.

Exactly........and its ugly to boot.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [doublea334] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
CAT cheetah was also doing stuff like this, years ago. eventually if you're making your bikes out of carbon and can build any shape you like, the limiting factor becomes standard hardware like BBs, headsets, and the like. so you simply make your own in bespoke dimensions that allow you to build the bike you want. annoying for repairs and stuff? sure. but it's a $15 000 bike. do you really care about that?

____________________________________
https://lshtm.academia.edu/MikeCallaghan

http://howtobeswiss.blogspot.ch/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Scottxs] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I like it! It's definitely different.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andres] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Andres wrote:
The thing in the back bothers me, but it looks to be removable. I think I'd be OK if it was level with the top tube such as on Trek's SC or QR's PR6, et.

But then, it might not be as effective as a "bluff body splitter", since it would be further from the "big blob" ;-)



http://bikeblather.blogspot.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:

The storage on the downtube is interesting and I am curious about their explanation on the sail in back.


I have two questions about its hydration functionality.

1) How do you refill it on course? From the picture posted here, it looks like the rear of the saddle extends pretty far back over the box, so, at best, you'd have to get a pretty steep attack angle on the bottle to reach wherever the opening is, even if the opening is all the way to the rear. It looks like it could be awkward. Maybe the answer is you don't refill on course, or you use a BTA if supplementing with on-course hydration. But I can easily burn through far more than 2L for a >100 mile bike on a hot day.

2) How do you clean the reservoir and the Roman Aquaduct-length tube? Are they flushable without getting sticky residue over the rest of your components? Even with good practice on flushing, eventually that tube is going to need to be sanitized properly (if I'm using it). Is it easy to remove and re-thread without an hour of profanity? Simply using straight water for hydration is not an option for me, as I prefer my calories liquid.

If bike purchase came down just to comparision of high-volume onboard hydration, the Ventum is winning for me hands down right now, though 1.4L vs. (allegedly) 2.0L. Unless there are really good answers for these two questions.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DBF] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DBF wrote:


I wonder how hard it is to get liquid all the way from back there thru the straw. The old one was not super easy.


most triathletes are really strong suckers, so i don't imagine it will be a problem

the bike is easy to pack, easy to fit, and fast (it's a specialized, it'll be fast). hyperbikes are going to be polarizing, but in person this one is pretty sick.
Last edited by: jkhayc: Oct 8, 18 7:10
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Could you just never fill it with liquid and just use it as storage

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
you'd use the giant empty down tube as storage. (SWAT)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
We will find out soon once the link goes live!

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [doublea334] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Wow, that's impressive and that looks like a beautiful bike.

You can get away with that in a velodrome but I wouldn't want to hit a pothole out on the road with a steerer tube that size!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tom A.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tom A. wrote:
Andres wrote:
The thing in the back bothers me, but it looks to be removable. I think I'd be OK if it was level with the top tube such as on Trek's SC or QR's PR6, et.

But then, it might not be as effective as a "bluff body splitter", since it would be further from the "big blob" ;-)


Iā€™m sure thereā€™s a 100% legitimate reason. Iā€™m just not into how it looks. Maybe Lucy will win now.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
you'd use the giant empty down tube as storage. (SWAT)

Maybe you need a pack a sandwich or raincoat?

If bike has storage in downtube then I would take that thing off and call it a day.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tom A.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tom A. wrote:
Andres wrote:
The thing in the back bothers me, but it looks to be removable. I think I'd be OK if it was level with the top tube such as on Trek's SC or QR's PR6, et.


But then, it might not be as effective as a "bluff body splitter", since it would be further from the "big blob" ;-)




It's still way below the body proper as-is.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
you'd probably be giving away significant aero advantage at any sort of yaw past 2-3 degrees, and that would be silly.
Last edited by: jkhayc: Oct 8, 18 7:33
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
you'd probably be giving away significant aero advantage at any sort of yaw past 2-3 degrees, and that would be silly.


:-(

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It was almost 10 years ago I had a similar idea for a fork but my head tube idea was way different. Specialized if you want the next iteration hit me up, lots of FA to be gotten rid of.

Haha
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Specialized is likely going to have some bold aero claims for this bike... and they will be plausible. That giant sail in the rear will help reattach flow behind the rider.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Actually, the fact that the claims are reasonable and within the realm of possibilities (and not outlandish) will probably inspire more confidence than if they claimed that this bike was responsible for a 13minute Hawaii Bike improvement by their top rider... Oh wait.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [RowToTri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RowToTri wrote:
You might be right. It can be hard to improve overall aerodynamics by improving viscous effects in a way that increases frontal area- but it is not unheard of.

And actually frontal area may not be that much bigger here.

Iā€™m wondering if itā€™s trying to take your legs out of the equation as much as possible. If the fork can split the airflow inside/outside your legs I could see that helping cda numbers.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
At least the paint is good.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
where did you grab these pics from??
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cookiebuilder] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The website was live last night apparently and then taken down.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cookiebuilder] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
also, if i want to take my shiny new shiv out for a sprint or olympic, i still have to use the massive hydration storage on back? or will there be different sizes avail?

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
also, if i want to take my shiny new shiv out for a sprint or olympic, i still have to use the massive hydration storage on back? or will there be different sizes avail?

Youā€™ll fit in better if you leave it on for a sprint. You never know when you could need 2L of water.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That is ugly. The front is interesting, thanking the lord I went with ARGON. The last shiv was beautiful and made sense, this is just icky.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The hydration storage is 1.5ltr.

https://bikerumor.com/...ign-massive-storage/

I ride:
Cervelo - P-Series/R3
GT - Sensor Carbon Expert

Supporters - Flo Cycling, Mount Bikes
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BayDad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Specialized claims that the resulting bike is almost a minute faster than the fastest 2011 Shiv setup possible. But compare it to the average Shiv set up (without the Fuelcell, Slammed bars, cleanest cable routing, and BTA bottle), and the new Shiv is minutes faster around the Kona course.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Grant.Reuter] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You might be onto something here, but bikerumors say Specialized says this bike is optimized for Kona crosswinds.

If that's indeed so, the fast guys can remain on P5/SC with peace in mind ;) (of course, I'm more from (even if illegal) TTer perspective)

----------------------------
Need more W/CdA.
Last edited by: mrlobber: Oct 8, 18 11:26
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
They should have just made a beam bike with fuselage storage.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
They should have just made a beam bike with fuselage storage.

Nah...beam bikes are meh....

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
And this bike looks like it got hit in the face with a shovel!

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
They should have just made a beam bike with fuselage storage.

If only someone already thought of that.



Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It took me a while to find those hidden pictures of the Shiv Disc but i cannot figure out the logic behind the youtube links that specialized gave to bike rumor.
They are called "Shiv 2" and "Shiv 3" and they are not listed (so you cannot find them on youtube when you search it).

But to my knowledge their should be around 5 Videos ( at least "Shiv 1" with the full introduction) would be there.
Is there any Einstein out there who could find those missing videos on youtube??

These are the already known videos (all posted on the 4th Oct)





Thanks in advance




Last edited by: Chris_Mint: Oct 8, 18 11:59
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Except for the fact it's a Dimond

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Gah...meant fuselage hydration...

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pro_Sandbagger] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pro_Sandbagger wrote:
Yes. However, I don't really see (and I'm no aerodyanmics expert) how having two more vertical bars (i.e. more frontal area) that the air has to wrap around will make it better. Specifically when other manufactueres are trying to reduce the number of solids that the air has to wrap around. Specialized didn't want to jump on that bandwagon and said, "we'll add more!"


Yeah, seems odd to reduce frontal area with a mono-post aerobar riser, then give it all back with that unconventional fork. But Specialized has a wind tunnel and I failed college calculus, so I'm begrudgingly willing to give them the benefit of the doubt.

"They're made of latex, not nitroglycerin"
Last edited by: gary p: Oct 8, 18 12:19
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gary p] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ok I found it.
This is the official launch video.
It seems it not to be public yet but enjoy:


Last edited by: Chris_Mint: Oct 8, 18 13:08
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
Specialized claims that the resulting bike is almost a minute faster than the fastest 2011 Shiv setup possible. But compare it to the average Shiv set up (without the Fuelcell, Slammed bars, cleanest cable routing, and BTA bottle), and the new Shiv is minutes faster around the Kona course.

That works out to ~13watts faster than the old Shiv in it's "fastest" possible configuration. If true, it's ~5 watts faster than the 2nd gen Speed Concept which would be quite impressive.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The GMAN wrote:
TheStroBro wrote:
They should have just made a beam bike with fuselage storage.

If only someone already thought of that.


This thread is about real bikes.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:

This thread is about real bikes.

HAHAHAHAHHAHAHA best comment ever about Dimond!

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
BryanD wrote:
Specialized claims that the resulting bike is almost a minute faster than the fastest 2011 Shiv setup possible. But compare it to the average Shiv set up (without the Fuelcell, Slammed bars, cleanest cable routing, and BTA bottle), and the new Shiv is minutes faster around the Kona course.


That works out to ~13watts faster than the old Shiv in it's "fastest" possible configuration. If true, it's ~5 watts faster than the 2nd gen Speed Concept which would be quite impressive.

But I donĀ“t really get it. So this is the launch edition bike which will be limited to 500 bikes and they will be delivered by March 2019. But when are the not limited non launching bikes coming? Or are they not coming and this is kind of a prototype.

Specialized is really trying to built up some pressure to make the people buying the bike before there is any test or review on it as they say it will be sold out soon. Are they afraid of people not buying it at all or that they are not buying once they saw a review :)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It's marketing! People want limited editions.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
+1 on the pure hideousness of it

"see the world as it is not as you want it to be"
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
jkhayc wrote:


This thread is about real bikes.


HAHAHAHAHHAHAHA best comment ever about Dimond!

Dimond is a much nicer bike than this. This Specialized will be slower and is competing with the Ventum for the ugliest available bicycle.

Dimond Bikes Superfan
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericlambi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ericlambi wrote:
BryanD wrote:
jkhayc wrote:


This thread is about real bikes.


HAHAHAHAHHAHAHA best comment ever about Dimond!


Dimond is a much nicer bike than this. This Specialized will be slower and is competing with the Ventum for the ugliest available bicycle.

I doubt that.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This probably isn't the one you're after, but I thought maybe worth posting.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oa5p4iJW1Q4





I wanna go fast!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericlambi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Dimond is the ugliest junk around. And yes, I have ridden one.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Last edited by: BryanD: Oct 8, 18 14:06
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
True QR got me that way. Also that color is expensive!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
Dimond is a much nicer bike than this. This Specialized will be slower and is competing with the Ventum for the ugliest available bicycle.


I doubt that.[/quote]
I don't. But in any case, when someone says "Optimized for Kona conditions", I hear "Not very fast in normal conditions". Perhaps that's unfair. I certainly am way faster on my Dimond than I was on a Speed Concept, which marketed with the same Kona-optimized gimmick.

Dimond Bikes Superfan
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
BryanD wrote:
Specialized claims that the resulting bike is almost a minute faster than the fastest 2011 Shiv setup possible. But compare it to the average Shiv set up (without the Fuelcell, Slammed bars, cleanest cable routing, and BTA bottle), and the new Shiv is minutes faster around the Kona course.

That works out to ~13watts faster than the old Shiv in it's "fastest" possible configuration. If true, it's ~5 watts faster than the 2nd gen Speed Concept which would be quite impressive.

Not sure I follow your math. If they said the Shiv Disc is ā€˜almost a minute fasterā€™ over 112 miles the watt savings is going to be much less than 13

Matt
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pun_Times] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pun_Times wrote:
GreenPlease wrote:
BryanD wrote:
Specialized claims that the resulting bike is almost a minute faster than the fastest 2011 Shiv setup possible. But compare it to the average Shiv set up (without the Fuelcell, Slammed bars, cleanest cable routing, and BTA bottle), and the new Shiv is minutes faster around the Kona course.


That works out to ~13watts faster than the old Shiv in it's "fastest" possible configuration. If true, it's ~5 watts faster than the 2nd gen Speed Concept which would be quite impressive.


Not sure I follow your math. If they said the Shiv Disc is ā€˜almost a minute fasterā€™ over 112 miles the watt savings is going to be much less than 13

Yeah...by the quick ROT of 1s/km ~= 10W, I'm getting more like 3W.

http://bikeblather.blogspot.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericlambi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ericlambi wrote:
when someone says "Optimized for Kona conditions", I hear "Not very fast in normal conditions".
Visual wind tunnel looks about right. It's basically a giant sail out the back; great lift while tacking and reaching but not great for going straight into the wind.

Would love to see hambini get his mitts on one and stick it in the "real world" wind tunnel protocol.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
IME, there were at least 13 watts to take off of a "perfectly optimized" Shiv already. Remove Specialized bars, and install TriRig or Ventus I/II. Remove the internal bladder (that tube was really big) and fish your flat kit down in there. Replace brakes with TriRig Omega SV.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
A bike optimized for Kona...?????!! I mean seriously, the number of athletes doing Kona who might consider buying this bike is what....at the very most like 100 (and more likely 25-50)....compared to the potential tri bike buying population that number is tiny. What a stupid marketing strategy.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [chicanery] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That launch video was cringeworthy. Everyone who spoke seems like an engineer and not a triathlete. The fuselage integration hydration is what had previously drawn me to Specialized, but being told everything was changing when I made my decision after being fit I went with the E119. Happier with this decision.

The foldable aerobars make sense but they also don't. They chose to go with a proprietary cockpit that will be tough to modify for all of the true aero weenies. The placement of the hydro-sale and the length of the drink tube could be an issue and unlike the previous version...will you have to take that to a shop every time you need a new one?

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I was hoping to see how they clean the hydration.

Like this is great and all but seriously, how the hell are you going to clean the tube that routes through the entire thing? Also how do you put it back in?

Also I wonder how much you lose trying to lug 1.5L of hydration and your entire buffet of fuel vs. using on course nutrition. Also wonder if you can fill that bad boy while on the go.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Aid.dre.an] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Aid.dre.an wrote:
I was hoping to see how they clean the hydration.

Like this is great and all but seriously, how the hell are you going to clean the tube that routes through the entire thing? Also how do you put it back in?

Also I wonder how much you lose trying to lug 1.5L of hydration and your entire buffet of fuel vs. using on course nutrition. Also wonder if you can fill that bad boy while on the go.

Likely two tubes, one that is removable for cleaning, the other is the guide tube.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Aid.dre.an] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Aid.dre.an wrote:
Also I wonder how much you lose trying to lug 1.5L of hydration and your entire buffet of fuel vs. using on course nutrition.


I'm curious. Are you saying that you would start an ironman with less than 1.5l of fluid and not pack all the nutrition you required? Really?
Last edited by: benb: Oct 8, 18 15:24
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [benb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
benb wrote:
Aid.dre.an wrote:
Also I wonder how much you lose trying to lug 1.5L of hydration and your entire buffet of fuel vs. using on course nutrition./quote]

I'm curious. Are you saying that you would start an ironman with less than 1.5l of fluid and not pack all the nutrition you required? Really?

Just wondering the time saved if you carry less and grab what you need as you go. I think there could be time saved by not having so much weight and potentially training with on course nutrition.

I think it's an interesting design though. I assume it's not gonna be cheap
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Ok I found it.

This is the official launch video.
It seems it not to be public yet but enjoy:



"The bike leg of a triathlon is probably the one cycling discipline where aero truly is everything."

Come on now.

(some Specialized love here).






It is hard to sit through.
Last edited by: trail: Oct 8, 18 15:24
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [chicanery] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
chicanery wrote:
IME, there were at least 13 watts to take off of a "perfectly optimized" Shiv already. Remove Specialized bars, and install TriRig or Ventus I/II. Remove the internal bladder (that tube was really big) and fish your flat kit down in there. Replace brakes with TriRig Omega SV.


This! Exactly this! The current (now "old") Shiv can be easily cleaned up even for longer 140.6 or 70.3 races.. the way it was configured from the factory was painful with cables hanging out in the wind, etc. I'd love to take my Shiv in IM config and run it against the new disc Shiv in a wind tunnel (and my frame is on the large size for me so I am already giving up some watts due to the frame being to big.) I run one bottle on the back of the set to refill the Xlab bTA aero bottle and when I am done with it I toss it... so no more aero penalty . Water is in the downtube bladder and my flat and other nutrition are in the fuelslage storage box. Nothing it hanging off the bike in the wind. Photo is from Cda70.3 but I run the same setup for a Full, just refill the xlab and bladder from the course.



______________________________________________
Team Zoot
Last edited by: gregtay: Oct 8, 18 17:29
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [benb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
benb wrote:
I'm curious. Are you saying that you would start an ironman with less than 1.5l of fluid and not pack all the nutrition you required? Really?


Is that supposed to be in pink?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gregtay] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That's a HAWT bike.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
benb wrote:

I'm curious. Are you saying that you would start an ironman with less than 1.5l of fluid and not pack all the nutrition you required? Really?



Is that supposed to be in pink?

No, not at all. 1.5l is only 2 bidons and carrying enough nutrition for 5 hours isn't hard.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Awesome for spez to give us a billboard at the back to advertise sponsors. Ad Space here call 877-808-1234
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [benb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
benb wrote:
trail wrote:
benb wrote:

I'm curious. Are you saying that you would start an ironman with less than 1.5l of fluid and not pack all the nutrition you required? Really?



Is that supposed to be in pink?


No, not at all. 1.5l is only 2 bidons and carrying enough nutrition for 5 hours isn't hard.

Maybe it isn't all that hard but on a hot race (and damn it seems like I am always choose 90+ degree hot races) I certainly like the ice cold bottle from the aid station 4 hours into the ride vs. the 90+ degree nutrition on my bike.

______________________________________________
Team Zoot
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Today is probably the launch of the new S-Works Shiv Disc 2019.
Official launch site here (eventually):

https://www.specialized.com/new-shiv
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [arkie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Looks like UPS is already bought a new Shiv and and sponsored it!

Last edited by: ZenTriBrett: Oct 8, 18 16:16
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [benb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
benb wrote:

No, not at all. 1.5l is only 2 bidons and carrying enough nutrition for 5 hours isn't hard.


Oh, I'm not arguing you could. I take all my calories in liquid since I don't like fussing around. I just have zero problem using a catered race course for liquids, which also isn't hard with a 2 bottle setup.

I don't think one way is necessarily any better. You just seemed shocked that someone would use on course nutrition or regularly grab bottles.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Aid.dre.an] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Aid.dre.an wrote:
Also wonder if you can fill that bad boy while on the go.

I would think that if that rear luggage compartment had a top similar to the fuel cell - a rubber slit, at least big enough to open to accommodate a water bottle nozzle - you could, reach back, find slit with nozzle, insert nozzle into slit, and squeeze the bottle to refill your pony keg all while still riding, no?

Amateur recreational hobbyist cyclist
https://www.strava.com/athletes/337152
https://vimeo.com/user11846099
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [benb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
benb wrote:
Aid.dre.an wrote:
Also I wonder how much you lose trying to lug 1.5L of hydration and your entire buffet of fuel vs. using on course nutrition.


I'm curious. Are you saying that you would start an ironman with less than 1.5l of fluid and not pack all the nutrition you required? Really?

Trying all the new on course gear is half the fun for me in an IM, keeps things fresh. Plus it's free!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
One minute?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [refthimos] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Think about that again for me...

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ZenTriBrett] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The new Shiv also has an ovelanding attachment for training during the off-season.
[/img][/img]
Last edited by: chadm: Oct 8, 18 16:53
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gregtay] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
your position needs more work than your shiv. looks like the shiv might be the wrong bike for you.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DFW_Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DFW_Tri wrote:
A bike optimized for Kona...?????!! I mean seriously, the number of athletes doing Kona who might consider buying this bike is what....at the very most like 100 (and more likely 25-50)....compared to the potential tri bike buying population that number is tiny. What a stupid marketing strategy.

Interestingly, many felt the same way about the P5x.

There are P5xs...everywhere.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
your position needs more work than your shiv. looks like the shiv might be the wrong bike for you.
I wouldn't disagree but I have made it work for now. But this really wasn't a "how's my fit thread", but thx.

______________________________________________
Team Zoot
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tom A.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I was trying to figure out the time difference over 40k which works out to 13 seconds. Car math. My bad.

60 seconds / 180km = .3seconds/km = 3 watts

...Speed Concept is likely faster. Iā€™ll keep my rim brake bikes.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Not really . Or was that supposed to b pink. Iā€™ve Never sent one in Person myself. And that marketing was based on all IMs not just Kona as far as i recall.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DFW_Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Not supposed to be in pink. Unsure why you haven't seen many P5xs. They are all over the place at west coast races.

Slowtwitch just doesn't get it, ultimately. They think these bikes are made for them. They aren't.

The fact that Specialized spent hundreds of thousands and millions? on researching, designing, and building a new tri bike should make everyone cream their pants while we participate in this sport that is dying, but no we as a community feel the need to nitpick the shit out of it. Stupid.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Well Iā€™m not on the west coast. I completely agree that bikes are not maser for STers, which makes the marketing of Kona racers more bizarre to me. STers, I think, do represent Kona racers fairly well they just donā€™t represent the masses very well. Thatā€™s why I think this marketing seems strange. Personally, I donā€™t find this bike nearly as offensive as others. But I also have no intention to purchase one.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DFW_Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DFW_Tri wrote:
WSTers, I think, do represent Kona racers fairly well they just donā€™t represent the masses very well. Thatā€™s why I think this marketing seems strange.

While I agree that at first glance it feels like it should. But next time that Slowman does a "Next wheel purchase poll" compare the results to the Kona bike count. Very very different numbers.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That thing is ugly! I ride a shiv and I would not ride that thing.
2 things that are dumb a collapsible front end and disk breaks.
The front end on the old shiv have 4 bolts not hard to take apart.
How are you going to refill the hydration in a race behind the seat?
I donā€™t get it!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
The fact that Specialized spent hundreds of thousands and millions? on researching, designing, and building a new tri bike should make everyone cream their pants while we participate in this sport that is dying, but no we as a community feel the need to nitpick the shit out of it. Stupid.

I'm not convinced that I should feel honoured that a company is investing in trying to sell me products for my sport.
And 13K bikes are hardly trying to remove barriers to entry to grow the sport either.
That applies to any company, not just SBC

In the case of this bike - it doesn't fit me and I don't like the complexity so I certainly won't be signing up. I do like the Klein-esque paint job though.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [cyclenutnz] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i see you twisting my message.

the fact that specialized even created a new tri bike is pretty great. i'm not gonna buy it, but i am not gonna hate it just because it's expensive and doesn't work for my use case, in theory. many of the people commenting on threads like this are short course athletes. this bike isn't for them either.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This bike is awesome. I agree with everything you said.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I think it has plenty of positive attributes. I don't hate on it at all, actually. Having spent time with those guys in that tunnel, I think they are trying to make something unique that is potentially fast.

My only complaint would be cleaning the bottle/tube and I wish those bars with the pivot didn't seem like such an aero compromise.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [MikeAG] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You are probably right. This is more just my gut based upon nothing more. Regardless, I have long said that STers do not represent the average consumer.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The mono stem doesnā€™t appear to have any tilt, but maybe theyā€™ll have angled risers?

Iā€™m curious to see if Lucy Charles will be able to hit her same mantis position on this bike.

Alex Arman

Strava
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
i see you twisting my message.

the fact that specialized even created a new tri bike is pretty great. i'm not gonna buy it, but i am not gonna hate it just because it's expensive and doesn't work for my use case, in theory. many of the people commenting on threads like this are short course athletes. this bike isn't for them either.

yeah, love that we are seeing companies big and small coming up with innovative new designs for our sport. i won't be buying one but i am happy that they have released it.

this new shiv is like the P5X in that it is not trying so much to be faster (we are in the age of peak aero) as more out of the box optimised so that the mass market consumer (ie the large numbers you need to attract to make a profit) can have a fast setup walking out the shop door rather than spending half their life testing and optimising like some here do.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [doublea334] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
doublea334 wrote:
The mono stem doesnā€™t appear to have any tilt, but maybe theyā€™ll have angled risers?

Iā€™m curious to see if Lucy Charles will be able to hit her same mantis position on this bike.

Iā€™m 90% sure it has tilt. It was specā€™d on the EU site as having 15 degrees of tilt adjustment.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Agreed x2..Not a huge Specialized fan but...how can people here say itā€™s ā€œslowā€...they have their own wind tunnel..R&D Iā€™m sure is a thorough process there..the people here amaze me..
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mike s] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The people here are probably not as fast as they claim to be. They think every bike has to be designed for them. Itā€™s a joke. The bike is amazing and better than a P5-X. It has everything you need and does it better than any other bike Iā€™ve seen. I canā€™t wait to see one of these in person.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I was curious to see what it looks like without the sail...



______________________________________________
Team Zoot
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Im sure they have different sized rear water storage, how will it be for small inseam riders.
For aesthetics id prefer that the rear water tank is in line with the top tube, but that defeats the 1.5ltr capacity.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [campled] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
campled wrote:
Im sure they have different sized rear water storage, how will it be for small inseam riders.
For aesthetics id prefer that the rear water tank is in line with the top tube, but that defeats the 1.5ltr capacity.

Agree... I am sure they will have a few different boxes that can go back there.... and agree aligning with the top tube certainly looks a bit more normal.



______________________________________________
Team Zoot
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gregtay] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
gregtay wrote:
agree aligning with the top tube certainly looks a bit more normal.
Some frame A/B comparisons
here (via Juxtapose link, as apparently we don't do iframes.)



Last edited by: uucee: Oct 8, 18 20:58
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gregtay] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
gregtay wrote:
campled wrote:
Im sure they have different sized rear water storage, how will it be for small inseam riders.
For aesthetics id prefer that the rear water tank is in line with the top tube, but that defeats the 1.5ltr capacity.


Agree... I am sure they will have a few different boxes that can go back there.... and agree aligning with the top tube certainly looks a bit more normal.

That bottle reminds me of the Ventum idea only they shoved it behind the seat tube instead of in front on the top tube. Without it, that is a huge non-aero space between the tail of the seat tube & lead edge of the rear wheel. Wow, until it run through the rigors of trials I best just clam it up and not judge--so...it is an interesting design for sure. We will have to wait for Pubes to pull this one into the tunnel for more testing with some new models.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Rocky M] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Looking forward to my new Shiv arriving in April
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
Not supposed to be in pink. Unsure why you haven't seen many P5xs. They are all over the place at west coast races.

Slowtwitch just doesn't get it, ultimately. They think these bikes are made for them. They aren't.

The fact that Specialized spent hundreds of thousands and millions? on researching, designing, and building a new tri bike should make everyone cream their pants while we participate in this sport that is dying, but no we as a community feel the need to nitpick the shit out of it. Stupid.


I see P5xs all the time in Arizona. When I rode through Usery pass there was a couple who rode their every Saturday like clockwork..

The Pathetic Triathletes seems to think it's uglier than a fat girl hit by a shovel.

BryanD wrote:
The people here are probably not as fast as they claim to be. They think every bike has to be designed for them. Itā€™s a joke. The bike is amazing and better than a P5-X. It has everything you need and does it better than any other bike Iā€™ve seen. I canā€™t wait to see one of these in person.

How much are you getting paid to blow that smoke up our butts?

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Last edited by: TheStroBro: Oct 8, 18 21:52
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
For the 100th time on here, I donā€™t get paid by brands. I give my opinions.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericlambi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ericlambi wrote:
BryanD wrote:
jkhayc wrote:


This thread is about real bikes.


HAHAHAHAHHAHAHA best comment ever about Dimond!

Dimond is a much nicer bike than this. This Specialized will be slower and is competing with the Ventum for the ugliest available bicycle.

I would bet my 401k the new shiv is faster.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Badger2501] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
https://www.specialized.com/us/en/new-shiv

Launched.

Interesting that they dummy proofed their fit app. They have you measure from a wall and the floor and give those measurements. I don't know those measurements.... I just know pad x and y. Wish I could just give those measurements into the app. Also... why does specialized list the reach and stack to the fork? Cervelo does the same thing. There's no need to show it (pad x and y are what matters) on a bike with an oem proprietary front end.

Still curious to see how the straw/hose is routed.

So you store your flat kit underneath the fuel cell in the downtube? Is there a separate compartment for the flat kit? How much room is there (enough for 2 tubes, 2 co2's, multi tool?)?? How does the fuel cell mount/fasten? Can it be removed quickly to change a flat?

blog
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DFW_Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DFW_Tri wrote:
A bike optimized for Kona...?????!! I mean seriously, the number of athletes doing Kona who might consider buying this bike is what....at the very most like 100 (and more likely 25-50)....compared to the potential tri bike buying population that number is tiny. What a stupid marketing strategy.

Very true kona and Galveston are the windest races I have raced, most course donā€™t compare.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [stevej] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Just throw it all in and pray you can find it when needed!

The straw routing will be interesting to see, seems like it could be problematic.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [stevej] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So, it's spec'ed with 24c Turbo Cotton tires. Fast rollers, but not terribly aero. I'm a little surprised they didn't come up with a new tire for this.

"They're made of latex, not nitroglycerin"
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gary p] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
LOLOLOLOL

Have you not seen the Tom A. tire data?

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 
found this on FB

Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [culpritbicycles] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thatā€™s a lot of m&mā€™s. Where is the spare tubes and co2ā€™s going?

Looks like a much lower bike then past shiv, which is nice.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
LOLOLOLOL

Have you not seen the Tom A. tire data?


Yes, I've seen Tom A's data. Its a fast roller (i.e. low .crr) But the aero sucks at higher yaw angles, which is what this frame is supposed to do best. As far as I understand, Tom runs Turbo Cottons on just about everything..... other than a TT bike.


This was a golden opportunity to launch a new TT tire that had something close to the Turbo Cotton .crr, but also had the right shape to compliment all the aero work that went into this frame and those Roval CLX 64's. It would also be something they could sell now to those of us who couldn't consider this bike until the more moderately priced derivatives come to market 2-3 years down the road.

"They're made of latex, not nitroglycerin"
Last edited by: gary p: Oct 9, 18 6:36
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This looks a "dummy" bike. An aero bike from 1993. Brutal. It'll be weird when everyone is buying LG bikes next year.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Interesting placement of the torpedo but shows tilt.



Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I just saw that it will be as expected 14k USD (and hopefully 12k ā‚¬) for the bike incl. the baike bag.
YouĀ“ll have to pay 1k to your dealer already as a reservation and the other 13k in March 2019 when you pick it up.

I absolutely need a new bike but all I was asking for was something like a P5-6 with disc brakes and a integrated handlebar, hydrtion and bento box like the Speedmax CF SLX.
But I donĀ“t get why everyone is trying to invent the bike from scratch now. I am not totally against the design of the new Shiv but seriously? A complete new and weird design for less than 60sec on a 5h bike ride?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lucy Charles
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [culpritbicycles] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
culpritbicycles wrote:

found this on FB

Based on this image that rear hydration is going to be a PIA in real life. That is a super long straw and unless its 100% the reservoir is substantially higher that the mouth piece. That means there will be a lot of liquid pooling in the tubes just waiting to get real gross. Even if it is removal for cleaning getting the gunk out of a tube that long is not going to be easy.

I would also be concerned about constantly removing a tube in that region unless I am using SRAM etap. The cable housing presumably runs in that region and its surprising easy to get the internal cable guides in a tangled mess if you have to force the new cables through them. Specialised already made this mistake with the Transition which due to a similar cable arrangement allows the internal guides to twist around each other when you trying and install new cables.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If a monopost is better than a traditional aerobar, why is a triple headtube better than a traditional one?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [scott8888] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thought I might prefer it without the pizza box on the back... Still not sure...
Also wonder who their sacrificial lamb will be to blaze up the beginning of the bike course for TV time.

Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [nchristi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The monopost design is required to clean up the straw exit for the hydration system. The way the straw wiggles via the frame to the fork/bars means it will kill the handling unless it goes centrally. You need the whole front end to pivot around the straw rather than flex the straw. This also requires a beefy monopost as it need a big void for the straw. My instinct is Once you have designed for the straw adding additional struts only slows things down.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [scott8888] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
JackL wrote:
I'm sorry, but the hydration rear sail is hideous.

Ohio_Roadie wrote:
That luggage in the back also looks like a late addition or after thought.
This... without the "I'm sorry".

DFW_Tri wrote:
A bike optimized for Kona...?????!! I mean seriously, the number of athletes doing Kona who might consider buying this bike is what....at the very most like 100 (and more likely 25-50)....compared to the potential tri bike buying population that number is tiny. What a stupid marketing strategy.
It's the new version of the "fast around the Nurburgring" idiocy.

scott8888 wrote:
culpritbicycles wrote:

found this on FB
http://i64.tinypic.com/2lm4gmr.jpg

Based on this image that rear hydration is going to be a PIA in real life.
Yup. Better start devising a high pressure contraption and stocking on hypochlorite to clean that mess up. I doubt regular 50ml syringes will cut it.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [culpritbicycles] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
They need to make an ice luge version of this for their Kona party

Chasing PB Podcast Latest interview with Eli Hemming on Targeting a US MTR spot in Tokyo
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
For the 100th time on here, I donā€™t get paid by brands. I give my opinions.
how can you have an opinion if you have not used the bike and have not seen tests.
what you have is emotions that you prefer the look of the shiv


i like what they did but i just dont think no bike is worth the price tag .
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [nchristi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
In a traditional design, the fork crown is a tough Aero challenge. It's tilted according to the the head tube angle, flat and wide to merge into the legs. Usually, the frame down tube is widened to streamline the fork. It works -but the leading edge is still bad.

This design moves the fork crown upwards above the headset - tilts the 'crown' horizontal, parallel to the airflow. The large shoulders are a trade-off but at least they can be streamlined, whereas a traditional fork crown cannot. The Wilier twinblade still had a crown.

Personally, I like how this cockpit pushes the boundaries!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [scott8888] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The routing doesnā€™t look too bad. Similar to a front derailleur.

https://imgur.com/gallery/3Rduodf
Last edited by: kart17: Oct 9, 18 3:54
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
despite James's and Bryan's off-putting comments, this bike is growing on me.

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

ā€œYou are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.ā€
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Thorax] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Might have to borrow a book from the beer homebrew crowd and pressure-blow some StarSan or other food-grade sanitizer through the pipes.

ZONE3 - We Last Longer
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericMPro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ericMPro wrote:
despite James's and Bryan's off-putting comments, this bike is growing on me.

Yeah I also came from "FUGLY" -> "Maybe not too bad -> back to "mehh..."
Because I thought it might be not too bad if you get rid of the sail (a gigantic sail that just saves you about 28sec on a 5h ride... tssss...) and also those cheap wheelset.
But than I realized that I would need to pay 14k for a bike where I would need to throw the wheels, the crank and the hydration system.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You remember the old one was painfully slow in comparison to every other tri specific bike in a wind tunnel test. According to spesh, this one in comparison to "the fastest race set up of our previous shiv" is 1min faster over an ironman. That's right...the new model (cost $13k) will save you 5.33 seconds per 10mile tt over a bike that's already proven to be slow anyway (which it is illegal for) - it is taking the term marginal gains to a whole new level. I was not a fan of the original Shiv, this one just makes no sense. Obviously people will buy it because Spesh tell them to but it cant be for performance reasons.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [piertown] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
piertown wrote:
Lucy Charles

Not a very good advertisement for your bike when you have an integrated hydration system and then she's sticking a bottle in her rear jersey pocket. That's one downside of the downtube storage, you can't put a water bottle there. I'd never race with a bottle on the downtube but it's a handy option for training. I do like having a hidden compartment in the DT for tube, CO2, etc. As long as the nutrition compartment is easy to pop out, not an issue. Just have a bag in there you can quickly grab, and to keep it from rattling around.

The tube routing doesn't look so bad, don't think it will be a problem. Although cleaning it when using sports drink... would like to know how they're handling that. And how are people so sure they have more than one size of the hydration compartment available, haven't seen anything about that yet? I sure hope no one tries to refill the rear hydration on the fly, yikes, I hope that was a joke. Folks wandering all over the course while they refill their front hydration is bad enough.

I sure hope that funky fork has an aero advantage as otherwise if they went to all that trouble just to get good routing for the tube, that's a big hmmmm. All so you don't have to do a bottle swap every hour or two? And it's so easy to drink out of a BTA bottle while staying in aero, don't get all this Rube Goldberg hydration stuff that so many triathletes are running.

I like the out of the box innovation on this bike but if they only got one minute in 112 miles over the old Shiv... that's not very encouraging.

I could care less about aesthetics but the price, well, that is pretty ugly.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [tttiltheend] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
the seat tube has a bottle mount.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericMPro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ericMPro wrote:
despite James's and Bryan's off-putting comments, this bike is growing on me.

excuse me? which of my comments have been "off putting" to you?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [doublea334] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The Hoff's shiv. You can see angled risers.


Could be Tim Don's but not sure.


2019 T-Rex Tri Series
Last edited by: mknight84: Oct 9, 18 5:26
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Any idea how log the pros would have had the new bike,wondering how much riding they would have done on them
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericMPro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ericMPro wrote:
despite James's and Bryan's off-putting comments, this bike is growing on me.

I want the clear version full of M&Ms. But, not just the one compartment - I want it completely filled, with a turn dispenser thingy in the BB.

Travis Rassat
Vector Cycle Works
Noblesville, IN
BikeFit Instructor | FMS | F.I.S.T. | IBFI
Toughman Triathlon Series Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mknight84] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So it still doesnā€™t look like tilt is available on the cockpit.

Hoff, Charles, and Don all have steeply bent extensions that exit the clamp straight, then rise up. Then, they have angled wedges under the arm rests that independently angle those up.

Alex Arman

Strava
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [piertown] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
since santa cruz 70.3
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [tttiltheend] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
so $14k. holy. CRAP.

im interested in this custom case they are selling with it.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
There are P5xs...everywhere.

Everywhere in Kona?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
so $14k. holy. CRAP.

im interested in this custom case they are selling with it.


They seem to have copied Cervelo. Lots of storage, foldable bar, custom case, mono-post, $14K.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
That is ugly. The front is interesting, thanking the lord I went with ARGON. The last shiv was beautiful and made sense, this is just icky.

Amen to that. So glad I got the previous model now that I'm seeing this. Unless this is somehow going to shave minutes off my time over the last design.....
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [JLars] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hmm. Not a fan of the aesthetics. But more interested in the #ā€™s of the tests and the true speed as I would set it up. What is the purpose of widening the front forks? Also, is that rear hydration sail thing there really for hydration or does it serve significant purpose of increasing overall aero of the bike? If itā€™s there for aero functions Iā€™m good with that. Iā€™m not a fan of big hydration reservoirs on bikes. I carry both sports drink and water on long rides and races and I canā€™t mix those in a reservoir like that. So I still have to carry multiple bottles. So whatā€™s the point... ha- possibly that big tank could reduce the need for a bike special needs bag if we could stuff everything in it! Iā€™m not a fan of the aesthetics but awaiting to see the aero test #ā€™s and the weight of the bike in a normal triathletes setup..
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
despite James's and Bryan's off-putting comments, this bike is growing on me.


excuse me? which of my comments have been "off putting" to you?


I was wondering the same thing? Can people not be excited about a bike? Or can you only be excited about Slowtwitch approved bike?

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Last edited by: BryanD: Oct 9, 18 7:34
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Drummon] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Drummon wrote:
Hmm. Not a fan of the aesthetics. But more interested in the #ā€™s of the tests and the true speed as I would set it up. What is the purpose of widening the front forks? Also, is that rear hydration sail thing there really for hydration or does it serve significant purpose of increasing overall aero of the bike? If itā€™s there for aero functions Iā€™m good with that.


As per the video, the fork design was chosen for greatest sail effect in crosswinds. And the reservoir was clearly an aero appendage first that was later adapted to carry water. The video mentions that they opted to put water there when it was determined the space was too thin/deep to be of use as any other sort of storage, indicating that it was there before for they knew what they were going to do with the space inside. With that small seat post and all the gap between the seat tube and rear wheel, there has to be a big aerodynamic penalty for running without it. .

"They're made of latex, not nitroglycerin"
Last edited by: gary p: Oct 9, 18 7:48
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
When you launch this, there's no excitement. Aesthetically it's uglier than a rabid squirrel. The aero numbers are whatever since most people are purchasing bikes for aesthetics, which is also why companies are shifting to custom paint jobs that you can order out of the box instead of being stuck with whatever stock crap they got or spending another k to get a vinyal wrap so that you don't screw the warranty.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [cyclenutnz] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
With the cockpit adjustability the frame can fall inline.

As for the hydration, #aeroiseverything.

SD

https://www.kickstarter.com/...bike-for-the-new-era
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andres] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Andres wrote:
milesthedog wrote:
pretty sure the rear container is for 2L of fluids

Whatever it is, not into it.

Looks like a few ideas cobbled together.

Last Shiv had a flow to it.

The tank at the back looks awful
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [cowboy7] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I like it.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I heard that rear storage is called the Specialized BedonkaBox Ā®
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mknight84] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
They mention in the video six athletes already have the bike and will be on it in Kona. Iā€™m guessing:
- Javier Gomez
- Ben Hoffman (not racing, though I bet the video was shot prior to his announcement)
- Tim Don
- Lucy Charles

Who am I missing. The Prince of Bahrain???

Matt
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pun_Times] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sarah True
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pun_Times] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
And Braden Currie

DFRU - Detta Family Racing Unit...the kids like it and we all get out and after it...gotta keep the fam involved!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mknight84] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mknight84 wrote:
The Hoff's shiv. You can see angled risers.

And the Transition's "Virtue" aero bottle lives on!! :-)

http://bikeblather.blogspot.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericMPro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TBH, it looks alot better without the huge pitcher in the back. But, that foil most likely makes it more aero.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
jkhayc wrote:

There are P5xs...everywhere.


Everywhere in Kona?

I'm not in Kona, but I have seen way more P5x's at races this past year and a half than I would have expected. At Oceanside in 2017 there were maybe 1-3 total. At Oceanside 2018 there were noticeably more. Same has been true at St. George, CdA, Santa Rosa.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It might be very fast, but it is surely ridiculous looking.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
When you launch this, there's no excitement. Aesthetically it's uglier than a rabid squirrel. The aero numbers are whatever since most people are purchasing bikes for aesthetics, which is also why companies are shifting to custom paint jobs that you can order out of the box instead of being stuck with whatever stock crap they got or spending another k to get a vinyal wrap so that you don't screw the warranty.

I would tend to agree, particularly since aero gains from one generation to the next are nowhere near as significant as they used to be. And they are often now focusing on certain situational gains (crosswinds, for example) as opposed to all-around gains since things have already become so optimized.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Travis R] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Travis R wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
despite James's and Bryan's off-putting comments, this bike is growing on me.


I want the clear version full of M&Ms. But, not just the one compartment - I want it completely filled, with a turn dispenser thingy in the BB.

Small pump in the bottom bracket connecting the rear hydration through the m&m's to the mouthpiece & bingo, no more energy wasted sucking on a tube.

An all in one hydration & nutrition system for sailing through the bike course.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [SteveM] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SteveM wrote:
Travis R wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
despite James's and Bryan's off-putting comments, this bike is growing on me.


I want the clear version full of M&Ms. But, not just the one compartment - I want it completely filled, with a turn dispenser thingy in the BB.


Small pump in the bottom bracket connecting the rear hydration through the m&m's to the mouthpiece & bingo, no more energy wasted sucking on a tube.

An all in one hydration & nutrition system for sailing through the bike course.

I'd rather see a coffee maker module in the downtube fuelselage that the water reservoir feeds. It would be awesome on early morning training rides to be able to drink fresh-brewed coffee through the straw without ever having to leave the aero position.

"They're made of latex, not nitroglycerin"
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tom A.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 
Hello

first post on Slowtwich for me. Sorry for the english, I'm french...

1 minute of aero gain over an Ironman : based on my beloved calculator, carefully calibrated through hours of ride on the track and road, 1mn over 180km around pro speed (40 km/h) equal : 2,1 w
i.e. 1,2 watt for me (around 33km/h)
i.e. 21 g of drag at 30mph (to compare to several studies like "Tri bikes at the age of peak aero", ...)
i.e. I will get twice or three time this saving replacing my good old ultregra pulley wheels with a nice 16 or 17 teeth OSPW from Cycling Ceramic or Ceramic Speed or whoever,,, just for comparing.

Please note this is nearly the margin error in an aero test.

Please note also we do not know which yaw repartition for this result (to my (lack of) knowledge)

Remark 1 : how can a big brand with big R&D can arrive to such a small result, reworking completely the bike ?
My view is that it is coming from the negative impact of disk brakes on aero.
Disk brake have such shitty aero that reworking the rest of the bike with radical new solution barely compensate ?
I'm curious to see the results of future Cervelo P5 (or P3) Rim vs Disk aero drag, based on various yaw. It will give us some real comparison figures.

Remark 2 : disk brakes is a clear trend (forced, but real), so brands need (want) to go there. For aero bikes, such as Tri bikes, it is still to be proven it is a good point for users. And this point appear to be difficult to prove. This bike is an exemple. Releasing a new 10/14kā‚¬/USD bike with no aero gain (thanks to margin error) based on unknown (but certainly oriented) yaw, is certainly not what Specialized expected...
Their previous bike already not an aero rocket... this one possibly worse (with not favorable yaw) ?
These products managers are not in a good situation...

Remark 3 : I love disk brakes, when going downhill for hundreds or thousands of meters of D- in Pyrenees or Alps... Much safer, much stronger. Especially with rain. But probably in a flat tri it will bring me nothing. Except drag ?
I'm ready to go disk, for safety reasons in downhill, under rain, but given the price to change one road and one TT/Tri bike (one with basic/training wheel, the other with 55mm aero wheels, frequently swapped depending on usage), I guess I will wait 1, 2 or 3 years in order to let the offer stabilize, then go to mid price models (such as P3 Disk, S3 Disk, or Trek, Spe, Canyon, Argon... equivalent).
Probably no or little aero gain (compared to my existing P3 2014), but safer.

No doubt early adopters and less price-sensitive peoples will go sooner for these disk equipped babies. Aero gains are ... ahem.... not guaranteed ?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
No one has mentioned the obvious - peeing while on the bike could result in your urine making its way into the hydration tank.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [CycleLogical] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
No.

It's a bladder system with a straw. The bladder fits into the draft box. It's not an open tank.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
No.

It's a bladder system with a straw. The bladder fits into the draft box. It's not an open tank.

Similar to Camelbak then - you have to remove the cover then open the bladder? Doesn't seem all that useful for long course racing.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [CycleLogical] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How is it not useful? You get 2 bottles of water in a bladder. Then, you have a BTA up front and a bottle behind the saddle if you need. That's 4 bottles of water. The bladder gets you through half of an Ironman course.

You guys are missing the bigger picture.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
How is it not useful? You get 2 bottles of water in a bladder. Then, you have a BTA up front and a bottle behind the saddle if you need. That's 4 bottles of water. The bladder gets you through half of an Ironman course.

You guys are missing the bigger picture.

I was just thinking of that. The BTA is a must, especially one you can swap out or refill. I suppose the question is if you set the bike up with sufficient hydration and food how does it effect the aerodynamics? That's a question I also have for some of these really wild designs like the Ceepo Phantom, the frame might be super fast but once you strap bottles and bags all over it then what?

-Of course it's 'effing hard, it's IRONMAN!
Team ZOOT
ZOOT, QR, Garmin, HED Wheels, Zealios, FormSwim, Precision Hydration, Rudy Project
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Bryancd] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Bryancd wrote:


I was just thinking of that. The BTA is a must, especially one you can swap out or refill. I suppose the question is if you set the bike up with sufficient hydration and food how does it effect the aerodynamics? That's a question I also have for some of these really wild designs like the Ceepo Phantom, the frame might be super fast but once you strap bottles and bags all over it then what?


Bikes are coming out that are fully integrated and allow you to carry everything you need for an Ironman, and it's not good enough. With the new Shiv, everything is hidden in the frame. What more can you ask for?

Bicycle only drag charts are meaningless because they aren't testing with storage and bottles. Pure frame drag doesn't mean anything once bottles get put on, bentos are attached, and flat kits are placed somewhere.

But you know....people argue all day long about the aerodynamics of a 23 mm or 24mm tire but won't even give a bike the time of day that has everything thought of.

It's hilarious to watch.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Last edited by: BryanD: Oct 9, 18 11:24
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pyrenean Wolf wrote:

Hello

first post on Slowtwich for me. Sorry for the english, I'm french...

1 minute of aero gain over an Ironman : based on my beloved calculator, carefully calibrated through hours of ride on the track and road, 1mn over 180km around pro speed (40 km/h) equal : 2,1 w
i.e. 1,2 watt for me (around 33km/h)
i.e. 21 g of drag at 30mph (to compare to several studies like "Tri bikes at the age of peak aero", ...)
i.e. I will get twice or three time this saving replacing my good old ultregra pulley wheels with a nice 16 or 17 teeth OSPW from Cycling Ceramic or Ceramic Speed or whoever,,, just for comparing.


Remark 1 : how can a big brand with big R&D can arrive to such a small result, reworking completely the bike ?

I'm only replying to a portion of your post but I agree with your points, and this is similar to what I was commenting on earlier. The aero gains manufacturers are making these days are so so minimal because bikes have already been optimized so far. Specialized must recognize this too, despite all the work I am sure they have put into the design.

All that said, whether they acknowledge it or not, I appreciate that they seems to be giving us honest numbers on time savings, etc. I am sure they also wanted to release a bike that saved people so much they *had* to go get it, but there's only so much more they can do....
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey All,

I am here to answer some questions about the bike.
  1. The hydration system does come in multiple sizes - There are currently 4 sizes based on the change in top tube height that help put the Fuelcell within the expected saddle adjustment ranges. The system can also be cut-to-fit for a rider that has a unique morphology.
  2. The frame has a permanently installed conduit within the frame that makes bladder removal very easy. You can push or pull the bladder system out with 1-hand. The permanent conduit makes sure you arent battling debris, tools, cabling, etc...while performing this process.

    • The photo of the clear frame is not the production system - It is a mockup - The way it was made does not allow for the internal conduit and production lid system, etc...
  3. The rear reservoir is removeable! It is only 2 bolts and it comes off. Of course this feature is a big aero benefit at yaw, so removing it is not recommended but its the riders choice.
  4. BTA, TT and ST mounting points are provided for flexibility in mounting additional storage/nutrition
  5. The front nosecone is removable to allow access to all of the cabling and hydration straw for further ease of use

Come by the SHIV Launch display next to Ceramic Speed by Huggos this week to check it out in person!


Last edited by: GatorRacer: Oct 9, 18 11:43
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That is amazing! Thanks for posting.



Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Mugen_EP] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
Interesting placement of the torpedo but shows tilt.

That's not a hydration system, he's running a catheter that allows him to pee without ruining the paint job on his bike.

I'm closer to the feathered end of the spear than the point.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [chadm] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
For those that want to test ride it, it's now an available bike on Zwift.

Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
As I said in the other thread about the new Shiv, I like the bike and I believe that Specialized will sell them as quickly as they choose to produce them. The old Shiv was "ugly" when it came out according to the masses but they sure sold a lot of them.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
trail wrote:
jkhayc wrote:

There are P5xs...everywhere.


Everywhere in Kona?


I'm not in Kona, but I have seen way more P5x's at races this past year and a half than I would have expected. At Oceanside in 2017 there were maybe 1-3 total. At Oceanside 2018 there were noticeably more. Same has been true at St. George, CdA, Santa Rosa.

I don't know. I live in San Diego, and regularly train on Fiesta Island, which is a common stomping ground for tri bikes. I've seen one. Compared to tons and tons of IAs, P5s, NP3s, Shivs, Speed Concepts, etc.

I could see there maybe being a higher concentration at bigger WTC races vs. "in the wild" as I imagine a good portion of the P5x crowd may not use the bike as their daily driver.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [arby] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowtwitch alone has 20,000 views and over 500 post about the new Shiv between three post. Along with all their athletes posting today, I also think they will have no problem selling all they make.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
Hey All,

I am here to answer some questions about the bike.
  1. The hydration system does come in multiple sizes - There are currently 4 sizes based on the change in top tube height that help put the Fuelcell within the expected saddle adjustment ranges. The system can also be cut-to-fit for a rider that has a unique morphology.
  2. The frame has a permanently installed conduit within the frame that makes bladder removal very easy. You can push or pull the bladder system out with 1-hand. The permanent conduit makes sure you arent battling debris, tools, cabling, etc...while performing this process.

    • The photo of the clear frame is not the production system - It is a mockup - The way it was made does not allow for the internal conduit and production lid system, etc...
  3. The rear reservoir is removeable! It is only 2 bolts and it comes off. Of course this feature is a big aero benefit at yaw, so removing it is not recommended but its the riders choice.
  4. BTA, TT and ST mounting points are provided for flexibility in mounting additional storage/nutrition
  5. The front nosecone is removable to allow access to all of the cabling and hydration straw for further ease of use

Come by the SHIV Launch display next to Ceramic Speed by Huggos this week to check it out in person!

1. Is it possible to fit anything else in the hydration system for trainings or is there any other box that fits tyres, CO2 etc. which could be mounted behind the seat post?
2. The limited edition will be shipped in March but is there also a standard version coming out next year (hopefully only as frame set)?
3. Is it true that this is more or less a prototype limited to 500pc and it depends if they sell well or not weather there will be a 2nd series of it or not?
4. Its said that the design is specifically for Kona. Does that mean that the benefits of the bike are below the margin when comes to other races?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Here is my quick review video.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [talbotcox] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Nice vid. Better than all the Specialized one at showing all the features. Just like the P5x it does seem very well thought out in terms of adjustment, storage, and travel.

That said, only a minute faster than an optimized old Shiv isnā€™t much given that the old Shiv always seemed to be a ways back in all the other manufacturers drag charts. Thereā€™s the argument that adding bottle and nutrition to the frame will slow a bike down, but thatā€™s not necessarily the case. Well placed items can often be drag neutral and in some cases (such as a BTA bottle) can lower the drag. Not having to slow down at aid stations would be nice. But that happens twice in an Ironman? And not at all in a half or shorter.

That said, Iā€™m sure Iā€™ll be riding by a few of these at WTC races next season

Matt
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [talbotcox] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Well, Sarah is a lot better at selling an ugly bike than the folks at Specialized.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pun_Times] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pun_Times wrote:
That said, only a minute faster than an optimized old Shiv isnā€™t much given that the old Shiv always seemed to be a ways back in all the other manufacturers drag charts.
This. And it's still fugly, expensive and still a hard NO.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
When you say the fuel cell can be cut to fit based on rider morphology, does this mean it could be custom fit to any height even if itā€™s not one of the 4 standard sizes. For example, if the rider wanted to cut it to be in line and level with the top tube then this is possible?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
Hey All,

I am here to answer some questions about the bike.
  1. The hydration system does come in multiple sizes - There are currently 4 sizes based on the change in top tube height that help put the Fuelcell within the expected saddle adjustment ranges. The system can also be cut-to-fit for a rider that has a unique morphology.
  2. The frame has a permanently installed conduit within the frame that makes bladder removal very easy. You can push or pull the bladder system out with 1-hand. The permanent conduit makes sure you arent battling debris, tools, cabling, etc...while performing this process.

    • The photo of the clear frame is not the production system - It is a mockup - The way it was made does not allow for the internal conduit and production lid system, etc...
  3. The rear reservoir is removeable! It is only 2 bolts and it comes off. Of course this feature is a big aero benefit at yaw, so removing it is not recommended but its the riders choice.
  4. BTA, TT and ST mounting points are provided for flexibility in mounting additional storage/nutrition
  5. The front nosecone is removable to allow access to all of the cabling and hydration straw for further ease of use

Come by the SHIV Launch display next to Ceramic Speed by Huggos this week to check it out in person!

Thanks for all the info!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Excellent analysis Wolf.

Also, It would be great to have a reference how much faster is this new Shiv compared to the new generation of Aero Road bike like the new Venge or S5 Disc. I know it's going to be compare apples to oranges as they have different geometry and applications however as a consumer and amateur cyclist and triathlete I'm not planning to get the new generation bikes with disc brakes that are rated USD+10k each and if we are talking about the same marginal gains between the new Shiv and Venge (2, 3watts) I would just get the new Aero road bike.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
On the shiv's unique aero features:

The splitter in the back will have some benefits at yaw as mentioned, but also at 0 yaw only from the fact it's cleanly splitting the vortices from the thighs as well as potentially providing some flow reattachment through certain areas of the pedalling cycle. Gains will be greater the narrower your net stance is. Any word on the q-factor?

The fork is a very interesting piece. At 0 yaw there is a benefit from distancing the blades and crown from the wheel due to flow velocity in that area. The blades and nose cone area is a strange looking spot from an interference drag perspective. When you have openings, flow going through them usually increases with speed, compressing until it chokes and a stagnation bubble forms. What happens then is the rest of the fluid goes around that virtual sheild. Not sure at which speed that might happen on the shiv, but it's been designed to acheive that, otherwise we wouldn't have that nose cone shaped this way.

Bikes do not ride themselves so the fact this fork arrangement creates a larger front end is inconsequential to frontal area when you put a rider on the bike, due to the legs. It changes the Cd and that is the interesting part. If you could break it down, you would see the legs are a really important source of drag as a percentage of CdA. And you can't really bend or incline them with the same flexibility as the torso, head and arms to tune for drag (except riding knees in). The wake generated by the fork has an impact on the legs inbound flow, which can have an impact on leg drag. Solving this as a fork-leg-rear wheel/splitter system can lead to lower drag overall. Basically, you use the fork to engineer the flow hitting the leg so you can more efficiently manage the flow that leaves it.

Can't wait to see WT reports on this. I bet drag for the bike alone will be higher than usual at low yaw angles, but that's pointless. Drag with a rider on will be competitive at 0 yaw with a P5(x) and will beat it at >15Ā°.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
No.

It's a bladder system with a straw. The bladder fits into the draft box. It's not an open tank.
Based on the video below it's not a bladder and you could well get piss in there if the top of the tank isn't sealed...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Oh how wrong you are. Let me upload a photo

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm just going on the Talbot video and Sarah said she can fill it on the fly. Explain that?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Shambolic wrote:
I'm just going on the Talbot video and Sarah said she can fill it on the fly. Explain that?

You can fill it THROUGH a fly. So, ya know, pee into it....

Alex Arman

Strava
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
She pretty much described how to fill it on the fly and according to her, you just remove the top and squirt away. Plus, the opening seems awfully narrow to try to squeeze a filled bladder through.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply


Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lol really? I suggest you read back through the thread about that picture...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You can see the bladder in the video. You don't fill up the box.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Explain the Sarah True video showing off her bike explaining she can flip the top off and fill it on the fly?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Explain the plastic bladder you can so easily see in that box.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
At 1:53 in the video, you can clearly see a plastic bladder. You will not be refilling this on the fly. No one could do that while riding. It's a bladder that holds 2 bottles of fluid with a straw.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Runorama] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Runorama wrote:
Any word on the q-factor?

I'd imagine it's the OSBB BB, unless they decide to break their recent trend with this bike.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jamlo] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If it has a bladder you couldn't fill on the fly. If it had an plastic removable lining with an open top you potentially could fill it. Certainly would be hard to fill on the fly regardless...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What do you think this is? It's a plastic bladder



Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Very conclusive picture...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Seriously? The origins of the clear frame was well understood. Do you honestly think Specilaized wouldnā€™t show a bladder on their instagram if there wasnā€™t one? Keep in mind they have a patent on a bladder hydration system.

I donā€™t understand why this is so difficult....

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Why would you put a bladder there if you already have a tank. You need a bladder in a frame. I'm sure Sarah would know how to fill her hydration?

I don't understand why this is so difficult...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Iā€™ll call Specialized on your behalf

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gregtay] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
gregtay wrote:
I was curious to see what it looks like without the sail...
loose the disc brakes, and I'd race that.

no sponsors | no races | nothing to see here
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lol just do it on yours and then pass the info on to Sarah as it could hurt her on race day. Cheers
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Specialized customer service confirmed itā€™s a bladder. Anything else you need me to find out for you?

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Shambolic wrote:
Why would you put a bladder there if you already have a tank. You need a bladder in a frame. I'm sure Sarah would know how to fill her hydration?

A variety of reasons.

But you could both be wrong. My bet is that it *is* bladder, but it has a one-way valve designed to accept common bidon nozzles for "in flight" refuelling. Sort of like the bite-valves on existing hydration packs, only designed for inflow. And designed to open on pressure from a nozzle rather than biting.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 

BryanD wrote:
Bryancd wrote:


I was just thinking of that. The BTA is a must, especially one you can swap out or refill. I suppose the question is if you set the bike up with sufficient hydration and food how does it effect the aerodynamics? That's a question I also have for some of these really wild designs like the Ceepo Phantom, the frame might be super fast but once you strap bottles and bags all over it then what?


Bikes are coming out that are fully integrated and allow you to carry everything you need for an Ironman, and it's not good enough. With the new Shiv, everything is hidden in the frame. What more can you ask for?

Bicycle only drag charts are meaningless because they aren't testing with storage and bottles. Pure frame drag doesn't mean anything once bottles get put on, bentos are attached, and flat kits are placed somewhere.

But you know....people argue all day long about the aerodynamics of a 23 mm or 24mm tire but won't even give a bike the time of day that has everything thought of.

It's hilarious to watch.

What more can we ask for ?

It is nice and elegant to get everything inside the frame.
But the aero result is .... zero
zero gain for.... 14k USD
zero gain comparatively to old Shiv, a not so aero bike...

Take a more basic bike (P2 or P3, mid range IA, ...), with similar wheels, hide one bottle between the arms, one bottle behind the saddle, repair kit in an Aeropouch, bars in a bento behind stem.... and you have the same aero effectiveness, very practical, very adjustable, and UCI legal in some cases, to go on TT. For less than half the price.

Is it hilarious (as you say) to think some people will spend that much money for ... what ?

Personally, I ask for a really efficient and versatile bike for a good price.

What most says here, and I agree, is that this bike doesn't convince us.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Lol no I'm good thanks. Maybe how the hell you fill it then because seems stupid having a bladder when you have a tank?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
Hey All,

I am here to answer some questions about the bike.
  1. The hydration system does come in multiple sizes - There are currently 4 sizes based on the change in top tube height that help put the Fuelcell within the expected saddle adjustment ranges. The system can also be cut-to-fit for a rider that has a unique morphology.
  2. The frame has a permanently installed conduit within the frame that makes bladder removal very easy. You can push or pull the bladder system out with 1-hand. The permanent conduit makes sure you arent battling debris, tools, cabling, etc...while performing this process.

    • The photo of the clear frame is not the production system - It is a mockup - The way it was made does not allow for the internal conduit and production lid system, etc...
  3. The rear reservoir is removeable! It is only 2 bolts and it comes off. Of course this feature is a big aero benefit at yaw, so removing it is not recommended but its the riders choice.
  4. BTA, TT and ST mounting points are provided for flexibility in mounting additional storage/nutrition
  5. The front nosecone is removable to allow access to all of the cabling and hydration straw for further ease of use

Come by the SHIV Launch display next to Ceramic Speed by Huggos this week to check it out in person!



Thanks for all the info. But if you are either sponsored by Specialized or directly employed by them you should indicate as much here. Mostly for your own benefit so this apparently "good" information is distinguishable from the pages of speculation.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey guys,

That's Keith, he's the lead engineer on the bike (has done a fantastic job) and was on the road to Kona when he wrote to answer some of your questions. Between Cam Piper, Keith, Chris Yu, SuperDave, and me, we'll set some time to connect w the crew on this thread to answer your questions. This bike is a whole new approach aerodynamically in many areas - no single chart or single data point will answer it all definitively.

We're all super excited about this new machine and everything it delivers. It challenges much of the status quo for aero - the ST defines so much of the speed versus everything we as an industry believe the DT has done in the past. The fork is designed to sail - very different than the low frontal area forks of our past (and present). The DT is designed for storage, handling, and weight and have concentrated our surface area where speed is gained most on other areas of the bike.

5 years after the Win Tunnel we've learned that HOW you carry your fuel matters MORE than the differences between most frame modules. We were conservative in saying 1 minute over Kona versus our absolute best configs. Versus the average? Much much more. Over the coming months, we can get more data from the tunnel to answer your specific questions.

Can't wait for the race this weekend! Will be an awesome Kona.

Mark

--
Mark Cote
MITAerobike
Specialized Bicycle Components
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:

Thanks for all the info. But if you are either sponsored by Specialized or directly employed by them you should indicate as much here. Mostly for your own benefit so this apparently "good" information is distinguishable from the pages of speculation.


Yes I work for specialized. I am here to help.

The hydration system is a carbon fiber reservoir off the back that receives a custom bladder system. This is to allow removal and cleaning. Obviously you do not want to be drinking out of raw carbon!

The lid does pop off. Refilling on the fly is possible but itā€™s not a function that we claim due to each riders different setups and bike handling skills.

Many of our pros in Kona will be refilling their systems on the fly, but itā€™s very individual.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [philly1x] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
philly1x wrote:
gregtay wrote:
I was curious to see what it looks like without the sail...
loose the disc brakes, and I'd race that.
Wouldnā€™t they just fall off?

I ride:
Cervelo - P-Series/R3
GT - Sensor Carbon Expert

Supporters - Flo Cycling, Mount Bikes
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
trail wrote:

Thanks for all the info. But if you are either sponsored by Specialized or directly employed by them you should indicate as much here. Mostly for your own benefit so this apparently "good" information is distinguishable from the pages of speculation.


Yes I work for specialized. I am here to help.

The hydration system is a carbon fiber reservoir off the back that receives a custom bladder system. This is to allow removal and cleaning. Obviously you do not want to be drinking out of raw carbon!

The lid does pop off. Refilling on the fly is possible but itā€™s not a function that we claim due to each riders different setups and bike handling skills.

Many of our pros in Kona will be refilling their systems on the fly, but itā€™s very individual.
Great to have you here, thanks.

Please can you elaborate on how you fill the bladder on the fly? Is there a nozzle of some such?

Cheers

I ride:
Cervelo - P-Series/R3
GT - Sensor Carbon Expert

Supporters - Flo Cycling, Mount Bikes
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How about we get the hydration back inside the downtube. That's what attracted me originally when I was replacing my last bike. When I was told everything was changing and to wait until April...I went somewhere else. And boy am I happy!

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Last edited by: TheStroBro: Oct 9, 18 16:51
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [MITaerobike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
MITaerobike wrote:
Hey guys,

That's Keith, he's the lead engineer on the bike (has done a fantastic job) and was on the road to Kona when he wrote to answer some of your questions. Between Cam Piper, Keith, Chris Yu, SuperDave, and me, we'll set some time to connect w the crew on this thread to answer your questions. This bike is a whole new approach aerodynamically in many areas - no single chart or single data point will answer it all definitively.

We're all super excited about this new machine and everything it delivers. It challenges much of the status quo for aero - the ST defines so much of the speed versus everything we as an industry believe the DT has done in the past. The fork is designed to sail - very different than the low frontal area forks of our past (and present). The DT is designed for storage, handling, and weight and have concentrated our surface area where speed is gained most on other areas of the bike.

5 years after the Win Tunnel we've learned that HOW you carry your fuel matters MORE than the differences between most frame modules. We were conservative in saying 1 minute over Kona versus our absolute best configs. Versus the average? Much much more. Over the coming months, we can get more data from the tunnel to answer your specific questions.

Can't wait for the race this weekend! Will be an awesome Kona.

Mark

Thanks for chiming in Mark. I'm curious, how does the fork affect the handling of the bike? To my eye it appears that about an equal amount of surface area is both ahead of and behind the steering axis so my gut says "neutral" but I'm curious to hear your take. For a flat kit, I assume the idea would be to stash a tube, CO2, etc in a bag and stuff that in the DT under the Fuelsage?

Also.... and this is important... what exactly does your "fastest Shiv" look like? Standard Shiv basebar? Which front brake?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [MITaerobike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey Mark, how much faster is this new Shiv the bike alone compared to the new Venge?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Very interesting bike. Love it or leave it, the most interesting development in bikes is happening in tt. I love the engineering.

Aero:

The claimed aero gains, or lack of, is a bit of a hint in my book:

If it beat the main competators in the wind tunnel, i suspect they would be announcing it with bells on. Instead, what i expect to see is good high yaw performance, but the low yaw stuff will likely be only ā€œgoodā€ (so they will need to do as the felt ia did and start winning at kona to help marketing).

I have no doubt it is fast however, but as was touched on before, their selling point will be itā€™s aero performance with 1.5L water or ā€œready to rideā€. I am sure it is faster than another bike without integrated hydration (but 1.5l of bottles on board). Canā€™t show that in a wind tunnel as there are too many permutations to compare. The sepecialized may have a hard/complex marketing sell, short of a kona win.

The fork:

i would like to get a better look. The previously mentioned idea that the fork wings may help prep the air for the knees is an interesting one. If it did, the low yaw data with a rider might be impressive, even if the low yaw riderless data was medeocre.

Hydration:

the rear hydration is interesting. It is a very race day ready feature (like tubular tires, great if you have loads of time, or a mechanic). The cleaning and routing must be a bit of work (i stopped using a camel back on mtb for that reason). I also figure that the sucking must be tough, and get a bit tougher once the resevoir gets lower.

I suppose if a rider mounts an empty horizonal bottle cage on the bars... uses the hydration resevoir for the first half the race, then uses bar mounted bottles grabbed from stations for the remainder, it might give an advantage. Mind you, there would only be drinking the old fashined way at that point. And refilling the resevoir on the go would seem hard and or slow.

Obviously, rides where 1.5l water is needed (and nothing extra) would be a sweet spot for the bike. I guess that somes down to how long, how hot, where are the refreshment stations for a specific race.

Storage box:

At first i thought it might be too far away to be convenient, but i think a rider could blindly grab from it in the aero position. Mind you, they could do the same from a top tube box also... . Not sure it would be an advantage, but i guess one would need to try to decide. I figure the top tube would be preferrable.

Discs:

The total drag is down vs the old model (marketing says 1 minute savings, but at what, presumably weighted, yaw angle???), but i will assume that the discs hampered how much better they could make it. And i understand that discs hurt more at high yaw anyway. I would like to see cfd images at different yaw.

One cool thing about discs is that it has appeared to allow the engineers play with different ideas now that they are not anchored to a rim brake design. It is interesting to see the initial design diversity with the disc tr bikes amongst brands before a more formal concensus is achieved (like we see with most aero road bike shapes now... thanks uci!).

Asthetics:

Overall, i am unsure of the asthetics. The big fin is bold, and kind of cool. The fork looks interesting also.
Last edited by: Rocket_racing: Oct 9, 18 18:22
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
trail wrote:

Thanks for all the info. But if you are either sponsored by Specialized or directly employed by them you should indicate as much here. Mostly for your own benefit so this apparently "good" information is distinguishable from the pages of speculation.


Yes I work for specialized. I am here to help.

The hydration system is a carbon fiber reservoir off the back that receives a custom bladder system. This is to allow removal and cleaning. Obviously you do not want to be drinking out of raw carbon!

The lid does pop off. Refilling on the fly is possible but itā€™s not a function that we claim due to each riders different setups and bike handling skills.

Many of our pros in Kona will be refilling their systems on the fly, but itā€™s very individual.
So you are terming it a bladder but it is effectively a liner of the box with the large lid on top of the box as the opening?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BayDad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Check tim don's instagram
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
what exactly does your "fastest Shiv" look like? Standard Shiv basebar? Which front brake?
Yup, it would be great to
know what "clean cable routing" is exactly:
Specialized wrote:
Compared to the fastest 2011 Shiv setup possible (Fuelcell, slammed bars, clean cable routing, BTA bottle), the Shiv Disc is nearly a minute faster over the Kona course.
From
https://specialized.com/new-shiv .
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Is the bigger picture proprietary everything with no real option to customize and big repair costs if you break something? Because I understood that the second they showed the fork.

It's an elite bike, meant to be ridden by elites. It's like a car company investing in F1. I know I can't buy their F1 car, but I might enjoy some trickle down to my road-legal model. I appreciate the effort, and look forward to the bits that trickle down to the $5 to $7k range, which means $2k used in four to five years, at which point I might buy one if I haven't yet won the lottery.

***
Quote Reply
Post deleted by Shambolic [ In reply to ]
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Iā€™m not entertaining any more of this nonsense. Itā€™s a removable bladder with a straw. Move on.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Attempting to refill that on the fly is going to induce a lot of crash replacements frames.

Downtube fuselage was fine, they could have also designed a BTA like front end since there were Specialized Athletes adding the PD integrated unit.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Shambolic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey all, tons of good questions here. I will get to as many of them as I can but it will be a bit slow since we are here in Kona answering inquiries on the ground. Also, uploading hi-res while mobile is a bit more tedious on ST.

Anyway, there are 5 major components of the Fuelcell hydration system:
  1. Reservoir - this is the carbon fiber airfoil shaped container that is attached to the Frame
  2. Bladder - this fluid bladder is has an integral lid as well as exitport
  3. Cap - this is the the silicone plug that seals into the bladder's kid
  4. Straw - this tubing is self explanatory and comes in at 150cm and can be cut to liking
  5. Bite Valve - Sef explanatory, but the new valve is 1-way to reduce hydration pull thru effort.

The big confusion on ST i see right now is that the bladder and lid are integral (1pc). The cap is a separate piece that has a tether and is removable while riding. The Lid is attached to the bladder (basically a trim ring that overlaps the reservoir top edge) and is not removable while riding.

To fill on the fly, you can pop off the cap and squirt squirt squirt...Or you can get creative (watch for some custom athlete solutions on Saturday!)

Here below is Tim Don filling on the fly. The cap is off and hanging off the backside (look closely) and the lid is still sitting on the reservoir which is supporting the internal bladder.


Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Another point to clarify is that the one of the pics floating around of Sarah True earlier was actually of a prototype system. Below you can see the 2 versions:

1 was a prototype zip top closure (blue) while we worked on the design of the lid and cap system. This allowed us to test the capacity and drinkability as well as routing of the system, ahead of the injection molded top closure system. The zip closure system is not able to be refilled and was positioned loosely within the reservoir.

The 2nd system is the production system (black) which the athletes are using now. It consists of the integral bladder with lid, and the removable cap with tether as shown. This is whats in the Tim Don picture above.



Here is a picture of the system on the bike, partially pulled up so you can see the interface. You can also see in the Seat Stay area where we enter the frame. There is a permanently bonded conduit to allow the straw to enter and exit the bike free of any restrictions, at all times. This is what allows easy cleaning and routing.


Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for showing pictures! I love the creativity and design that went into this.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Last edited by: BryanD: Oct 9, 18 21:21
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
Attempting to refill that on the fly is going to induce a lot of crash replacements frames.

Downtube fuselage was fine, they could have also designed a BTA like front end since there were Specialized Athletes adding the PD integrated unit.

Hey StroBro...we agree that downtube nutrition is a good idea. We just determined it to be much more efficient to have the hydration in the rear and the solid nutrition on the downtube so it was more easily reached while in the aero position. Further, the Fuelcell in the DT is removable allowing storage of tubes, co2, and levers below the fuelcell in space that would otherwise be unused.

To make the rear airfoil capable of holding tools, etc...would have not been as aero as Dr. Speed mentioned in the launch video.

Lastly, we do have a BTA solution! There is a custom extension based mount that allows a bottle cage between the arms or a computer mount. This will allow you to take on any course bottle at any aid station just like before. Nutrition needs are very specific, especially at full Iron distance so we wanted to give flexible solutions such as TT rivets, ST rivets, BTA rivets...Fuel On!

If you really want to, you can forget the food and tools and stuff an osprey bladder in there. Send pics so I can show our product manager!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Runorama] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Runorama wrote:
Drag with a rider on will be competitive at 0 yaw with a P5(x) and will beat it at >15Ā°.

What's "competitive" mean exactly? And >15deg isn't a viable design point.
Quote Reply
Post deleted by windschatten [ In reply to ]
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Just wanted to thank you for bringing back my old bike stream :-)

Where's the seat shifter?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I guess watching where you are going in or near an aid station is not important.

2017 Cervelo P2
2017 Cervelo S2
itraininla.com
#itraininla
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
To make the rear airfoil capable of holding tools, etc...would have not been as aero as Dr. Speed mentioned in the launch video.
How did the 2011 Fuelcell in the seat tube cage mount do in the tunnel? Looks like it's still almost a perfect fit :)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Rocket_racing] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Rocket_racing wrote:
The fork:

i would like to get a better look. The previously mentioned idea that the fork wings may help prep the air for the knees is an interesting one. If it did, the low yaw data with a rider might be impressive, even if the low yaw riderless data was medeocre.

Is there any serious manufacturer nowadays, who still tests bikes without a rider onboard?

----------------------------
Need more W/CdA.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [MITaerobike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey Keith and Mark,

Thanks for answering some of our questions. That is great support.

I was wondering were and when we could see the new Shiv if we are not in Kona.
Are there any specific stores (especially in Europe) where we could see the bike before we have to decide to order one or not?

Thanks
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [rruff] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rruff wrote:
Runorama wrote:
Drag with a rider on will be competitive at 0 yaw with a P5(x) and will beat it at >15Ā°.


What's "competitive" mean exactly? And >15deg isn't a viable design point.

I guess we will have realistic aero figures and comparisons when several other disk models are available (P5, P3, IA, Canyon, ...) and an independent study will be made comparing (some of) these new disk models with (some of) existing disk models (P5X, Dimond, new Shiv, ...) and (some) rim models (P5, P3, IA, Canyon, ...), a bit like the "Tri bike in the age of peak aero" study, including :

- equivalent configs (same volume of water, gels and bars, repair kit, tooth brush, shower gel, credit card holder....)
- same rider with same position and same helmet
- various yaw
- in a single wind tunnel, same wind speed

I think this new Shiv bring interesting aero solutions. And I like the look. It is not pretty, but it look efficient, impressive, innovative.

No comment on practicability of bladder, refilling, etc... this is personal choice.

The elephant in the room, for me, at this stage (apart from the price, so letĀ“s say the second elephant in the room...) is why such a shy announcement regading aero perf ?
I'm sure Spe engineer are good, they brought very innovative solutions (at the expense of look and cost ?), they should have got a significant gain over old Shiv, and they have nearly nothing... 1mn on 180km is error margin.

A problem with disk brake aero ?
All new solutions (new fork, new "bladder sail", ...) just to compensate disk drag ?
Probably every brand will have this problem ?

At this stage, I consider disk brake is nice for security, but maybe not a step in the right direction for aero ? Making aero perf announcement difficult for new disk models ?

Any results from fair comparaison between same model with rim brake vs disk brake ?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pyrenean Wolf wrote:
Hello

first post on Slowtwich for me. Sorry for the english, I'm french...

1 minute of aero gain over an Ironman : based on my beloved calculator, carefully calibrated through hours of ride on the track and road, 1mn over 180km around pro speed (40 km/h) equal : 2,1 w
i.e. 1,2 watt for me (around 33km/h)
i.e. 21 g of drag at 30mph (to compare to several studies like "Tri bikes at the age of peak aero", ...)
i.e. I will get twice or three time this saving replacing my good old ultregra pulley wheels with a nice 16 or 17 teeth OSPW from Cycling Ceramic or Ceramic Speed or whoever,,, just for comparing.

Please note this is nearly the margin error in an aero test.

Please note also we do not know which yaw repartition for this result (to my (lack of) knowledge)

Remark 1 : how can a big brand with big R&D can arrive to such a small result, reworking completely the bike ?
My view is that it is coming from the negative impact of disk brakes on aero.
Disk brake have such shitty aero that reworking the rest of the bike with radical new solution barely compensate ?
I'm curious to see the results of future Cervelo P5 (or P3) Rim vs Disk aero drag, based on various yaw. It will give us some real comparison figures.

Remark 2 : disk brakes is a clear trend (forced, but real), so brands need (want) to go there. For aero bikes, such as Tri bikes, it is still to be proven it is a good point for users. And this point appear to be difficult to prove. This bike is an exemple. Releasing a new 10/14kā‚¬/USD bike with no aero gain (thanks to margin error) based on unknown (but certainly oriented) yaw, is certainly not what Specialized expected...
Their previous bike already not an aero rocket... this one possibly worse (with not favorable yaw) ?
These products managers are not in a good situation...

Remark 3 : I love disk brakes, when going downhill for hundreds or thousands of meters of D- in Pyrenees or Alps... Much safer, much stronger. Especially with rain. But probably in a flat tri it will bring me nothing. Except drag ?
I'm ready to go disk, for safety reasons in downhill, under rain, but given the price to change one road and one TT/Tri bike (one with basic/training wheel, the other with 55mm aero wheels, frequently swapped depending on usage), I guess I will wait 1, 2 or 3 years in order to let the offer stabilize, then go to mid price models (such as P3 Disk, S3 Disk, or Trek, Spe, Canyon, Argon... equivalent).
Probably no or little aero gain (compared to my existing P3 2014), but safer.

No doubt early adopters and less price-sensitive peoples will go sooner for these disk equipped babies. Aero gains are ... ahem.... not guaranteed ?

great first post

and better grammar than most of us English speakers !
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mrlobber] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mrlobber wrote:
Rocket_racing wrote:

The fork:

i would like to get a better look. The previously mentioned idea that the fork wings may help prep the air for the knees is an interesting one. If it did, the low yaw data with a rider might be impressive, even if the low yaw riderless data was medeocre.


Is there any serious manufacturer nowadays, who still tests bikes without a rider onboard?


The marketing departments will work with whatever numbers they can get their sticky hands on. Any good marketer worth his/her salt will find the situation that puts a bike in the best light, rider or not, weighted yaw angles or not.

I will give them some time, but what is most notable with the new ia, and to a lesser degree shiv, is actually the lack of marketig aero data. To me that says a lot.
Last edited by: Rocket_racing: Oct 10, 18 4:27
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Rocket_racing] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Rocket_racing wrote:


I will give them some time, but what is most notable with the new ia, and to a lesser degree shiv, is actually the lack of marketig aero data. To me that says a lot.


Does it really matter anymore? Peak aero is here and thatā€™s ok! Integration and braking is the new focus instead of this crazy requirement that every bike be significantly faster than the old one. It just wonā€™t happen anymore.

Let the OCD about drag data go and embrace integration and features.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Last edited by: BryanD: Oct 10, 18 4:33
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Rocket_racing] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Rocket_racing wrote:


The marketing departments will work with whatever numbers they can get their sticky hands on. Any good marketer worth his/her salt will find the situation that puts a bike in the best light, rider or not, weighted yaw angles or not.

I will give them some time, but what is most notable with the new ia, and to a lesser degree shiv, is actually the lack of marketig aero data. To me that says a lot.


Completely agree, the "white paper" that Pinarello just put out on the bolide tr/tr+ was just a marketing pamphlet with no data at all.

Edit: to reply to Bryan above me, I feel this is more of a confirmation of this "age of peak aeroness" argument. But yes this does mean now features are more of an differentiating factor than before for high end consumers, at least currently.

Edit2: well shit, this is what happens when people reply close to the same time, now it just looks like im regurgitating
Last edited by: zinny: Oct 10, 18 4:40
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
Attempting to refill that on the fly is going to induce a lot of crash replacements frames.


That's a problem in the making. People are going to crash trying refill that thing.

That's my one and only true critique of the bike. I'm all for out of the box thinking and I get some of the reasons why it was placed where it was placed. That stated, the bike is designed specifically for long course triathletes in mind with the storage and hydration part of the design and they put a refillable hydration cell behind the rider. That's baffling to me. It's incumbent on the rider to practice and do it or don't do it but we all know how that goes. Maybe refilling it is an easier process than it looks. That picture of Tim Don refilling it gives me nightmares about what's to come when someone not as adept and in control does that.

My guess is next to nobody uses it and refills it once they deplete whatever fluids they had to start with. 50 ounces would get me through about 75-90 minutes of an Ironman race depending on how warm. So about 1/4 to 1/5 of the bike.

Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Last edited by: The GMAN: Oct 10, 18 4:46
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Rocket_racing] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Rocket_racing wrote:


The marketing departments will work with whatever numbers they can get their sticky hands on. Any good marketer worth his/her salt will find the situation that puts a bike in the best light, rider or not, weighted yaw angles or not.

I will give them some time, but what is most notable with the new ia, and to a lesser degree shiv, is actually the lack of marketig aero data. To me that says a lot.


I think the lack of marketing aero data says exactly what we expect nowadays:
(Edit - because I agree with you. If the aero data was there, it would be marketed without question)

BryanD wrote:


Does it really matter anymore? Peak aero is here and thatā€™s ok! Integration and braking is the new focus instead of this crazy requirement that every bike be significantly faster than the old one. It just wonā€™t happen anymore.

Let the OCD about drag data go and embrace integration and features.
Last edited by: JLars: Oct 10, 18 4:47
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
Rocket_racing wrote:


I will give them some time, but what is most notable with the new ia, and to a lesser degree shiv, is actually the lack of marketig aero data. To me that says a lot.


Does it really matter anymore? Peak aero is here and thatā€™s ok! Integration and braking is the new focus instead of this crazy requirement that every bike be significantly faster than the old one. It just wonā€™t happen anymore.

Let the OCD about drag data go and embrace integration and features.

Yes, it matter !

You are missing the big picture (on purpose ?).

We are talking Tri bike. Objective is faster time with same power, same position, same helmet, same wheels, same tyre... so, more aero.

If your objective is on aesthetic, or philosophy, we are not on the same discussion here.

1) Braking is important for road bike, for D-, but for flat tri ?
If I go disk on my Tri/TT bike, it is more because I want to be able to swap wheels with my road bike than any other reason.

2) Integration : my P3 give me enough capacity for integration. With aero efficiency. If I can suppress the aero pouch, it is estethically nicer. More aero ? No

3) Aero : if disk brakes are aero shit, I prefer to know it.

What is the point of a 14kUSD bike, if it bring nothing in performance ? Ego masturbation (which I also practice sometimes) ?

"We are at aero peak... stop looking at aero figures..."... blablabla...

Aero peak doesn't exist, each bike have different aero perf depending on configuration, wheels, yaw...
And if I'm to use my money to buy one, I want some clear view on aero perf.

I'm not simply going to buy the highest price, thinking "Ohh, that expensive... must be faaaast..."
Strangely, I will buy cheap and PROVEN fast.

I understand that some peoples by Tri bike on color, shape, aesthetic, high price, social status affirmation,whatever reasons ...but please don't say we do not need to look at aero perf. That is hilarious. Or biased ?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I think you need to go read the Slowtwitch wind tunnel study

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
I think you need to go read the Slowtwitch wind tunnel study

I read a lot of aero studies, and perform a lot of them also.

Don't hesitate to supply me the link to this specific study, I will give you my feedback.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I guess the question is... what is ā€œpeak aero?ā€

- riders position.
- the bike.
- the rider and the bike as a system
- Now it is the rider, bike, and everything needed on actual race day (water/storage).

Marketing and comparing the details of the final stage in ā€œpeak aeroā€ is tough. Most marketing wind tunnel data does not include hydration needs for the race. And based on the race, hydration needs change, and aero needs change, so like high vs low yaw angle, there is no easy answer... or easy marketing.

Do you compare the shiv to tt bike x in the wind tunnel with 1.5L water on board? Where do you put the 1.5L on bike x? Do those systems get to be aero? What if you now need 3l for a race? 1L? Who is fastest now? How do you market that?

Here is my opinion: if your new addition is disc brakes, or new integration: market that, and just reassure the aero weenies that there is no aero loss. Next gen, disc brakes are old news... so the marketing and design focus is again on aero and more integration. Need to sell bikes.
Last edited by: Rocket_racing: Oct 10, 18 6:25
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
https://www.slowtwitch.com/Tech/Triathlon_Bikes_in_the_Age_of_Peak_Aero_6429.html

I read this study last year, when it came out.
And I mentionned it twice in my last few posts in this thread.
It confirm what I say. Aero test are important, because there is significant differences between bikes, configs...

You will notice that in this study, the difference between best performing bike and least performing bike is around 100g of drag, 5 time the difference announced by Spe between optimized old and optimized new Shiv.

The question is, where are the Shiv positioned amongst these rim bikes ?

From another study, with 0 yaw, old Shiv is probably in second half of this pack, and from Spe annoucement, new Shiv is probably middle of this pack, behind P5X, P5, and also probably P3 (again from another study).

To be confirmed, or not when serious aero figures will be published.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [cowboy7] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
cowboy7 wrote:
Pyrenean Wolf wrote:

Hello

first post on Slowtwich for me. Sorry for the english, I'm french...

1 minute of aero gain over an Ironman : based on my beloved calculator, carefully calibrated through hours of ride on the track and road, 1mn over 180km around pro speed (40 km/h) equal : 2,1 w
i.e. 1,2 watt for me (around 33km/h)
i.e. 21 g of drag at 30mph (to compare to several studies like "Tri bikes at the age of peak aero", ...)
i.e. I will get twice or three time this saving replacing my good old ultregra pulley wheels with a nice 16 or 17 teeth OSPW from Cycling Ceramic or Ceramic Speed or whoever,,, just for comparing.

Please note this is nearly the margin error in an aero test.

Please note also we do not know which yaw repartition for this result (to my (lack of) knowledge)

Remark 1 : how can a big brand with big R&D can arrive to such a small result, reworking completely the bike ?
My view is that it is coming from the negative impact of disk brakes on aero.
Disk brake have such shitty aero that reworking the rest of the bike with radical new solution barely compensate ?
I'm curious to see the results of future Cervelo P5 (or P3) Rim vs Disk aero drag, based on various yaw. It will give us some real comparison figures.

Remark 2 : disk brakes is a clear trend (forced, but real), so brands need (want) to go there. For aero bikes, such as Tri bikes, it is still to be proven it is a good point for users. And this point appear to be difficult to prove. This bike is an exemple. Releasing a new 10/14kā‚¬/USD bike with no aero gain (thanks to margin error) based on unknown (but certainly oriented) yaw, is certainly not what Specialized expected...
Their previous bike already not an aero rocket... this one possibly worse (with not favorable yaw) ?
These products managers are not in a good situation...

Remark 3 : I love disk brakes, when going downhill for hundreds or thousands of meters of D- in Pyrenees or Alps... Much safer, much stronger. Especially with rain. But probably in a flat tri it will bring me nothing. Except drag ?
I'm ready to go disk, for safety reasons in downhill, under rain, but given the price to change one road and one TT/Tri bike (one with basic/training wheel, the other with 55mm aero wheels, frequently swapped depending on usage), I guess I will wait 1, 2 or 3 years in order to let the offer stabilize, then go to mid price models (such as P3 Disk, S3 Disk, or Trek, Spe, Canyon, Argon... equivalent).
Probably no or little aero gain (compared to my existing P3 2014), but safer.

No doubt early adopters and less price-sensitive peoples will go sooner for these disk equipped babies. Aero gains are ... ahem.... not guaranteed ?


great first post

and better grammar than most of us English speakers !


Perfectly put, really good post.

Si mon franƧais Ʃtait aussi bon que votre anglais, j'en parlerais Ơ tout le monde!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Rocket_racing] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 
Very simple : you take the aero figure for what you need.

if you do TT, use simply 1 aero bottle, and make comparaison as such.
If you do tri, and need 2 bottles + bento + repair, then take the aero figures with 2 bottles +....

Where do you put them ? where they have the least impact : integrated or hidden

Read the study mentionne above: interesting

And from this + other studies :
1 bottle behind the saddle : no aero impact
1 bottle behind the arms : no aero impact
Aero pouch : no impact
Bento behind stem : no impact

Each brand of course bias the info. To push own product. But there is some real comparaison you can find.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [windschatten] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I dislike the bike

However, I dislike the perception that every tri is flat and thus there is no benefit in better braking (not breaking...). One of my favourites is Mallorca 70.3 where I took minutes out of folks on flashy top end TT bikes because my basic TT bike had better braking and because of that I had more confidence. If you can brake harder and later going into a corner you will go faster overall. I appreciate the drag argument but I do think being bale brake better and have more confidence on a tri bike is worth some development.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jayski] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jayski wrote:
One of my favourites is Mallorca 70.3 where I took minutes out of folks on flashy top end TT bikes because my basic TT bike had better braking and because of that I had more confidence.


I'd bet that almost all of that was just you being more skilled, though. If the only differentiating factor was disc brakes you'd be taking seconds, not minutes.
Last edited by: trail: Oct 10, 18 6:43
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That picture of Tim Don refilling the bladder is quite possibly the dumbest thing I have ever seen.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
jayski wrote:
One of my favourites is Mallorca 70.3 where I took minutes out of folks on flashy top end TT bikes because my basic TT bike had better braking and because of that I had more confidence.


I'd bet that almost all of that was just you being more skilled, though. If the only differentiating factor was disc brakes you'd be taking seconds, not minutes.

^^^^
This.

In Mallorca roughly the first half of the bike is up and down (Coll de Femenia), then it is flat road for more or less 40k (We had rather strong crosswind this year). You kept your hard earned advantage maybe because your basic TT bike was more aero with rim brakes? :)

My point is, disc brakes might help even in TT /LD Tri, given that the course is not pancake flat, but aero is far more important... I am in the market for new TT and road bikes, and I know it will be rim brake for the TT (maybe for the last time) and disc for the road.

Sr. Salitre
Last edited by: SrSalitre: Oct 10, 18 6:55
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [SrSalitre] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SrSalitre wrote:
trail wrote:
jayski wrote:
One of my favourites is Mallorca 70.3 where I took minutes out of folks on flashy top end TT bikes because my basic TT bike had better braking and because of that I had more confidence.


I'd bet that almost all of that was just you being more skilled, though. If the only differentiating factor was disc brakes you'd be taking seconds, not minutes.

^^^^
This.

In Mallorca roughly the first half of the bike is up and down (Coll de Femenia), then it is flat road for more or less 40k (We had rather strong crosswind this year). You kept your hard earned advantage maybe because your basic TT bike was more aero with rim brakes? :)

My point is, disc brakes might help even in TT /LD Tri, given that the course is not pancake flat, but aero is far more important... I am in the market for new TT and road bikes, and I know it will be rim brake for the TT (maybe for the last time) and disc for the road.

At that time everyone was on rim brakes.

My point is that I had better (old, standard ultegra) brakes and more confidence throwing the bike around and braking later as opposed to integrated, rubbish rim brakes on higher end tri bikes. Having discs gives that confidence and automatically means you can descend faster. I wouldn't put myself out there as a fantastic descender.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It wasn't designed to be refillable while riding. You can, but it wasn't designed that way.

See this quote from one of the Specialized guys just a few pages back:

Quote:
The lid does pop off. Refilling on the fly is possible but itā€™s not a function that we claim due to each riders different setups and bike handling skills.

Group Eleven ā€“ Websites for Athletes / mikael.racing / @mstaer
Last edited by: Staer: Oct 10, 18 7:27
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Staer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Staer wrote:
It wasn't designed to be refillable while riding. You can, but it wasn't designed that way.

See this quote from one of the Specialized guys just a few pages back:

Quote:
The lid does pop off. Refilling on the fly is possible but itā€™s not a function that we claim due to each riders different setups and bike handling skills.
You wouldn't need to refill it in an Ironman. 2 bottles in the bladder, 1 BTA, and 1 behind the saddle. That's 4 bottles. That gets you through 4 hours of an Ironman and you can refill at special needs or grab on course bottles.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Staer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Staer wrote:
It wasn't designed to be refillable while riding. You can, but it wasn't designed that way.

See this quote from one of the Specialized guys just a few pages back:

Quote:
The lid does pop off. Refilling on the fly is possible but itā€™s not a function that we claim due to each riders different setups and bike handling skills.

I get that and I read that but still... whatā€™s the point of designing a bike around integration and storage just to have an integrated hydration system that only gets me through about 30 miles on the bike? It seems aerodynamics trumped functionality here, which is great and all, but this was a bike designed around the supposed needs of long course triathletes. At least the older Shiv and the Ventum have easily refillable solutions. This is a head scratcher to me. Iā€™m otherwise fine with the bike.

Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You drink 2 bottles of water in 30 miles?

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Oh I completely agree. Seems like a massive oversight.

I should not have to add a bottle behind the saddle (looks whack on this bike) and then still figure out an aftermarket refillable BTA solution, when I dropped $18k (CAD) on the "ultimate" tri bike.

Group Eleven ā€“ Websites for Athletes / mikael.racing / @mstaer
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Bryan...4 Bottles? Really? you survive on 4 bottles? Doubt it. More like 7.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Staer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Staer wrote:
Oh I completely agree. Seems like a massive oversight.

I should not have to add a bottle behind the saddle (looks whack on this bike) and then still figure out an aftermarket refillable BTA solution, when I dropped $18k (CAD) on the "ultimate" tri bike.

I hear you, but remember the wing was designed first for aero reasons... then they figured ā€œwhy not fill it with waterā€.

I bike designed around water needs first might look very different
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
Bryan...4 Bottles? Really? you survive on 4 bottles? Doubt it. More like 7.


Ironman Chattanooga I think I drank 5 bottles. I had 3 bottles on my P2 and refilled at special needs.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Last edited by: BryanD: Oct 10, 18 8:19
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Rocket_racing] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Rocket_racing wrote:

I bike designed around water needs first might look very different

Like the Ventum?

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Staer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Staer wrote:
It wasn't designed to be refillable while riding. You can, but it wasn't designed that way.

See this quote from one of the Specialized guys just a few pages back:

Quote:
The lid does pop off. Refilling on the fly is possible but itā€™s not a function that we claim due to each riders different setups and bike handling skills.

Not Designed to vs idiots still trying it are two different things. Since itā€™s possible people will try it and itā€™ll be ugly for a lot of them.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
Rocket_racing wrote:

I bike designed around water needs first might look very different

Like the Ventum?

Hahah. Yup! Imho that thing is an abomination to my eyes. I dont care how fast or convenient it is... :-D
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Rocket_racing] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is what is hilarious about Slowtwitch.

People want a bike that looks like a Speed Concept or a P5 because they think that's how a bike is supposed to look.

Then, people say, I wish we had integrated hydration and storage and not be UCI legal. Here comes the Ventum. People claim it's ugly, it's stupid, etc. Same thing happened with the P5-X.

Specialized comes out with a new Shiv that has everything you need for racing and suddenly it's ugly, stupid, dumb.

Pinarello comes out with a bike and everyone is excited because it looks like a Speed Concept/P5. When the new P5 disc brake comes out, people will go nuts because it looks like what they think a bike should be.

And yet somehow people loved Dimond?

This place makes me laugh on a daily basis.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Last edited by: BryanD: Oct 10, 18 8:31
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
Does it really matter anymore?

Does going fast matter?

The old Shiv did poorly in aero tests. If they are only beating that by 1min in Kona simulations, then there are a few bikes still ahead of it by a good margin.

I really dislike integrated front ends that are proprietary and difficult to adjust. Usually *expensive* to adjust as well. That's a big speed/comfort issue. You *need* to be able to do quick changes for aero testing. I don't know exactly how the Shiv is in that respect, but it doesn't look promising.

I don't mind the looks of the front end, but I suspect there is some negative aero going on with interference drag and clunky base bars. The rear reservoir is probably aero but looks like a tacked on aftermarket item that wasn't made for the bike.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [rruff] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rruff wrote:

Does going fast matter?


It doesn't matter when the %diff in drag between most of these bikes is so small. And it will only get smaller.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Last edited by: BryanD: Oct 10, 18 8:44
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
For all the love you're throwing Specialized here and you ride a Cervelo? Also the entry level cervelo at that.

Where's the ROFL emojis. The vast majority of athletes probably have 6-7 bottles on the ride, pros are one thing...everyone else is a different matter.

Rocket_racing wrote:

Hahah. Yup! Imho that thing is an abomination to my eyes. I dont care how fast or convenient it is... :-D

The old Shiv was designed around hydration first, beautiful bike. This not so much.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Last edited by: TheStroBro: Oct 10, 18 8:49
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
For all the love you're throwing Specialized here and you ride a Cervelo? Also the entry level cervelo at that.

Where's the ROFL emojis. The vast majority of athletes probably have 6-7 bottles on the ride, pros are one thing...everyone else is a different matter.
I find the hostility hilarious. I'm sorry I don't agree with your version of what a bike should be. 6-7 bottles on a bike? Yeah no. I'm not a beginner.

Oh...you want to make fun of my bike? That's cute.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
It doesn't matter when the %diff in drag between most of these bikes is so small. And it will only get smaller.

I bet the P5X beats the Shiv by a "not small" margin in realistic wind. What about my other points, like adjustability... which is a more important aero consideration than the frame itself?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hostility, no, you just are falling over this bike saying: wait until they show you the numbers, well they aren't showing the numbers and you said it was only a minute faster in Kona conditions...has that been tested? Testing that in the wind tunnel is not the same. I guess we'll see what Lucy's bike split is on Saturday because I don't think any of the Specialized male pros make top five.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
This is what is hilarious about Slowtwitch.

People want a bike that looks like a Speed Concept or a P5 because they think that's how a bike is supposed to look.

Then, people say, I wish we had integrated hydration and storage and not be UCI legal. Here comes the Ventum. People claim it's ugly, it's stupid, etc. Same thing happened with the P5-X.

Specialized comes out with a new Shiv that has everything you need for racing and suddenly it's ugly, stupid, dumb.

Pinarello comes out with a bike and everyone is excited because it looks like a Speed Concept/P5. When the new P5 disc brake comes out, people will go nuts because it looks like what they think a bike should be.

And yet somehow people loved Dimond?

This place makes me laugh on a daily basis.

No man, I want what a bike with down tube fuselage hydration that is also refillable and easy to wrench. Specialized was there, just needed to make some tweaks to the bike.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So buy the old Shiv?

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [MattyK] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I love your sailing comparison. +1
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
+1
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I never said wait for the numbers. How about this? What if I said I donā€™t care about the numbers?

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
You drink 2 bottles of water in 30 miles?

You don't?

That's for an average temperature ride. During a hot race I will drink two bottles per hour.

Last IM I did I drank seven bottles of Perform by the halfway point of the bike.

Last 70.3 I did I drank six bottles of water or Gatorade in two and half hours.

Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Bryan apparently has the lowest sweat rate known to man...if he was fast he'd save time by skipping 2/3 of the aid stations!

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Holy crap. If I drink one bottle an hour Iā€™d be surprised.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Grant.Reuter] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Grant.Reuter wrote:
Holy crap. If I drink one bottle an hour Iā€™d be surprised.

I might be a bit of a billy goat but it's what I need to get through it all. I take in like 600 cal/hour during an IM and almost 400 for a 70.3.

Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
Staer wrote:
It wasn't designed to be refillable while riding. You can, but it wasn't designed that way.

See this quote from one of the Specialized guys just a few pages back:

Quote:
The lid does pop off. Refilling on the fly is possible but itā€™s not a function that we claim due to each riders different setups and bike handling skills.

You wouldn't need to refill it in an Ironman. 2 bottles in the bladder, 1 BTA, and 1 behind the saddle. That's 4 bottles. That gets you through 4 hours of an Ironman and you can refill at special needs or grab on course bottles.

4 bottles seems low. Many go through more, and the longer (slower) you take to ride the more you'll need. Also, for other reasons sometimes BTA bottles don't work well. I have never had success using them nor do I like having them mounted in front while I'm riding. I'm surprised they would not design something that is intended to be refilled.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
Staer wrote:
It wasn't designed to be refillable while riding. You can, but it wasn't designed that way.

See this quote from one of the Specialized guys just a few pages back:

Quote:
The lid does pop off. Refilling on the fly is possible but itā€™s not a function that we claim due to each riders different setups and bike handling skills.
You wouldn't need to refill it in an Ironman. 2 bottles in the bladder, 1 BTA, and 1 behind the saddle. That's 4 bottles. That gets you through 4 hours of an Ironman and you can refill at special needs or grab on course bottles.

I think suggesting someone could do an Ironman on 4 bottles is absurd.

That being said. I agree that I donā€™t think youā€™d have to necessarily refil. One could make up a concentrated liquid nutrition for bladder and just use water swaps at aid stations in BTA and refill at special needs, etc.

So I donā€™t think lack of easy refill on this is a deal killer or as bad as many say. Especially considering how few bikes have integrated hydration, this is a win if itā€™s actually easy to use, clean, and aero.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Nope. I can throw down 4:40 half ironmans and only drink 2-2.5 bottles on the bike.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [blueapplepaste] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Did you even read what I wrote? I said carry 4 bottles and refill at special needs.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [blueapplepaste] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
blueapplepaste wrote:
I think suggesting someone could do an Ironman on 4 bottles is absurd.

This is a bit of a generalisation, different strategies work for different people. In my last IM I went through maybe just over 1.5l total fluid and that's about normal for me. Sometimes I may go through 2l. I may be an outlier but to suggest it's absurd is incorrect.

In terms of bikes I just want a fast, minimal bike that allows me to make choices as to where I carry my nutrition and fluid rather than integration that I don't particularly need.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [JulianM] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
JulianM wrote:
In terms of bikes I just want a fast, minimal bike that allows me to make choices as to where I carry my nutrition and fluid rather than integration that I don't particularly need.

Hey all, JulianM's point is an important one...Everybody's nutrition is quite specific. We have some riders here that use 4 bottles, some use 9 bottles....some do sprints, some do full distance...

The New Shiv provides options for you. The rear reservoir with up to 1.5L of capacity takes those 2 bottles that you would normally have hanging off the back, in a non-aero situation, and moves them into an aerodynamic Fuelcell with a lower center of gravity. This improves the bikes performance and handling of the bike.

There are TT rivets, ST rivets, and BTA options all provided. Of course some will need them, and most will not, but this is the nature of individual specific nutrition.

To make 1.5L available in the downtube would have taken a significantly large frame shape. Doing this would have put the hydration system within a structural member of the frame and likely would have added a ton of weight, and made achieving the ride characteristics we were seeking very difficult if not impossible. The biggest complaint of the old bike (other than not being low enough) was often the size of the bladder and the difficulty to use & install. We think the new option solves those issues.

I think its a good time to mention that the weight of the bike is around 9kg race ready (no fluid). This is significantly lighter than some of the other fully integrated tri bikes out there. One thing I really like about this bike, is that it RIDES like a bike. Its much more like a Venge than a Shiv in a lot of ways and makes it enjoyable. Its not a noodle, and its not a slug. Power transfer is excellent and the steering preciseness makes rolling and twisting roads a blast.

I hope you can see the bike in person and get a better understanding for it.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thank you for coming on here and responding

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
I never said wait for the numbers. How about this? What if I said I donā€™t care about the numbers?

I'd say that's marketing's goal if the numbers for your product aren't noteworthy.

So good job marketing!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [walie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
walie wrote:
BryanD wrote:
I never said wait for the numbers. How about this? What if I said I donā€™t care about the numbers?


I'd say that's marketing's goal if the numbers for your product aren't noteworthy.

So good job marketing!

Sigh....this is just like the cell phone and semiconductor industry.

Everyone wants bigger, faster, better, etc yet you hit a point where you just can't and the %diff is so small it's hilarious.

If you can't understand why bike companies are focusing on integration and braking, then I don't know what to say.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The front end looks awesome



Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Today is probably the launch of the new S-Works Shiv Disc 2019.

Below you can find the first pictures as well the description.


I love it.

New official ride of Uber Eats... It will get to you faster...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i'll pass...where's the puke bucket?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm curious to see some aero numbers with a rider onboard. My biggest beef with this bike is the "shoulder" of the basebar. There's no way that's not an aero penalty.

Side note: LC looks awesome! Ryf better watch out!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It looks like wings!

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Now that I agree with you. The front is aesthetically pleasing and intriguing.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
Now that I agree with you. The front is aesthetically pleasing and intriguing.

Progress has been made!

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
This is what is hilarious about Slowtwitch.

People want a bike that looks like a Speed Concept or a P5 because they think that's how a bike is supposed to look.

Then, people say, I wish we had integrated hydration and storage and not be UCI legal. Here comes the Ventum. People claim it's ugly, it's stupid, etc. Same thing happened with the P5-X.

Specialized comes out with a new Shiv that has everything you need for racing and suddenly it's ugly, stupid, dumb.

There is a reason that 90%+ of Ferraris are sold in red. It is part of the human condition to have certain expectations, and to often contradict themselves. It becomes easier to deal with when you accept that humans often defy logic.

I am superficial with my bikes, and i admit it. It is step 3 in the recovery process of this biking hobby.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tom A.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Other than the fact that the Shiv looks like a Speed Concept mated with a Felt and came out backwards (very ugly).....since the hydration tube is routed through the frame how do you clean it?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Scottxs] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You pull the hose and bladder out and clean it with soap and water.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Any thoughts about how the additional weight and size of the rear (particularly in wind) hydration impacts handling?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DFW_Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DFW_Tri wrote:
Any thoughts about how the additional weight and size of the rear (particularly in wind) hydration impacts handling?


My speculation: It might actually move the center of mass *lower* since it's well below the saddle, and most mass is above the saddle.

And it might move the center of pressure aft and lower being near the back and lower than most surface area.

Both those things generally correlate to good, stable bike handling from my lay understanding of bike physics.
Last edited by: trail: Oct 10, 18 19:30
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
One thing I really like about this bike, is that it RIDES like a bike. Its much more like a Venge than a Shiv in a lot of ways and makes it enjoyable. Its not a noodle, and its not a slug. Power transfer is excellent and the steering preciseness makes rolling and twisting roads a blast.

This will certainly get me onboard with a new Shiv (once the prices come down and I can get a frameset and build it up.) I love my <old> Shiv but every time I get on my Venge it makes me wish the Shiv handled and accelerated the same way. If you have found a way to make the new Shiv as enjoyable to ride as my Venge then I'm interested.

______________________________________________
Team Zoot
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DFW_Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DFW_Tri wrote:
Any thoughts about how the additional weight and size of the rear (particularly in wind) hydration impacts handling?

Generally speaking it is much improved. Most riders are accustomed to hanging a bottle or 2, as well as a flat kit amongst other things behind the saddle.

The new Shiv's solution takes this same need and distributes it lower on the bike helping improve handling and ride feel. Overtime, the CG lowers even more as you drain fluid which is a favorable thing.

As far as the size goes, the additional counterbalance of the rear reservoir often times reduces the effects of steering torque on the front axis...similar to a disc wheel helping reduce the crosswind effects of a deep front wheel
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jayski] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
 
Thanks cowboy7 and jayski for your feedbacks

jayski, ton francais est trĆØs bon !
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I like it. The sail doesn't bother me. Seems like a good location and very aero way to store a good portion of your fluids. Love the adjustable base bar. Way better looking bike than a P5X, Andean or Ventum in my opinion. I think tri bikes in general are getting pretty ugly, and this one is less ugly.

"The first virtue in a soldier is endurance of fatigue; courage is only the second virtue."
- Napoleon Bonaparte
Last edited by: Don_W: Oct 11, 18 2:48
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pyrenean Wolf wrote:

Thanks cowboy7 and jayski for your feedbacks

jayski, ton francais est trĆØs bon !

Thanks! I can type or write French pretty well but ask me to listen to a french person and then respond...my brain doesn't work quickly enough! I think that's why I like riding bikes and running - just go, no thinking required!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
Did you even read what I wrote? I said carry 4 bottles and refill at special needs.

Why carry so many? I scope out the map and look for aid station locations that fit my needs. I then carry as minimal bottles as possible to keep excess weight down. I donā€™t want to lug around bottles that I will use an hour or two later. We fight to save all these watts with bike design and clothes but then people put so much nutrition on their bike. Not saying you do that but weā€™ve all seen people who have enough nutrition to ride across Earth.

I know weight savings is a low priority so maybe this is the mountain bike racer in me where weight is a huge factor.

_________________________________
The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Does anyone know the weight of the bike?

Thanks
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Does anyone know the weight of the bike?

Thanks

it was mentioned a few posts back by the guy from specialized (i think)

--> 9kg race ready (no fluid)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Economist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Economist wrote:
BryanD wrote:
Did you even read what I wrote? I said carry 4 bottles and refill at special needs.

Why carry so many? I scope out the map and look for aid station locations that fit my needs. I then carry as minimal bottles as possible to keep excess weight down. I donā€™t want to lug around bottles that I will use an hour or two later. We fight to save all these watts with bike design and clothes but then people put so much nutrition on their bike. Not saying you do that but weā€™ve all seen people who have enough nutrition to ride across Earth.

I know weight savings is a low priority so maybe this is the mountain bike racer in me where weight is a huge factor.

Agreed. I carry one bottle on the bike during a race. There might be a few moments during a hot race I might have an extra bottle of water from an aid station but itā€™s rare.

Even with all the calories I take in I still manage to do it with just one bottle.

Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Economist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I will give you several reasons to consider minimizing use of on course nutrition
(1) you are stuck with whatever they are offering
(2) they are the most dangerous section of most courses-wet, volunteers, biker refilling etc
(3) aero or weight ā€œlossesā€, if any, may be regained when you donā€™t have to slow down at an aid station
(4) if you miss a bottle hand up you when biking by, you either have to stop and go back or wait
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DFW_Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DFW_Tri wrote:
I will give you several reasons to consider minimizing use of on course nutrition
(1) you are stuck with whatever they are offering
(2) they are the most dangerous section of most courses-wet, volunteers, biker refilling etc
(3) aero or weight ā€œlossesā€, if any, may be regained when you donā€™t have to slow down at an aid station
(4) if you miss a bottle hand up you when biking by, you either have to stop and go back or wait

all of this.

ive only done one 70.3, but i was very glad i had all my nutrition on board for the bike. the bike aid stations were a cluster.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
As far as the size goes, the additional counterbalance of the rear reservoir often times reduces the effects of steering torque on the front axis...similar to a disc wheel helping reduce the crosswind effects of a deep front wheel

Hmmm...so then for Kona, will they be banned, just like discs? :-/

I kid....I kid...

http://bikeblather.blogspot.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DFW_Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DFW_Tri wrote:
I will give you several reasons to consider minimizing use of on course nutrition
(1) you are stuck with whatever they are offering
(2) they are the most dangerous section of most courses-wet, volunteers, biker refilling etc
(3) aero or weight ā€œlossesā€, if any, may be regained when you donā€™t have to slow down at an aid station
(4) if you miss a bottle hand up you when biking by, you either have to stop and go back or wait

Those make sense. Iā€™ve seen many accidents at aid stations. Itā€™s certainly an individual decision. When I train I try to use same nutrition that will be on my ā€œAā€ race. If it doesnā€™t work then I do have to find a plan B. Never really had it not work. Also itā€™s not Just losing aero but also energy to haul around the excess weight.

I find it easy to mitigate the aid station issues by avoiding the beginning of the aid station. We all know there is a technique. Point to the person. Be loud and direct on what want. Be thankful to them when you leave. Iā€™ve never had an issue or a missed handoff in the aid station.

If you do it right the nutrition handoff takes just seconds. Iā€™d rather do that then use energy carrying full bottles. Keep in mind Iā€™m not stopping at every aid station. But this is my personal preference. If others have picky stomachs or nervous around aid stations then of course it makes sense to bypass.

Hard nutrition (gel, blocks, etc) I carry. I only use aid stations for fluid.

Obviously on shorter Races it differs. Sprint doesnā€™t require any on bike nutrition and Olys maybe just a small water bottle.

_________________________________
The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
You pull the hose and bladder out and clean it with soap and water.

You pull out the tubing, clean it, and have to re-route it back through the frame?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Scottxs] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yes. The hose routes through a channel in the frame making it easy to pull out and put back in.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
Yes. The hose routes through a channel in the frame making it easy to pull out and put back in.

Can you post a video showing how "easy" this is?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [walie] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ask GatorRacer since he helped design the bike. I'm only telling you what he said.

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
My name is Cam - and I'm the Product Manager for the all-new Shiv Disc. We're stoked to see all the feedback about the new bike.

We have some videos in the works to show routing of the hydration system and additional features of the bike. We're busy here in Kona, but I'll do my best to help answer any additional questions you all might have. Keith, the project's lead engineer, has already been on here between shifts at our display to help answer some other questions!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cam: there seems to be some confusion as to whether or not the cockpit allows for tilt adjustment. So far, we haven't seen any on ST or LC's bikes and LC runs a borderline mantis position. However, at one point on the EU site the new Shiv was listed as having 15 degrees of tilt adjustment. Could you clarify on this point?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi Cam,

Are there any plans to introduce a more affordable version of the new Shiv?

Signed...a happy Shiv Sport rider
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
Cam: there seems to be some confusion as to whether or not the cockpit allows for tilt adjustment. So far, we haven't seen any on ST or LC's bikes and LC runs a borderline mantis position. However, at one point on the EU site the new Shiv was listed as having 15 degrees of tilt adjustment. Could you clarify on this point?
Hey GreenPlease

Yes there is a 10deg fixed tilt option. This option adds ~6mm of stack. Lucy and Ben are running this adapter. Tim is also using tilt but an aftermarket solution.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm glad this is one of the first posts in this thread. The reactions I saw on social media were all high praise, but it's hideous. The parts that aren't hideous aren't anything new or interesting, kind of vanilla. Even seeing a pro riding one was humorous, seemed like it was only because he was obligated to ride it for press pics.

Brenden Macy
Sports & Entertainment Attorney
I am Drive. I am Grit. I am Determination.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi Cam,

Is it possible to pre - order the S-WORKS Shiv Disc but swapping the cranks for different size Dura Ace and also different wheels?

Thanks,

Brent
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BRGUST65] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BRGUST65 wrote:
Hi Cam,

Is it possible to pre - order the S-WORKS Shiv Disc but swapping the cranks for different size Dura Ace and also different wheels?

Thanks,

Brent

Hi Brent,

The only model that is currently available is the Limited Launch S-Works Shiv Disc. This bike has our SW Powercranks and Roval CLX 64 Disc wheels. We unfortunately are not able to offer custom options to swap parts. Which crank size and wheels were you interested in versus what is spec?

Also, if anyone would like to see the bike in person, we're still going to be open tomorrow from roughly 10am until 4pm. I'd love to chat through the new details of the bike! Pictures don't do the bike justice once you see it in person!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Per] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Per wrote:
Hi Cam,

Are there any plans to introduce a more affordable version of the new Shiv?

Signed...a happy Shiv Sport rider

Hi Per,

Thanks for the note - happy to hear you're on a Shiv Sport!

We currently only have the one launch edition bike available at the S-Works level. The Elite and Sport models got some updates to their specs and some new colorways for MY19.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for the quick response Cam. On the Medium I would use 165 or 167.5 - 53/39 cranks and Zipp NSW or HED 60/90 wheel set. Brent
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi Cam, great to have you here answering our questions!
I have been discussing this bike with an engineer working on composites. He is concerned about torsion resistance in the DT, which seems to be affected by the fuel cell opening. I am attaching a DT scan he sent me from another bike, which he claims to have a similar opening...
What do your tests show? Noodle or not?

EDIT: the image on the left is a standard DT, the one with the opening is on the right.

Sr. Salitre
Last edited by: SrSalitre: Oct 11, 18 22:01
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [SrSalitre] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SrSalitre wrote:
Hi Cam, great to have you here answering our questions!

I have been discussing this bike with an engineer working on composites. He is concerned about torsion resistance in the DT, which seems to be affected by the fuel cell opening. I am attaching a DT scan he sent me from another bike, which he claims to have a similar opening...
What do your tests show? Noodle or not?

EDIT: the image on the left is a standard DT, the one with the opening is on the right.

Hey SrSalitre - thanks for the question!

We have been working on SWAT for many years at Specialized and there have been countless FEA simulations and prototypes made of different configurations on many different bikes - most recently before the new Shiv was the new Stumpjumper. The same engineers who helped with the new Stumpy SWAT also did this SWAT (which we're calling the Fuelcell on Shiv). From what they tell me and how I feel it rides, it's plenty stiff - certainly no complaints.

I asked one of the composite engineers who has been a big part of the Shiv's development. He said, "It's definitely not a noodle. The hole is molded and not machined so we can add reinforcement plies all around the hole to help better distribute the loads. Sure, if the hole wasn't there we could cut some additional weight out of the frame - but that's not why we engineered the frame the way we did. The spot where the hole ended up was the best compromise of a place that is easily accessible for the rider while racing but takes the least amount of weight to get the stiffness back. I like where the Stumpy's hole is better from an overall optimization of weight/stiffness, but putting it way lower doesn't serve this rider properly."

Edit: formatting...
Last edited by: Cam Piper: Oct 11, 18 22:49
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Great first post.

Ken


"the trick is to keep losing weight until your friends and family ask you if you've been sick. then you know you're within 10 pounds. if they start whispering to each other, wondering if you've got cancer or aids, you're within 5. when they actually do an intervention, you're at race weight." - Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jkhayc] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jkhayc wrote:
The fact that Specialized spent hundreds of thousands and millions? on researching, designing, and building a new tri bike should make everyone cream their pants while we participate in this sport that is dying, but no we as a community feel the need to nitpick the shit out of it. Stupid.

Ummm No. What you describe is call the market. Its what you do if you want to build and sell bikes. Just because Specialized built a bike to get YOU to spend YOUR money doesn't mean anyone should "cream their pants". I guess you do that every time you go to the store and buy bread because we participate in this sport and that takes carbohydrates?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [SrSalitre] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It's a triathlon bike, not a track bike, crit bike, "climbing" bike, or even TT bike. While it presumably could have greater downtube torsional stiffness without the fuel cell opening, does it really need to? For a bike that's primarily intended to be ridden at a steady, well-below-maximal effort, and generally in a straight line, there's a certain threshold of adequate stiffness beyond which performance for the intended purpose isn't really enhanced.

"They're made of latex, not nitroglycerin"
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gary p] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
right on---and this has been done for some time in the MTB world with these openings and they do fine. using it as a tri bike worries me very little
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Scottxs] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i don't think you actually understand the intent of my post. not that i'm surprised.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I accept payments via check/paypal, but here's your marketing materials, also don't sell any of these to men because your marketing should focus only on women based on this time split improvement.

Lucy Charles Legacy S-Works SHIV 2017 Bike Split-4:58:19
Lucy Charles S-Works Sail Equipped SHIV 2018 Bike Split-4:38:11

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Post deleted by windschatten [ In reply to ]
Last edited by: windschatten: Oct 13, 18 21:29
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [windschatten] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yeah...again, the masses don't read slowtwitch though. You have Lucie go on tour promoting the bike to major Specialized dealers packaged with some women for tri events and go: "This bike helped me go 20 minutes faster at Kona". It's marketing man...sort of like movie themed cereal.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [windschatten] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
And they did it not looking as ugly. Looking at the stationary photos and video of it I thought well if itā€™s inovative it you could learn to love it but it looked ugly on the telecast.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I really like what you've done. It's clever. The fork design is similar to the Avanti Pista, and we know that turbulence around the wheel is huge. Could you please show us some CFD results to illustrate airflows?

Most of the commentary here misses the point - it doesn't matter how the bike rides clean, it matters how it rides with nutrition (please don't call it fuel) and drinks on board. That's partly Specialized's fault for not making it explicit, but they probably saw the backlash from Cervelo taping 12 gels to the toptube and decided to play it safe.

I'd like to see this in black. The hypercolour paint scheme doesn't do anything for me, and might be another reason the scofflaws aren't taking this seriously.

'It never gets easier, you just get crazier.'
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
I accept payments via check/paypal, but here's your marketing materials, also don't sell any of these to men because your marketing should focus only on women based on this time split improvement.

Lucy Charles Legacy S-Works SHIV 2017 Bike Split-4:58:19
Lucy Charles S-Works Sail Equipped SHIV 2018 (with hydration lid flapping in the wind) Bike Split-4:38:11

FTFY
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [awenborn] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Check the pictures on tririg. Gomez used electrical tape to keep the lid on the hydration thing. Sarah True had hers taped down as well. Apparently some knew it would stay seated. With as long as we waited for the "new shiv", stuff like this seems very short sited by one of the biggest players in the game.
Last edited by: Mike Alexander: Oct 14, 18 6:28
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [georged] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
georged wrote:
I really like what you've done. It's clever. The fork design is similar to the Avanti Pista, and we know that turbulence around the wheel is huge. Could you please show us some CFD results to illustrate airflows?

Most of the commentary here misses the point - it doesn't matter how the bike rides clean, it matters how it rides with nutrition (please don't call it fuel) and drinks on board. That's partly Specialized's fault for not making it explicit, but they probably saw the backlash from Cervelo taping 12 gels to the toptube and decided to play it safe.

I'd like to see this in black. The hypercolour paint scheme doesn't do anything for me, and might be another reason the scofflaws aren't taking this seriously.

They have a Bento Box that is on the down tube and have lasts on the frame for a cage or another bento. Personally I don't like where their Bento is overall, but hey...if you can learn to reach that far you'll be alright...much easier than refilling the sail tank on the go.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi Cam,
Since the S-Works app tells me, that I am right in between size S and M I was wondering what the main differences are between the sizes. Is the hydration system way smaller in S and what would be your recommendation?


BTW:
Did you guys see Braidn Curries solution for refilling the tank on the fly? Pretty interesting. He cut off a bottle an than linked it with a pipe to the big tank.


Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
that is awesome!

that bike looks WAY better with a rider on it.

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

ā€œYou are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.ā€
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
Yeah...again, the masses don't read slowtwitch though. You have Lucie go on tour promoting the bike to major Specialized dealers packaged with some women for tri events and go: "This bike helped me go 20 minutes faster at Kona". It's marketing man...sort of like movie themed cereal.

You don't need to go that far in marketing, delivering a bullshit time comparison.

The price is enough.
"14k USD, waoowwww, must bee faaaaassst"
It will be enough for many !
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hi Cam,
Since the S-Works app tells me, that I am right in between size S and M I was wondering what the main differences are between the sizes. Is the hydration system way smaller in S and what would be your recommendation?


BTW:
Did you guys see Braidn Curries solution for refilling the tank on the fly? Pretty interesting. He cut off a bottle an than linked it with a pipe to the big tank.


Its a beer bong solution to a bad design.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Scottxs] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Agree. Specialized needs to sort that hydration system issue. At first look I was sure that could be a problem. The actual racing, with Lucie's problem, Javi taping his down, and Braden having to do some backyard engineering, this system is clearly ill-considered. This is just bad engineering. Surely it was not tested adequately under duress prior to this race. First race out and three significant issues on their highest placed athletes' bikes.

Back to the drawing board, Spec.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DFW_Tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DFW_Tri wrote:
A bike optimized for Kona...?????!! I mean seriously, the number of athletes doing Kona who might consider buying this bike is what....at the very most like 100 (and more likely 25-50)....compared to the potential tri bike buying population that number is tiny. What a stupid marketing strategy.

In term of reality, this is very true. On the other hand, look how well hard core SUV's sell when the large majority of people who buy them will nevertake them off road. It's all about marketing to people's wishes and dreams, not reality...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [helo guy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Indeed; good analogy. Given the fiasco over the wknd, itā€™s obviously all marketing bs
Last edited by: DFW_Tri: Oct 15, 18 9:22
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hi Cam,
Since the S-Works app tells me, that I am right in between size S and M I was wondering what the main differences are between the sizes. Is the hydration system way smaller in S and what would be your recommendation?

Hi Chris_Mint, as long as you can achieve your saddle height on the larger size, we'd recommend going for the Medium. Slightly large capacity for the hydration fuel cell (~100ml) and a bigger aero gain in crosswinds due to some additional surface area. Also, a potentially more compact cockpit.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [helo guy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
helo guy wrote:
DFW_Tri wrote:
A bike optimized for Kona...?????!! I mean seriously, the number of athletes doing Kona who might consider buying this bike is what....at the very most like 100 (and more likely 25-50)....compared to the potential tri bike buying population that number is tiny. What a stupid marketing strategy.


In term of reality, this is very true. On the other hand, look how well hard core SUV's sell when the large majority of people who buy them will nevertake them off road. It's all about marketing to people's wishes and dreams, not reality...


Also, "optimized for Kona" doesn't necessarily mean it's bad for other courses. In fact being optimized for Kona probably fits well with other courses that are similar in nature. Sure it might not be ideal for some of the most mountainous courses, but you can't optimize for both. Maybe "optimized for ___ conditions" would have been a better tagline, where you could fill in the course conditions and styles the bike is best on. Specifically calling out Kona when most people won't go there though does make the bike seem a bit more out of reach, and bit more unneeded than it otherwise would be.
Last edited by: JLars: Oct 15, 18 12:09
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [JLars] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
JLars wrote:
helo guy wrote:
DFW_Tri wrote:
A bike optimized for Kona...?????!! I mean seriously, the number of athletes doing Kona who might consider buying this bike is what....at the very most like 100 (and more likely 25-50)....compared to the potential tri bike buying population that number is tiny. What a stupid marketing strategy.


In term of reality, this is very true. On the other hand, look how well hard core SUV's sell when the large majority of people who buy them will nevertake them off road. It's all about marketing to people's wishes and dreams, not reality...


Also, "optimized for Kona" doesn't necessarily mean it's bad for other courses. In fact being optimized for Kona probably fits well with other courses that are similar in nature. Sure it might not be ideal for some of the most mountainous courses, but you can't optimize for both. Maybe "optimized for ___ conditions" would have been a better tagline, where you could fill in the course conditions and styles the bike is best on. Specifically calling out Kona when most people won't go there though does make the bike seem a bit more out of reach, and bit more unneeded than it otherwise would be.

You have a valid point. I was assuming that ā€œoptimized for Konaā€ meant it was best for high yaw conditions (for instance as opposed to a P-5 which performs best relative to other bikes at low yaw). The big sail/water tank in back would tend to support that but Specialized might mean something else or it could be pure marketing.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Awesome photos of the Shiv here https://www.tririg.com/...Specialized_New_Shiv

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
Awesome photos of the Shiv here https://www.tririg.com/...Specialized_New_Shiv
Can't wait to ride it around IM Lanzarote. Not hoping for crosswinds though (nor leaky fuel cells :-) )
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The more I look at the new Shiv, the more I think with some creative paint patterns it could be a very cool looking bike.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
My quick first concept....I like the idea of designing the paint to keep the top tube design flat across the fuel cell, elongates the bike, and seems to flow better to me aesthetically....


Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mile2424] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I like it! That looks worlds better. DM that to the Specialized people here in the thread and maybe DM it to Specialized on Instagram/Facebook as well.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks!!!

I know a few of the guys there and the graphic designer. They do a good job on their own and Iā€™m sure they will have some cool ideas once the actual bikes and non limited version release if we can assume it will eventually.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The GMAN wrote:
BryanD wrote:
You drink 2 bottles of water in 30 miles?


You don't?

That's for an average temperature ride. During a hot race I will drink two bottles per hour.

Last IM I did I drank seven bottles of Perform by the halfway point of the bike.

Last 70.3 I did I drank six bottles of water or Gatorade in two and half hours.


Whaaaaa?????? How many stops at the porta-potty?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Scottxs] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Scottxs wrote:


Whaaaaa?????? How many stops at the porta-potty?

I drink a bottle (regular day) or 1.5 bottles (hot day) at every aid station. Pee a little while riding 2-3 times and start the run hydrated!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BigBoyND] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'll drink 1 bottle an hour easy..500ml ~20+ miles
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Scottxs] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Scottxs wrote:
The GMAN wrote:
BryanD wrote:
You drink 2 bottles of water in 30 miles?


You don't?

That's for an average temperature ride. During a hot race I will drink two bottles per hour.

Last IM I did I drank seven bottles of Perform by the halfway point of the bike.

Last 70.3 I did I drank six bottles of water or Gatorade in two and half hours.



Whaaaaa?????? How many stops at the porta-potty?

During a 70.3? Zero stops and zero pissing on the bike. I wait until I get back to T2 or start the run.

During an IM, depends on if I feel like stopping to rest for a couple of minutes or if I pee on the bike. Either way... two or three potty breaks.

Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [gregtay] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Wow, that is clean. Sure would seem like it should test just as fast. Do you have more pics of your slick bike? that's inspirational.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Here are some images of the transport bag which will come with the limited edition:




While the last images is obviously from tririg.com the other three I found on instagram (@velocity_nn)

TBH: If you take out the price for the transport bag and the powermeter you almost end up with the same price tag than the Canyon Speedmax CF SLX. And I donĀ“t know how it is in the rest of the world but in Europe you cannot go to a bike dealer for a fit or anything else with a Canyon or other online-brands. They are not happy to help you with Canyons. Therefor I feel the price of the S-Works is quite fair and it is still cheaper than the P5X or the new Felt IA. After all I actually got used to the new look of the Shiv disc.

I wonder if it is already sold out.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Here are some images of the transport bag which will come with the limited edition:




While the last images is obviously from tririg.com the other three I found on instagram (@velocity_nn)

TBH: If you take out the price for the transport bag and the powermeter you almost end up with the same price tag than the Canyon Speedmax CF SLX. And I donĀ“t know how it is in the rest of the world but in Europe you cannot go to a bike dealer for a fit or anything else with a Canyon or other online-brands. They are not happy to help you with Canyons. Therefor I feel the price of the S-Works is quite fair and it is still cheaper than the P5X or the new Felt IA. After all I actually got used to the new look of the Shiv disc.

I wonder if it is already sold out.

Yeah, that's the reason i managed to pursy... for a complete triathlon bike, it is still expensive but not as 'over the top' as the Felt FRD which sets you back 16k Euro without powermeter or bike case/bag.

My local (belgian) specialized website mentions that it is sold out as of the 17th.

But they'd better starting producing and delivering them as racing seasons starts early May here while their delivery dates are April :-)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
And I donĀ“t know how it is in the rest of the world but in Europe you cannot go to a bike dealer for a fit or anything else with a Canyon or other online-brands. They are not happy to help you with Canyons.
You don't need to go to a bike dealer for a fit; in the US you can go to a localized fitter. Before I got my Canyon road bike I went to Ero Sports where the fit helped me decide which bike to get and which size. Then once I got it I went back to have it set up just right.

And you can always go to your local bike shop to get something fixed; in times of yelp reviews and social media it's in their best interest to serve the customer. They can make money by fixing your bike whereas they make nothing if you go elsewhere.

And finally - we now also have Velofix which comes to your house to fix your bike by appointment. I haven't used it yet but I can only imagine it being very convenient. Point being that the direct to consumer model has enough support systems for a good customer experience.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Therefore I feel the price of the S-Works is quite fair and it is still cheaper than the P5X or the new Felt IA.


You should be more specific. You can get the new Felt IA disc with Ultegra for $6,125. You can get one with eTap for $8,275. You can also get a P5x for $12K. Or you can order framesets for either bike, right now, should you prefer your own powermeter, travel case, or a racing wheelset with a rear disc.

Of course that will presumably change in 6 months. Or a year. Or something. But since you used present tense, I'm holding you to present facts.
Last edited by: trail: Oct 25, 18 6:55
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Very nice!

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
You should be more specific. You can get the new Felt IA disc with Ultegra for $6,125. You can get one with eTap for $8,275. You can also get a P5x for $12K. Or you can order framesets for either bike, right now, should you prefer your own powermeter, travel case, or a racing wheelset with a rear disc.

Of course that will presumably change in 6 months. Or a year. Or something. But since you used present tense, I'm holding you to present facts.

I think it's pretty clear he was referring to similarly equipped models, not the ones with 105 and aluminum training wheels
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BigBoyND] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BigBoyND wrote:

I think it's pretty clear he was referring to similarly equipped models, not the ones with 105 and aluminum training wheels

Wasn't clear to me. Also, eTap, Ultegra, and HED Jets included in their. I'd call eTap with Jets second to none in group and wheel spec.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mile2424] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Inspired by Martini racing cars colors ?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Pyrenean Wolf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Correct!! I did a martini shiv on the old nose cone version a while back.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Been a while.
But I found some nice detail shots from this website:
https://grove-miyamaedaira.com/category_road/4376


Anyone has information when they are going to ship it and if there are any changes to the bike that we saw at WC2019?


Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
maarten.claes wrote:
I donĀ“t know how it is in the rest of the world but in Europe you cannot go to a bike dealer for a fit or anything else with a Canyon or other online-brands. They are not happy to help you with Canyons.

Really? It's all business to local bike shops. I have taken my Canyon to the LBS for work to be done on it, and I have no doubt I could get a fit done by a store that sells other brands; they're not going to turn me away when they could make Ā£Ā£Ā£ (certainly stores with fit franchises like Retul).

If Bike shops only worked on brands they stocked, they'd soon go out of business these days.

29 years and counting
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Jorgan] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jorgan wrote:
maarten.claes wrote:
I donĀ“t know how it is in the rest of the world but in Europe you cannot go to a bike dealer for a fit or anything else with a Canyon or other online-brands. They are not happy to help you with Canyons.


Really? It's all business to local bike shops. I have taken my Canyon to the LBS for work to be done on it, and I have no doubt I could get a fit done by a store that sells other brands; they're not going to turn me away when they could make Ā£Ā£Ā£ (certainly stores with fit franchises like Retul).

If Bike shops only worked on brands they stocked, they'd soon go out of business these days.


That might be different in the US since Canyon is also a quite new brand to that market. But in Europe no one really wants to put hands on a Canyon. And even Canyon would ask you to send the bikes rather back to them in Germany than going to a local dealer.
I think people really should consider this when buying a new bike.
TMO if you really love your sport than you also want to support the people living from the sport like the bike dealers, shops and service centers. I would always prefer to go to my local dealer, have a chat and some insights than ordering everything online. That doesnĀ“t really help the sport to grow at all. Knowing this I can understand why many people start avoiding brands such as Canyon, Poison or Diamond Back as well as I can also understand why regular shops would not support you or repair your bike. Please also consider that the more exclusive your bike gets (Speedmax, Ultimate...) the more unique parts are built in and Retailers such as Canyon and Poison are not distributing these parts to workshops or retailers. Meaning if your unique cockpit breaks for your Canyon who have to send it to them and pay whatever they ask for it.
I would always prefer a prestigious bike from one of the big brands that are pushing the boundaries of our sport and support all of there customers but I can also understand that you might want to go for a Canyon or Poison if you think this is a better price-performance ratio.


As long as we all have fun with the sport that we are loving
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:


As long as we all have fun with the sport that we are loving

+ A long as we get our new shiv delivered well before our first 2019 (spring) events start ? :-)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
That might be different in the US since Canyon is also a quite new brand to that market. But in Europe no one really wants to put hands on a Canyon. And even Canyon would ask you to send the bikes rather back to them in Germany than going to a local dealer.
I think people really should consider this when buying a new bike.
TMO if you really love your sport than you also want to support the people living from the sport like the bike dealers, shops and service centers. I would always prefer to go to my local dealer, have a chat and some insights than ordering everything online. That doesnĀ“t really help the sport to grow at all. Knowing this I can understand why many people start avoiding brands such as Canyon, Poison or Diamond Back as well as I can also understand why regular shops would not support you or repair your bike. Please also consider that the more exclusive your bike gets (Speedmax, Ultimate...) the more unique parts are built in and Retailers such as Canyon and Poison are not distributing these parts to workshops or retailers. Meaning if your unique cockpit breaks for your Canyon who have to send it to them and pay whatever they ask for it.
I would always prefer a prestigious bike from one of the big brands that are pushing the boundaries of our sport and support all of there customers but I can also understand that you might want to go for a Canyon or Poison if you think this is a better price-performance ratio.


As long as we all have fun with the sport that we are loving

I think you may be extrapolating a trend from insufficient data here. I've done a lot of asking around recently as I was concerned about this and I'm looking at a Canyon road bike. None of my contacts has ever had an issue getting a Canyon worked on. I've had responses from people all across the US, Western Europe and Australia (and some significantly farther afield), at a good range of bike price-points and operator tech-competency levels. Yes, really complicated repairs may need the bike sending back to the factory but those are pretty rare and I had exactly the same with my better half's Felt. They wanted it sending back rather than to a dealership.

I agree with wanting to support people who work in the industry, but the people behind Canyon etc. also work in this industry. The amount of bad (and frequently unsolicited) advice I've had from bike shops over the years is pretty astounding and generally skews heavily towards 'you should totally buy this thing that I totally happen to have in stock in approximately the right size'. It's understandable human nature but why should I or anyone else want to support that over someone else who works elsewhere in the industry? I've found bike shops in the US and the Netherlands to be a little better than their British and German counterparts but there's still a whole load of bs sales pitches that masquerade as 'advice'.

As for the 'prestigious bike' part, I do kind of agree in that I really do like a nice shiny big brand bike(!) :-) though everyone has their own preferences here. However, you say that they support all their customers and push the boundaries of the sport. Have you tried getting customer support from Cannondale or Pinarello*? It can be woeful**! Spesh are great... as long as you're in the right country. If you're a customer in a smaller country without its own local opco then good luck! I'd also argue that it's often not just the big names pushing the boundaries. They are the ones with the marketing budgets to shout about the boundaries they ARE pushing but there's a fair bit of innovation coming from smaller or niche brands too. The Boardman TTE was a nightmare bike for so many reasons but it didn't half test well in a tunnel!

* I know it's more of a road bike prestige brand but still...
** but is also sometimes excellent just to be confusing
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ejls2] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
My Speedmax arrived with a dodgy di2 shifter. Canyon shipped me the part (when no one else in the country could get it) and were happy for me to get my LBS to fit it and then reimburse me.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [benb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm glad to hear it! :-)

I just heard back from another friend who had a similar issue, but with an aero-extension and she says Canyon were very helpful and her LBS did the work, no questions asked. I pinged my LBS (because this thread was making me paranoid!) and asked them what they honestly thought and they said they absolutely wouldn't work on my shiny new Canyon... unless they got to take it out for a 'test-ride' ;-)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey there,

I was actually wondering if anyone knows about the delivery date of the new Shiv.
The last date that I got from Specialized was the 06.04. (For the European market) but this seems to be postponed (maybe to end of April???!)

Finger crossed.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hey there,

I was actually wondering if anyone knows about the delivery date of the new Shiv.
The last date that I got from Specialized was the 06.04. (For the European market) but this seems to be postponed (maybe to end of April???!)

Finger crossed.

My dealer says June (end of) - Belgium. Pretty pissed about it considering IM Lanzarote end of May.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
maarten.claes wrote:
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hey there,

I was actually wondering if anyone knows about the delivery date of the new Shiv.
The last date that I got from Specialized was the 06.04. (For the European market) but this seems to be postponed (maybe to end of April???!)

Finger crossed.


My dealer says June (end of) - Belgium. Pretty pissed about it considering IM Lanzarote end of May.

WHAAAT??!?!?
June???

I have two 70.3 in May and one in June. I would definetly pi.... unhappy if it would come once my season is over....
I really hope, that there will be some official information from Specialized soon.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hey there,

I was actually wondering if anyone knows about the delivery date of the new Shiv.
The last date that I got from Specialized was the 06.04. (For the European market) but this seems to be postponed (maybe to end of April???!)

Finger crossed.

Hi Chris_Mint,

We are providing updated delivery timing in our communication to riders this week! Any dates that were previously provided are likely later than the actual delivery dates. Keep your eyes peeled on your inbox/check with your retailer again at the end of the week!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cam Piper wrote:
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hey there,

I was actually wondering if anyone knows about the delivery date of the new Shiv.
The last date that I got from Specialized was the 06.04. (For the European market) but this seems to be postponed (maybe to end of April???!)

Finger crossed.


Hi Chris_Mint,

We are providing updated delivery timing in our communication to riders this week! Any dates that were previously provided are likely later than the actual delivery dates. Keep your eyes peeled on your inbox/check with your retailer again at the end of the week!



any updates you can share? there is no information from my dealer .. they know nothing yet.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Same here. Havn't heard anything. :-/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Still nothing from my dealer. They said their calls have gone unanswered. Iā€™m not sure if itā€™s a production delay or part spec delay. Pretty close to asking for my deposit back and jumping on the Felt train.
Last edited by: jrcarson: Apr 8, 19 19:22
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jrcarson] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jrcarson wrote:
Still nothing from my dealer. They said their calls have gone unanswered. Iā€™m not sure if itā€™s a production delay or part spec delay. Pretty close to asking for my deposit back and jumping on the Felt train.


sign of life! My dealer was told by specialized (in sweden) that they will deliver in early May..

I hope this doesn't change now ..
Last edited by: pingu: Apr 12, 19 5:07
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
No news on this side of the world. I asked two or three Specialized Concept Stores here but still they have no updates. The only rumors that I got from them is that the bikes should either come by mid of May or even end of June. The official customer support here told me that they also donĀ“t have any news but they are "sure" that the bikes will be here soon.

Also I am wondering if this is a delivery or production issue or if they found some flaws or manufacturing defects.
Would be just great if we could plan a bit in advance...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
No news on this side of the world. I asked two or three Specialized Concept Stores here but still they have no updates. The only rumors that I got from them is that the bikes should either come by mid of May or even end of June. The official customer support here told me that they also donĀ“t have any news but they are "sure" that the bikes will be here soon.

Also I am wondering if this is a delivery or production issue or if they found some flaws or manufacturing defects.
Would be just great if we could plan a bit in advance...

Hi Chris - where are you located? I will check in with your specific market to ensure someone follows up with you.

We have another communication going out to riders by mid-week. I'll be available in the second half of this week to help answer any additional questions you might have and to ensure you received this communication! Will keep an eye on this thread.

Thank you all for your patience - this bike is worth the wait. We're excited to see some fast splits this year!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [jrcarson] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jrcarson wrote:
Still nothing from my dealer. They said their calls have gone unanswered. Iā€™m not sure if itā€™s a production delay or part spec delay. Pretty close to asking for my deposit back and jumping on the Felt train.

Hi jrcarson, where are you located? Shoot me a PM with some more information, and we'll make sure you're getting the information you need from us!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Too bad that there are still no news. I guess since also the end of April is quite close it seems to be more likely that the worst case comes true and we will only get the bike once the season is over ;/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hello Chris, there is something new with you about the new shiv.
I am still waiting for a promise, when the shiv finally comes. Unfortunately still no info. Think also that it does not come in may
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [grokster] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
grokster wrote:
Hello Chris, there is something new with you about the new shiv.
I am still waiting for a promise, when the shiv finally comes. Unfortunately still no info. Think also that it does not come in may

Hi Grokster,

The Limited Edition Shivs are currently delivering to retailers! Could you send me a PM with some additional information about where you're located and I can dig into when your bike should be landing? Thanks!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [grokster] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey there,

I got informed by my retailer that some of the Shivs arrived in Europe and that they are on their way to the retailers. But I donĀ“t know if that means that they will arrive rather today or in 2 weeks but as far as I know the goal is to have everyone sitting on their new bike by end of the month.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi,
would be great, that all can drive soon
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hey there,

I got informed by my retailer that some of the Shivs arrived in Europe and that they are on their way to the retailers. But I donĀ“t know if that means that they will arrive rather today or in 2 weeks but as far as I know the goal is to have everyone sitting on their new bike by end of the month.

Hi Chris,

I just got from my retailer that my bike is in Rotterdam, Holland and will be shipped to me (I'm in sweden) today!

fingers x...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I got similar information.
Rumour has it that my bike is currently at the Specialized HQ (where ever that is...) and should be shipped soon.
But I donĀ“t know how they will be delivered and how long it will take. I am afraid it wonĀ“t be an overnight flight. Lets see.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pingu wrote:
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hey there,

I got informed by my retailer that some of the Shivs arrived in Europe and that they are on their way to the retailers. But I donĀ“t know if that means that they will arrive rather today or in 2 weeks but as far as I know the goal is to have everyone sitting on their new bike by end of the month.


Hi Chris,

I just got from my retailer that my bike is in Rotterdam, Holland and will be shipped to me (I'm in sweden) today!

fingers x...

That's good news (at least for you :-) ). I hope mine is arriving in that same batch then. Rotterdam - Antwerp is a <60' drive
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Specialized HQ is in SF, USA?

My bike will go by trailer/boat so there is still a few days of travelling before it is "home"




Chris_Mint wrote:
I got similar information.

Rumour has it that my bike is currently at the Specialized HQ (where ever that is...) and should be shipped soon.
But I donĀ“t know how they will be delivered and how long it will take. I am afraid it wonĀ“t be an overnight flight. Lets see.

Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
My Shiv arrived in Australia last week. Our shop will be assembling it over the next week as I donā€™t have any races coming up. The paint is amazing the way it changes colors in the sunlight and shade. If it rides as good as it looks it will be incredible
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Badger2501] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Mine arrived today. Awesome looking bike. Can pick it up for a first spin next tuesday!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Finally the time has comešŸ˜ŠI pick up my bike at Friday.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [grokster] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
3 rides now on the beauty. KOM on every ride ;)

love it!!

just ONE thing... why a 160mm disc rotor on back?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pingu wrote:
3 rides now on the beauty. KOM on every ride ;)

love it!!

just ONE thing... why a 160mm disc rotor on back?

Excited to hear you received your bike and have been enjoying the ride!

As the industry moves to disc brake components and these components evolve, and with triathlon joining this movement, we decided to be more progressive with the choice to add 160mm rotors. Some component manufacturers are choosing 160mm rotors as the best experience for the riders - and it also opens up some additional clearance to allow for more wheel options - especially with disc disc wheels in the rear. Pushing the caliper away from the drop outs increases the clearance to spokes/hub/wheels. With a minimal aero impact in the rear, and with the added benefits noted above, it was the best decision for this platform.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
since owners are now getting these bikes can you all give some feedback on thoughts on the bike other than ā€œitā€™s awesome and omg so fastā€? details on your thoughts on the integrated hydration, does it really handle more like a road bike than a tri bike as specialized has said?

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Last edited by: damon.lebeouf: Jun 13, 19 9:32
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey Cameron,

Can we expect a frameset option for this bike?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
since owners are now getting these bikes can you all give some feedback on thoughts on the bike other than ā€œitā€™s awesome and omg so fastā€? details on your thoughts on the integrated hydration, does it really handle more like a road bike than a tri bike as specialized has said?

I hade the ā€oldā€ shiv s-works and my first impression was that it is stiffer. I have my first 70.3 in 3 weeks. Can give u an honest say after that ;)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Had my first ride on this today. Sweet ride. KOM and plenty of PR. Fast as hell but surprisingly similar to the speed concept 9.9
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
since owners are now getting these bikes can you all give some feedback on thoughts on the bike other than ā€œitā€™s awesome and omg so fastā€? details on your thoughts on the integrated hydration, does it really handle more like a road bike than a tri bike as specialized has said?

Mine was delivered a good 1.5 weeks before IM Lanzarote so - obviously - I took the new ShivDisc with me and left the old, reliable ShivPro 2012 (sram force 10s, FFWD 60mm) at home.

* Got used to the synchro shifting after a few short rides. coming from a near perfect sram force setup, the DI2 synchro shift is next level though. Especially in windy/hilly conditions, being able to shift on the base bars is really nice. Not to win minutes, but it means comfort and thatā€™s want you want on the 180k bike ride.
* My 'feeling' with the new ShivDisc compared to the 2012 Shiv is that it is much 'stiffer'. I'm probably not using the right word as I donā€™t mean stiffer frame only. It just feels like everything is 'bolted together better' and that results in the feeling that it's much faster.
* Cross winds: I trained with the 2012 shiv in Lanzarote earlier in the year and the crosswinds often were pretty terrifying (up to the point I needed to hit the brakes on certain straight descents midway). On race day, with the ShivDisc, my <feeling> was that it stood up much better to the crosswinds. Again, a feeling but I remained confident pretty much all the time and I had the impression that the forces on my front wheel were much less compared to the 2012 shiv. To me, "it cuts through the wind".
Never had the impression that 'the sail' aka the rear hydration unit was pushing me around in crosswinds.

* Either my old FFWD wheels are 'end of life', or those new Roval 64 wheels reallly 'turn frictionless'. Driving on a flat road, stop pedalling and the bike seems to keep on going much better. Again, a good feeling that it is better than the old one. Probably not a surprise given that the ShivDisc has premium components all over the place and that it's brand new. But I clearly notice the wheels turn much better.
* Brakes... OMG.. the brakes on my 2012 Shiv are so shitty I nearly had to start braking at the top of a descent in order to get it stopped at the bottom of the hill (my friend's new canyon TT with rim brakes pretty awesome too so its not that rim brakes are bad in general,... just my rim brakes ;-) ). So for me, the stopping power of the ShivDisc is insane. I'm sure it saved me at least a minute or two on the bike leg of a long Ironman.. On faster descents (70-80 kph), i did hear a strange noise coming from the brake system (like som parts were about to fly off off the bike). Either i need to have this checked or its normal.. don't know. On one descent, the rear brake starting making a really loud noise to the point that it was somewhat embarrassing. The noise went away on the next hill descent though.
* Fuel Cell - Hydration Unit: This was the biggest change I had to get used to in the 1.5 weeks before the race. My race setup ultimately consisted of the fuel cell for 5-6 gels and three salt tablets, an xlab torpedo mounted on the TT bars, a xlab gorrilla cage on the down?tube and the rear hydration unit.
Fuel Cell: Easy to stick my repair kit under the fuel cell, that's good. The fuelcell itself, although it is positioned lower than the xlab 'poche' i had installed on my toptube on the 2012 shiv, is easily reachable. Happy.
Hydration Unit: For me, this is the only part on the bike that I think needs improvements. The lid doesnt stay fixed so I had taped it for the race. Refill on the go is next to impossible (and I dont think it was designed to do that). But that means that you have like two bottles of fluid in there and once youā€™ve emptied it, the rear hydration unit is 'useless'. And for me, two bottles is 2 hours in what ended up to be a 6u30 bike ride. I noticed on instagram that Braden Currie tried a hack wit an inverted bottle pouring liquids right into the hydration system . It confirms a bit that other people (even pro's) also think the hydration system works well but a good refill option is not available. So for the remaining 4u30, i used the xlab torpedo and downtube cage to refill and store liquids.
Inserting my hydration bladder and connecting it to the 'drinking tube/hose' is really difficult as it seems the bladder is a bit short. Tried all sorts of things and with some 'pressure' you get the bladder connected to the hose but it is far from user friendly. I don't think its going to last long. Well, in fact, my bladder is leaking already - bummer. Drinking from it, however, is a pleasure. So ideally, I want to refill on the go and connecting the bladder to the hose much easier.

* Case - Flight: I used a hard case before and the soft case looks very fragile at first. I was really anxious to put my brand new, premium bike in such a case. Removed pedals, loosened the cockpit, took off the rear derailleur and taped it to the inside of the frame. I didnt remove the saddle/seat post as I thought leaving the rear hydration unit on there without any 'cushioning' would leave it very vulnerable to breaking off . So I lowered the seatpost so that that would absorbe an impact and not the plastic hydration unit. again, dissambling the hydration unit is a bit of a pita. Removed the arm pads as well from the cockpit. Wheels fit nicely. Lots of extra room to store my helmet, spare parts, bottles etc. Weighed 25 kgs so well under the 30kg limit that my airline uses. Bike made it to and from Lanzarote in one piece! Most stressful moments of the trip I admit :-)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
best bike review EVER.

thanks so much for taking the time to write all that up!!!

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The brake noise is mostly like due to expansion heating and is completely normal. Mountain bikers have tried a million things to improve the issue with but itā€™s just one of those things.

Brake technique is a big factor and you need to learn not to drag to brake but rather use shot intense pulses when riding discs. (A quick google will pull up lots of videos on the topic). On mountain bike people have also moved to larger rotors but that isnā€™t a solution for you.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Good review...thanks! Aside from the bladder being sort of inaccessible to refill on race day, are you happy with your purchase? Anything else you've uncovered during rides with it thats worth noting?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
best bike review EVER.

thanks so much for taking the time to write all that up!!!

I hesitated alot to put it up on ST :-) My first review ever and triathletes are not an easy audience, damn perfectionists :-) .
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [spectrum5825] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
spectrum5825 wrote:
Good review...thanks! Aside from the bladder being sort of inaccessible to refill on race day, are you happy with your purchase? Anything else you've uncovered during rides with it thats worth noting?

I'm really happy yes. Now, I must admit I only have Specialized bikes (1x shiv disc, 1x shiv pro, 1x venge, 1x stumpjumper, 1x allez ) so it would be really difficult for me to say this bike is anything other than impressive :-) Plus i'm not an expert biker, i ride since 2016.

But I love taking it out for a spin, even if it's a 2u30' LSD, recovery ride. And in the end, that is what matters to most riders. Great if it can win races like Lucy C or Braden C show... but I love to ride it day in and day out.

The only thing I'm sort of uncomfortable with is people staring in your direction but ultimately look at the gorgeous bike :-) Lot's of people took photos of my bike at an IM event and not my friends brand new BMC TT disc .. I rest my case haha!

Ah, and the build-in powermeter is more inline with my Tacx Neo and my coaches' Kicker as compared to my old Garmin vecto paddles so that's great too!


But i'm curious about other owner's and/or experts first impressions! And if people recognize the very small/tiny cage holder that fits between the rear hydration unit and the saddle.. i'm looking for it.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
maarten.claes wrote:

Inserting my hydration bladder and connecting it to the 'drinking tube/hose' is really difficult as it seems the bladder is a bit short. Tried all sorts of things and with some 'pressure' you get the bladder connected to the hose but it is far from user friendly. I don't think its going to last long.

Update: Specialized kindly notified my that i was doing it wrong.. very wrong! Here's a link to the cockpit and hydration unit installation procedure: https://vimeo.com/325542736 Hope this can prevent fellow shiv disc owners from making the same mistake. Thanks!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi Cam -- Can you guys share a stack/reach chart, which shows the X/Y coordinates possible with the various sizes. I see you guys have some kind of sizing tool online where you measure your current bike against a wall, but it was WAY off (suggested a Small for me, when I'm most likely a Large, maybe Medium) given I'm X=480, Y=640.

Cervelo's "Bike Size and Setup Calculator" is the great, since it even shows you how many spacers/etc you'd be running, but even just a simple chart would help.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Have you a black 2019 Shiv? You pass me in Mirador de Haria with your shining SWorks itā€™s marvellous!! šŸ˜
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
any one here have any info on when we might see additional models released? Looks like the limited edition version is down to only a few left...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Iā€™m still not getting any concrete delivery information from my LBS. They are saying not even Specialized Canada knows when the bike will ship. Do you have any insight on shipping for Canada? I was initially told it would be here in April, then May, then June, then July, and now ā€œsometime in Augustā€ was my last update.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [eDokter] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
eDokter wrote:
Iā€™m still not getting any concrete delivery information from my LBS. They are saying not even Specialized Canada knows when the bike will ship. Do you have any insight on shipping for Canada? I was initially told it would be here in April, then May, then June, then July, and now ā€œsometime in Augustā€ was my last update.

id be pretty mad if i paid $14k and was told a specific delivery date and that was pushed back like that.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [eDokter] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
eDokter wrote:
Iā€™m still not getting any concrete delivery information from my LBS. They are saying not even Specialized Canada knows when the bike will ship. Do you have any insight on shipping for Canada? I was initially told it would be here in April, then May, then June, then July, and now ā€œsometime in Augustā€ was my last update.

Is that the special edition one? Weren't they all built and in stock?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [spectrum5825] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
spectrum5825 wrote:
eDokter wrote:
Iā€™m still not getting any concrete delivery information from my LBS. They are saying not even Specialized Canada knows when the bike will ship. Do you have any insight on shipping for Canada? I was initially told it would be here in April, then May, then June, then July, and now ā€œsometime in Augustā€ was my last update.


Is that the special edition one? Weren't they all built and in stock?

It was for the special edition one. I ordered and reserved it when it was revealed last year.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [eDokter] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
FYI
The stock Shiv and S-Works will be released later today
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
Have you a black 2019 Shiv? You pass me in Mirador de Haria with your shining SWorks itā€™s marvellous!! šŸ˜
It's a beautiful bike! I was so happy it was delivered in time to take it out 'for a spin' across the Lanzarote island :-) I hope you had a good race too!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [bespoke] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bespoke wrote:
FYI
The stock Shiv and S-Works will be released later today

Here they are https://www.specialized.com/...ikes/c/roadtriathlon

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
that pink / yellow paint...

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I love that red one!

Make Inside Out Sports your next online tri shop! http://www.insideoutsports.com/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Right? Holy cow that red looks great. As much as I love strawberry lemonade, that colorway isn't really doing it for me.

Benjamin Deal - Professional - Instagram - TriRig - Lodi Cyclery
Deals on Wheels - Results, schedule, videos, sponsors
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [realbdeal] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That expert model really got a nice treatment...the green looks like something Peter Sagan would ride himself! Also that matte black s-works...hot. Any word on when these things might actually ship?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
anyone find any info on the weight diff between the sworks and the expert models?

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Its the same frame; so only real difference will be wheels - I cant imagine DA vs Ultegra is much

Spez are in a cool position; they can definitively test how much more aero is a 1*12 vs the 2*11 one

I think the red AXS bike looks amazing
I cant but help prefer the clean lines of the Shiv TT though

I would love Spez to give the drag numbers of the Shiv Tri vs Shiv TT
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [bespoke] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
the expert isnt the same frame as the sworks models, at least thats not how specialized has done their frames in the past.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The specs say all are Fact 11r
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [bespoke] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bespoke wrote:
The specs say all are Fact 11r
hmm... thats cool if they are the same frame!

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
100% they are
It would cost way too much to do different lay ups for such a niche model

And the pricing is very close; the expert is high - the only difference is DA vs Ulegra, power meter and much nicer wheels
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [spectrum5825] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It will ship end of August in Europe and the Frame end of October. At first I really disliked the new SHIV but it grew on me and that red one is absolutely beautiful. I traded in my 2018 SHIV this morning for the new SHIV. I actually got a fantastic deal on the old model.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [K73] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
K73 wrote:
It will ship end of August in Europe and the Frame end of October. At first I really disliked the new SHIV but it grew on me and that red one is absolutely beautiful. I traded in my 2018 SHIV this morning for the new SHIV. I actually got a fantastic deal on the old model.

thats sooner than i thought.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [bespoke] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
no basebar shifters for the expert model? I know they can be added later but without them whats the point of di2?

2019 T-Rex Tri Series
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i stopped by my LBS yesterday, i deal with them a lot because all of my bikes are specialized except my tri bike. i asked about the new shiv, pretty much all of the offerings, even the frame set, will be avail this month in the states.

if anyone was interested.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I reached out to my lbs too. They were follow up with the rep. Should know Monday what they say. I'm up in the PNW. will confirm if it's the same availability.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Did you get any manual of how to pack the bike in the bag best way?

or just try n error?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Does anyone know if this bike will get down to a model that's affordable ( i.e. under maybe 5K)? I love this bike, never understood the hate when it first came out, but 8.5K + is out of my league.

"The first virtue in a soldier is endurance of fatigue; courage is only the second virtue."
- Napoleon Bonaparte
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Don_W] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If the frame is 6k, it's unlikely we will see a 5k build any time soon
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mknight84] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mknight84 wrote:
no basebar shifters for the expert model? I know they can be added later but without them whats the point of di2?
my guess is to hit a certain price point.

I couldnā€™t agree more with your comment though.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pingu wrote:
Did you get any manual of how to pack the bike in the bag best way?

or just try n error?

Hey Pingu,

See the following Specialized Service Video for how to pack your Shiv Disc for travel!

https://vimeo.com/339456363
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mknight84] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mknight84 wrote:
no basebar shifters for the expert model? I know they can be added later but without them whats the point of di2?

hey mknight84,

This is not fully accurate. You can shift both derailleurs from the extensions and you can shift the rear derailleur from the basebar on the expert model.

The expert model uses TRP TT levers, which incorporate a Shimano climbing shifter into the body, which allows you to shift up or down.

The ski tip shifters are the 2 button style that allows up and down.

If you really want up and down at all 4 locations, you can add a 2nd climbing shifter into the 2nd TRP lever body
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BryanD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BryanD wrote:
bespoke wrote:
FYI
The stock Shiv and S-Works will be released later today

Here they are https://www.specialized.com/...ikes/c/roadtriathlon

Although i like the red one at this price and starting at 8500 this is not a series of bikes for the majority by looks and prcies. So far i think cervelo will be the major player in tri for 2020 even more when they release a P2/P3 disc bike at a more mortal price level. And that is to be expected i think. Or if they lower the price on the current P2/P3, which could also be a possibility

Jeroen

Owner at TRIPRO, The Netherlands
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
pingu wrote:
Did you get any manual of how to pack the bike in the bag best way?

or just try n error?

Hey Pingu,

See the following Specialized Service Video for how to pack your Shiv Disc for travel!

https://vimeo.com/339456363

Great!!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Which is the new Shiv weight?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The race-ready weight is about 9.3kg (no water in the tank)

To me the fuel cell works quite good but I also needed to tape the lit as it sometimes went off when riding over rougher roads. But I was quite surprised when I measured the amount of water that goes into it. In total it fits about 2L (Size M) which I think is pretty awesome. I know it might not be enough for a full distance but for me it is enough for the 70.3. Also I donĀ“t think the fuel cell is useless once it is empty as it still more aero to ride with it. I do also use it for longer training rides but it is true that it is probably not as easy to mount and dismount as with i.e. the Scott Plasma. But I consider the 2L tank to be a real advantage during the race while everything with a capacity less than 1.3L is more like a nice-to-have thingy but not really you main hydration unit.

Compared with all bikes that I rode before I especially think that the basebar is really a game changer. It is super easy to adjust and incredibly stiff. Same goes for the fork. I always feel in control when riding the bike.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is good info Chris.
Do you know how much is the tank capacity for a Small size?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Does anyone know the availability dates for the Shiv Framesets? black or red?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Black frame set end of this month. Red doesn't show up on dealer website yet.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
In Europe the black will be available Around mid to end of October. At least that is what my LBS is telling me. I am not sure about the red (the one I like)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
2liters Chris? I canā€™t fill my medium shiv with two 750ml bottles. I think itā€™s more like 1.3liters for me. Thatā€™s about 2/3 of my needs for 70.3 bike leg. It does work quite well bar the lid thingie on rougher roads.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
#metoo Maarten...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
maarten.claes wrote:
2liters Chris? I canā€™t fill my medium shiv with two 750ml bottles. I think itā€™s more like 1.3liters for me. Thatā€™s about 2/3 of my needs for 70.3 bike leg. It does work quite well bar the lid thingie on rougher roads.

Interesting, so about as much as two behind the seat bottles but not able to refill. Also no data as to how bad of an aero penalty that fin is.

Maurice
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mauricemaher] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Watching this video as to the "aero penalty" on the fin, hydration system on the SHIV, you will see that your legs during pedaling will break up the crosswinds.



Robert Driskell
Certified Master Body Geometry fit Technician
Certified Master Retul Fit Technician
Zipp Service Course Specialist
Bikes Plus Pensacola Florida
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mauricemaher] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mauricemaher wrote:
maarten.claes wrote:
2liters Chris? I canā€™t fill my medium shiv with two 750ml bottles. I think itā€™s more like 1.3liters for me. Thatā€™s about 2/3 of my needs for 70.3 bike leg. It does work quite well bar the lid thingie on rougher roads.

Interesting, so about as much as two behind the seat bottles but not able to refill. Also no data as to how bad of an aero penalty that fin is.

Maurice

No problems to refill during race.
Bad aero? Aero advantage.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pingu wrote:
mauricemaher wrote:
maarten.claes wrote:
2liters Chris? I canā€™t fill my medium shiv with two 750ml bottles. I think itā€™s more like 1.3liters for me. Thatā€™s about 2/3 of my needs for 70.3 bike leg. It does work quite well bar the lid thingie on rougher roads.

Interesting, so about as much as two behind the seat bottles but not able to refill. Also no data as to how bad of an aero penalty that fin is.

Maurice

No problems to refill during race.
Bad aero? Aero advantage.

I havenā€™t seen the bike in person, I like it though. Refill just based on comments appears to be very sketchy, IE dangerous, IE leave as is for both the safety of yourself and fellow racers.

In terms of aero we simply donā€™t know if this bike is fast or not, we know itā€™s faster than the old shiv, but IIRC so is the venge.

One of the comments from Josh @ Silca was that the new shiv TT is a very fast bike and the back end is essentially the shiv Tri without hydration.

I just want to know if this approaches p5-d/6/x or sc9 slippery ness.

Maurice
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mauricemaher] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mauricemaher wrote:
Interesting, so about as much as two behind the seat bottles but not able to refill. Also no data as to how bad of an aero penalty that fin is.

Maurice

Penalty? In the press release, didn't they say it makes the bike faster?

Also, two bottles is plenty for your carb mix even if you go liquid-only. Then you just need a BTA watter bottle to swap at aid stations
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BigBoyND] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BigBoyND wrote:
mauricemaher wrote:
Interesting, so about as much as two behind the seat bottles but not able to refill. Also no data as to how bad of an aero penalty that fin is.

Maurice

Penalty? In the press release, didn't they say it makes the bike faster?/quote/

They say the bike is optimized for Kona...not any mention of what Yaw, yaw distribution, weightingā€™s etc. With the new shiv TT I want to know which bike is faster, and how they stack up against the competition....the bike is going on a year old and zero data, for 17k$ or so I want a white paper, at the very least.

Also, two bottles is plenty for your carb mix even if you go liquid-only. Then you just need a BTA watter bottle to swap at aid stations./quote/

I suppose if it works for you great.

Maurice
Last edited by: mauricemaher: Aug 14, 19 19:08
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Any additional color on how the bike handles in real world? There aren't many reviews from people who have actually ridden the bike. Does the fork make a noticeable improvement in handling and crosswind stability? Seems like the water reservoir in the back also would improve handled compared to the between the aerobar placement on the Canyon, Giant, etc.
Last edited by: wintershade: Sep 10, 19 14:13
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [wintershade] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
wintershade wrote:
Any additional color on how the bike handles in real world? There aren't many reviews from people who have actually ridden the bike. Does the fork make a noticeable improvement in handling and crosswind stability? Seems like the water reservoir in the back also would improve handled compared to the between the aerobar placement on the Canyon, Giant, etc.

So I had totally written this bike off when I first saw it based on looks alone..... Having just gotten back from racing worlds in France and spending the entire descent with a guy on a black shiv disc frame I can say for me I really like the look of it and it looks remarkably better in person.

I am a totally trek fan and have loved being on a Speed Concept since 2014 so hard for me to jump of a trek and back onto a shiv without hearing what people are actually saying about its ride quality / handling.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [wintershade] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
just bumping this thread for anyone that owns this bike would love just to hear more about it.

1. storage
2. handling
3. Wrenching it
4. front end
5. how they are using the bladder
6. problems
7. love hate things about the bike.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
1. storage
plenty. more then i would need
2. handling
excellent. especially combination of stiffer more direct front end and disc brakes. no more need to be timid descending passes
3. Wrenching it
so far easy, especially packing it with the base bars folding down
4. front end
its probably the best part as it allow the bike to start "sailing" at a much steeper yaw angle then the old shiv (cannot compare to other bikes) it definitely is a blast riding with any sort of side winds
5. how they are using the bladder
just for racing. train with 2 bottles (seat tube and BTA)
6. problems
none so far
7. love hate things about the bike.
love the sailing and the control. hate that its synchro-shift only (hence will add sprint shifters to base bar)
also, changed rear disc to 140mmm (from 160mm) so that i can easily swap training wheels
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mauricemaher] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mauricemaher wrote:


They say the bike is optimized for Kona...not any mention of what Yaw, yaw distribution, weightingā€™s etc. With the new shiv TT I want to know which bike is faster, and how they stack up against the competition....the bike is going on a year old and zero data, for 17k$ or so I want a white paper, at the very least.

Maurice

You are not going to get much data these days, bike are now so well optimised there is a limited amount of improvements that can no be made. But they still need to sell new bikes.

Probably more important is questions about adjustability and general handling. From an aero point the basic bike are all getting to the same place.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mammamia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for the feedback.

Did you buy the travel case made specifically for the bike?

Do you train with the rear bladder in it all the time?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Mario S] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Mario S wrote:
mauricemaher wrote:


They say the bike is optimized for Kona...not any mention of what Yaw, yaw distribution, weightingā€™s etc. With the new shiv TT I want to know which bike is faster, and how they stack up against the competition....the bike is going on a year old and zero data, for 17k$ or so I want a white paper, at the very least.

Maurice

You are not going to get much data these days, bike are now so well optimised there is a limited amount of improvements that can no be made. But they still need to sell new bikes.

Probably more important is questions about adjustability and general handling. From an aero point the basic bike are all getting to the same place.

Sort of,

There is likely 0-5 watts among the top 3-5 (most being rim brakes, 5-10 year old design) bikes, then thereā€™s every one else.

My specific point was where is this bike within that? With no data we have to assume ā€œeveryone elseā€

Agree on fit/ease of adjustments etc.

Maurice
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Did you buy the travel case made specifically for the bike?
did not have to, it came with the bike.... ;) (special edition series)

Do you train with the rear bladder in it all the time?
no. trained with 2 bottles only. down tube and BTA
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mammamia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mammamia wrote:
Did you buy the travel case made specifically for the bike?
did not have to, it came with the bike.... ;) (special edition series)

Do you train with the rear bladder in it all the time?
no. trained with 2 bottles only. down tube and BTA

Man way to jump on it early, I am searching for any deal i can find on one....

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
Thanks for the feedback.

Did you buy the travel case made specifically for the bike?
A: was included. served me well on both IM trips.

Do you train with the rear bladder in it all the time?
A: I do actually. But for training, i mostly just use water and no sportsdrink to keep it somewhat cleaner. Have a BTA too but dont use it for 70.3 or short training rides.

I like it. (a lot)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mammamia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Does anyone happen to know if the Roval Disc wheel was designed to work with the shiv specifically?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
according to what specialized has said the roval disc was specifically designed to work with the uci legal shiv, so the tri specific shiv would work well with it, i would imagine.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mammamia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mammamia wrote:
Did you buy the travel case made specifically for the bike?
did not have to, it came with the bike.... ;) (special edition series)

Do you train with the rear bladder in it all the time?
no. trained with 2 bottles only. down tube and BTA

What is the travel case? Is it a specialized product?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
according to what specialized has said the roval disc was specifically designed to work with the uci legal shiv, so the tri specific shiv would work well with it, i would imagine.

Works well! Rode it on IM Barca
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
mammamia wrote:
Did you buy the travel case made specifically for the bike?
did not have to, it came with the bike.... ;) (special edition series)

Do you train with the rear bladder in it all the time?
no. trained with 2 bottles only. down tube and BTA

What is the travel case? Is it a specialized product?

Yepp, came with the limited edition Shiv. Havenā€™t used mine and not sure I will. I am a hard box-person...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
To those doing full distance on the new shiv, how are you using the fuelsalage? Filling it with concentrated liquid calories that will last the whole race, or just using it for water?

To me the capacity would work well for up to a 70.3 distance race, but i would think anything past that you would be stretching the usefulness of the rear ā€œsailā€ unless youā€™re doing concentrated calorie drink.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pingu wrote:
Works well! Rode it on IM Barca

How did the Shiv handle on the flat, fast roads of Calella?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You want to sale it?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
according to what specialized has said the roval disc was specifically designed to work with the uci legal shiv, so the tri specific shiv would work well with it, i would imagine.

This is not accurate...The ShivTT was designed around the 321 but the 321 was not designed around the ShivTT.

Actually the Shiv Tri design had more influence on the 321 even though it was launched after
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks for the clarification.

regardless, itā€™s pretty apparent the ass end of the shiv tt is just a shiv without the hydration sail. imo, and itā€™s just a visual based opinion, it was a lazy design move by specialized.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
thanks for the clarification.

regardless, itā€™s pretty apparent the ass end of the shiv tt is just a shiv without the hydration sail. imo, and itā€™s just a visual based opinion, it was a lazy design move by specialized.

That is also not true...the TT is UCI legal, has to respect the fit boxes and tube size constraints...the Shiv Tri violates all of these aspects and has much lowered seat stays, provision for the hydration, and the extended beyond axle Seat Stays. The Seat Tube of the Tri is moved forward relative to the BB to make clearance for the reservoir, and the Seat Tube for the TT is in its traditional place. Optically it looks similar, because the offset in the seatpost head disguises this, but its significant.

Lastly, the cutout on the TT is quite different than the Tri...and done for a reason totally different than the Tri.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
again thanks for the clarification. i need to personally look at the bikes side by side.

not that iā€™m in any sort of position to need a shiv tt.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey GatorRacer, perhaps you know. I just got my shiv tri S size, and I got it with the seatpost 25 offset. I was hoping to get the zero offset as this would allow to move the saddle more forward and raise the saddle. Can I replace the seatpost?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Which build did you get?

Btw red with sram or black with Da

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I got the frameset only Small size. Black
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
guillermoD wrote:
Hey GatorRacer, perhaps you know. I just got my shiv tri S size, and I got it with the seatpost 25 offset. I was hoping to get the zero offset as this would allow to move the saddle more forward and raise the saddle. Can I replace the seatpost?


I highly doubt you have the 25 offset post. The +25 post is aftermarket only and does not come with bikes or modules unless your dealer maybe had one for some reason.

The 0 offset post looks like a negative offset post due to the aforementioned seat tube position that allows for the hydration Fuelcell. The +25 post looks like a traditional 0 offset post with the saddle clamp ā€œeyeā€ nearly inline with the post.

Double check what you have and offer why you want to change posts and I can help.

But to answer your question, YES there are 2 posts and they are interchangeable. Note that these 2 posts can change clearance to the reservoir, and of course your effective ST angle
Last edited by: GatorRacer: Nov 6, 19 22:58
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [WhittleFit] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
WhittleFit wrote:
pingu wrote:

Works well! Rode it on IM Barca


How did the Shiv handle on the flat, fast roads of Calella?

Great, me at 65kg avg 230w and 39,5km/h..

I had the "old" shiv last year, this one is stiffer and I think it feels more like my tarmac than my old shiv.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pingu] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pingu wrote:
WhittleFit wrote:
pingu wrote:

Works well! Rode it on IM Barca


How did the Shiv handle on the flat, fast roads of Calella?


Great, me at 65kg avg 230w and 39,5km/h..

I had the "old" shiv last year, this one is stiffer and I think it feels more like my tarmac than my old shiv.
That's fast! I dragged my 69kg body to T2 in 4u45' - 174W 37.5kmh.


I just feel good on the bike and it showed in IM barcelona. Nothing more I can say really as I don't test a bunch of other bikes nor have 20y experience or so. I was retul fitted on my old Shiv and with that data, we've set up the new Shiv so i'd think 'the fit' can be left out of the equation here.

About fueling strategies for a full ironman on the Shiv Disc.. here's how I did it:
* Hydration unit filled with 1.3liters of Maurten 320 + extra Precision Hydration electrolytes: +- 80gram Carbs + 1000mg salts/ per hour for three hours. So for the first three hours, i used the hydration unit + some extra water from the aid stations in my BTA (xlab torpedo).
* One bottle on the downtube filled with 9x liquid gels (Maxim - 28gram carbs 60ml ) and also added PH electrolytes. I dont like to fiddle with pulling out gels, opening it etc.. Again, carbs and electrolytes for like 3 hours (previous ironman bike pb was 5u30). Of course i need to supplement that more with water from aidstations but that went fine.
* Fuel cell: 2x spare gels (just in case I lose my bottle) plus an extra inner tube. Didnt use it.

I think this makes for a clean nutrition setup for Ironman distances if you dont need solid food. It was the first time that my nutrition strategy worked on the bike and that I arrived in T2 relatively fresh despite of the massive PB 4u45' (OK, as a lousy swimmer, i catch *alot* of people on the first lap and I honestly think riding from group to group is sort of 'legal drafting' :-) )

Did see 2x fellow Shiv Disc owners, one guy with a limited edition bike + roval disc wheel and another athlete with a black shiv disc if I recall correctly. Left me wondering what a roval disc wheel would have meant for me on such a fast course ;-) I didnt went for the disc wheel as I didnt have any expectations going into the race injured... saved 2k euro but maybe lost 5' haha
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for the info. So yes I stand corrected. What I need is that aftermarket +25 offset seatpost. And as you mention one of the reasons is also the clear out the reservoir obstructing as I cannot go lower height than 710mm seat to BB. And the second reason is to change the ST angle.
Did you said interchangeable? Can I replace the seatpost I currently have? Please let me know how I can make the replacement.
Last edited by: guillermoD: Nov 7, 19 6:48
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
whats best way to clean tubing and bladder after you put calorie mix in there?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
guillermoD wrote:
Thanks for the info. So yes I stand corrected. What I need is that aftermarket +25 offset seatpost. And as you mention one of the reasons is also the clear out the reservoir obstructing as I cannot go lower height than 710mm seat to BB. And the second reason is to change the ST angle.
Did you said interchangeable? Can I replace the seatpost I currently have? Please let me know how I can make the replacement.

Contact your dealer and they can order one for you. There is a cost for the post
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
whats best way to clean tubing and bladder after you put calorie mix in there?

The bike comes with a cleaning kit that includes a 1meter coil ā€œsnakeā€ that has a wire brush head attachment. You can fish this thru with week soapy water to clean out a hydration mix.

It also comes with a plug attachment that you can use to easily route thru the bike.

A little trick is to store the bladder with clean water if you wonā€™t be using it for a few weeks (it months remove it and dry it). Using distilled water for storage is best because every gone water source can contain trace elements that lead to bacteria.

Also, more expensive, but letting carbonated soda water sit in the system can make cleaning easier.

The bladder is design as a ā€œrace dayā€ solution, and while it is OK to use daily, of course that can be tedious. This is why the system was designed to have a removable and replaceable bladder. At one point it was consider to make the fuelcell the tank but we decided differently at the expense of a little capacity.

Cheers!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What bag are you using for travel with it? I have used a scion in the past, but with the base bar folding down maybe can switch to a hard case?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
What bag are you using for travel with it? I have used a scion in the past, but with the base bar folding down maybe can switch to a hard case?

https://www.instagram.com/p/BuoOQHTBsPx/ Looks like she can fit the bike into a hard case. Don't know how much disassembly is needed to fit it in there. Probably depends on size of the bike too.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have not travel with it yet but I have BikeBoxAlan (which I saw Lucy Charles traveling with) similar to scion and I hope there no issues. Iā€™ll keep you posted.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I travel with it to kona in hard case. Did not remove the drinking system. Very easy to pack
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Likeglad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Which hard case? Will any hard case work?
Was there anything special about the case that came out with the limited edition?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I think almost any hard case will do. You might have to remove the fuel cell if its not a big case.... I got a M and used a b&w
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
whats best way to clean tubing and bladder after you put calorie mix in there?

Ask your local homebrewing shop or buddy for some PWB and StarSan, it's how we clean beer lines and nooks and crannies in the brewing process (which, essentially, is also sugary water) that can't be scrubbed directly.

PBW is a cleaner - running it warm through the tubing and letting the bag sit filled with it should dissolve any muck buildup. StarSan is a no-rinse sanitiser, meaning you don't have to wash it out - it's safe to ingest - but will keep anything from growing in there. You can leave it in the tubing and bladder until it's time to fill with your race drink of choice.

ZONE3 - We Last Longer
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [tessar] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks!

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
guillermoD wrote:
I have not travel with it yet but I have BikeBoxAlan (which I saw Lucy Charles traveling with) similar to scion and I hope there no issues. Iā€™ll keep you posted.

You using the triathlon version or road bike version? Have you packed it in case to see how fit is?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
With the zero offset seat post will that give a few extra mm can bring seat down? I just got in a size M but with 170 cranks I am still 12mm short of the seat height I need. I can gain 5mm back by switching to 165 cranks. It looks like the zero offset might give me a just a touch more room I can push the seat down to?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
With the zero offset seat post will that give a few extra mm can bring seat down? I just got in a size M but with 170 cranks I am still 12mm short of the seat height I need. I can gain 5mm back by switching to 165 cranks. It looks like the zero offset might give me a just a touch more room I can push the seat down to?

So with 170 mm cranks you are 12 mm short of the seat height? In that case you will not gain 5 mm back with 165 mm cranks, with that switch you will be 17 mm short of saddle height. If i understand you correct. When you shorten the crank the saddle goes the difference UP

Jeroen

Owner at TRIPRO, The Netherlands
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
See the following Specialized Service Video for how to pack your Shiv Disc for travel!

https://vimeo.com/339456363
Can you tell what boxes the Swift Academy Kona group traveled with? Any success / horror stories to share?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TRIPRO] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Opposite; think of the crank arm being at bottom of peddle stroke your foot is 5mm higher.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi Toothengineer,

Yes, the +25mm Forward Offset post will give you additional clearance to the reservoir - so you should have no problem getting the addition 12mm you need.

As Keith mentioned earlier, the bikes come with the 0mm Offset post. This post looks like a "traditional" rearward offset post, due to the design of the seat tube being offset forward to allow for additional volume in the Fuelcell. This artificially gives the aesthetic of a rear offset. The +25mm Forward offset post puts the saddle rail mount inline with the post, offering additional clearance to the reservoir. These are the only two offset posts available.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cameron much appreciated info!

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Where can I pull up a manual for this bike? The link online does not work.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
Where can I pull up a manual for this bike? The link online does not work.

Seems like there are some technical issues on the site - the dropdown is not working for me either. Here is the manual: https://media.specialized.com/...teral/0000139205.pdf
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cam Piper wrote:
Toothengineer wrote:
Where can I pull up a manual for this bike? The link online does not work.


Seems like there are some technical issues on the site - the dropdown is not working for me either. Here is the manual: https://media.specialized.com/...teral/0000139205.pdf

Thank you for the link.

So it seems like with the different seat post it will allow me to just fit onto a medium by just a few mm. This does seems to be a limiting fit factor with the fuel cell, are they plans to say make a smaller fuel cell to give a wider range of fits? I have heard the fuel cell for a size small frame won't work with a size medium frame?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cam Piper wrote:
Toothengineer wrote:
Where can I pull up a manual for this bike? The link online does not work.


Seems like there are some technical issues on the site - the dropdown is not working for me either. Here is the manual: https://media.specialized.com/...teral/0000139205.pdf

Cameron, do you ahve the same manual for the Shiv TT?

Mine allegedly shipped Friday, and I'd like to do some reading before I tear it apart to make my own.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
Cam Piper wrote:
Toothengineer wrote:
Where can I pull up a manual for this bike? The link online does not work.


Seems like there are some technical issues on the site - the dropdown is not working for me either. Here is the manual: https://media.specialized.com/...teral/0000139205.pdf


Thank you for the link.

So it seems like with the different seat post it will allow me to just fit onto a medium by just a few mm. This does seems to be a limiting fit factor with the fuel cell, are they plans to say make a smaller fuel cell to give a wider range of fits? I have heard the fuel cell for a size small frame won't work with a size medium frame?

The 25mm Forward Offset post allows for an additional 30-35mm of clearance (depending on the saddle you're using).

You're correct, the reservoir (the carbon part that holds the Hydration Fuelcell) cannot fit on other frame sizes. They are specific to the frame size you are riding. The machined hole is specific to the frame size.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [RKW] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RKW wrote:
Cam Piper wrote:
Toothengineer wrote:
Where can I pull up a manual for this bike? The link online does not work.


Seems like there are some technical issues on the site - the dropdown is not working for me either. Here is the manual: https://media.specialized.com/...teral/0000139205.pdf


Cameron, do you ahve the same manual for the Shiv TT?

Mine allegedly shipped Friday, and I'd like to do some reading before I tear it apart to make my own.

Hi RKW, we're excited for these new Shiv TT's to land, as well!

Here are the specific manuals - please PM me if you have any specific questions!

Full Manual: https://media.specialized.com/...teral/0000143663.pdf

Schematic: https://media.specialized.com/...teral/0000143664.pdf
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks! I can't wait to get it out on the road.


Do you know if the first shipment of them actually went out on Friday?
Last edited by: RKW: Dec 3, 19 11:25
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
Opposite; think of the crank arm being at bottom of peddle stroke your foot is 5mm higher.

Sorry, maybe a language barrier. I thought you meant that you needed an extra of 12 mm of saddle height. So for example you need 72 cm of saddle height and you are now with 170 mm cranks maxed out at 708 mm. When you go to a 165 mm crank you want the saddle to go up to 725 mm.

But as said maybe we meant the same thing ;-)

Jeroen

Owner at TRIPRO, The Netherlands
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [TRIPRO] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yes we said same thing in opposite way. Lol, we are on same page. This bike has limiting factor in saddle by the fuel cell. Front end of this bike is amazing, love it.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi Keith! brand new owner of the Shiv Disc myself coming from a 2013 Trek SC. Quick question: Is it possible to drain the fluid after a ride without removing the entire bladder? After a ride, say I have 25% of fluids left, I would have to empty the tank before putting the bike back in my car. Just wondering if there's any elegant way apart from turning bike upside down or drinking it all up? Thanks!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [melvody] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Does anyone know what degree the shims are for the shiv; 10 degree, 15 degree, or 20 degree.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [melvody] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
melvody wrote:
Hi Keith! brand new owner of the Shiv Disc myself coming from a 2013 Trek SC. Quick question: Is it possible to drain the fluid after a ride without removing the entire bladder? After a ride, say I have 25% of fluids left, I would have to empty the tank before putting the bike back in my car. Just wondering if there's any elegant way apart from turning bike upside down or drinking it all up? Thanks!


Hey melvody congrats on the new bike!

Honestly, there is no "elegant" way for this situation, but its not a difficult one to manage. If your saddle height allows for it, the fastest way is to remove the bite valve and just remove the bladder (straw and all) from the fuelcell. If your saddle is too close to the fuelcell for this, then I would advise to remove the 2 bolts holding the fuelcell to the frame. Just remember to install your included straw plug prior to pulling through so it doesnt drain (I keep it in the nutrition box when not racing)

The Fuelcell was designed as a race feature, so in reality I expect most people to not use the bladder with fluids for most training situations and use a BTA bottle + downtube bottle....if you're on a really long training ride then the story may be different but then you could end up in your situation, but only if you arent using a bike rack.

I hope this helps
Last edited by: GatorRacer: Dec 9, 19 9:05
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
Does anyone know what degree the shims are for the shiv; 10 degree, 15 degree, or 20 degree.

10degree
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
It also comes with a plug attachment that you can use to easily route thru the bike.

How does this work?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Spent a while messing around with front end starting to dial in position (copying from my Trek). To get the setup optimal for what I want will prob end up doing some kind of custom extension. I am almost maxed on how low I can go with currently only a 5mm spacer, which I might need to taker out, my seat height is going to be with rails sitting basically on hydration cell. My question is: do you know which frame seems to be faster: a frame that got close to zero stack height but almost a frame thats to big or a smaller frame but adding stack height?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [WhittleFit] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
WhittleFit wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
It also comes with a plug attachment that you can use to easily route thru the bike.


How does this work?

There is a barb included in the cleaning/routing kit that attaches into the hose after bite valve removal. This item allows for easier re-routing, prevents leaking if the system is still wet, and also prevents pickup of any debris during the servicing process.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
Spent a while messing around with front end starting to dial in position (copying from my Trek). To get the setup optimal for what I want will prob end up doing some kind of custom extension. I am almost maxed on how low I can go with currently only a 5mm spacer, which I might need to taker out, my seat height is going to be with rails sitting basically on hydration cell. My question is: do you know which frame seems to be faster: a frame that got close to zero stack height but almost a frame thats to big or a smaller frame but adding stack height?

There is not a clear differentiator aerodynamically with a body on board the bike because your body onboard, but generally the larger frame is better due to increased surface area of the reservoir and longer forks blades. In addition you gain fluid capacity. These generally will outweigh the increased frontal area if you assume a yaw distribution. The difference between the 2 frames in stack is ~25mm which isnt something to sweat. The rear and saddle height are much more important when you are a "tweener" size
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Looking at possibly getting Shiv Disc, but I am in between a S and a M. Are there specs on the differences in fluid capacity between the two sizes? I see 1.5L everywhere, but doesn't mention less or more based on size from what I can see.

Also I am guessing handling would be affected by size difference. Unfortunately I won't be able to ride each size before deciding, but I am thinking shorter should handle better, or is that backwards?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [lenny07] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
lenny07 wrote:
Looking at possibly getting Shiv Disc, but I am in between a S and a M. Are there specs on the differences in fluid capacity between the two sizes? I see 1.5L everywhere, but doesn't mention less or more based on size from what I can see.

Also I am guessing handling would be affected by size difference. Unfortunately I won't be able to ride each size before deciding, but I am thinking shorter should handle better, or is that backwards?

Capacity is size dependent but it changes about 0.1-0.15L per size

I always advise to Size Up if you can, but the most important consideration in doing so is your saddle height. You can get the same fit on many sizes with the New Shiv Disc but the reservoir system requires you to consider your saddle height.

As for handling, it will depend on your fit. If you have a lot of weight forward of the steering axis (i.e. smaller frame with a lot of reach) the handling is going to be much faster, whereas if you are closer to the steering axis it will be slower....For triathlon, slower is generally better as it takes less energy to maintain a straight line and you arent concerned with ripping apexes on a descent like in a road race.

If you are in between, and your saddle height allows for a MD, that would be my gut recommendation. Of course a good bike fitter should be able to give you the best advice.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for the info! My shop measured by current bike setup today and M seems to fit better based on the options. Merry Christmas to me lol
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So is the front end issues I have found seeing if anyone has good solutions to them yet?

-- the pad spacing does not allow you to run narrow and mount a BTA; you either have to have arms super far apart or super narrow thus not being able to run BTA. There is not middle ground here.

-- Small complaints:
1. I wish the bike came with both seat posts, just had to spend more money to get different offset for fit; at this price point give the consumer everything they need and not have to buy more stuff.
2. The arm pads / cups its comes with are super small and its best if you just change them out to bigger ones; I struggle to understand why companies dont make better arm cups and forces the consumer to go to secondary market (general gripe about standard cups that come on new bikes).
3. Different extension options: once again at this price point would be great if you had different options for different degrees of hand rise.

Currently trying to figure out how to make this front end work, seems to be some good after market companies allowing me to get this workout out. Having small debate if I should just give up and sell the bike off already.


Edit:

Options out there to improve front end: anyone seen any other options:

Ride Synch
SpeedBar
WattShop

Maybe I am just to picky

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Last edited by: Toothengineer: Dec 24, 19 8:12
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have the same complaints about the armpads. I hated them, never felt like there was enough space to get locked in. I have 51S arm cups on at the moment but they don't fit super great in terms of being able to position them just due to the ways the holes are cut. I was looking at wattshop because they have the tilt already built in, but are crazy expensive.

I didn't like the extensions much either, they felt a bit flat. I went with the Vision mantis extensions and have been pretty happy with thise.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [spectrum5825] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have 51ss cups on 2 other bikes; had to drill my own holes in them to get them perfect.

The 51ss cusps and the zipps with bring pads a little closer together but specialized did not give enough places to mount the pads/cups so you loose some range of how close you can bring your forearms and elbows together.

I will look at vision extensions; had planned on getting some zipp evo 110 or 51ss ultimates till
Wattshop; ride synch; or drag2zero can get finishā€™s thereā€™s up for this bike.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [spectrum5825] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Do you think the Zipp or TR cups would work better? TR just so damn heavy though.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The two I'd like to try are wattshop and the TR scoops. Not sure about weight but concerned about having enough room to set them up.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Question: if we put base bar at up or down angle does it effectively make the bar a little less wide / skinner?

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I don't see how it would? Maybe from an aerodynamic perspective it could have some impact?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [spectrum5825] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
spectrum5825 wrote:
I don't see how it would? Maybe from an aerodynamic perspective it could have some impact?

No aero benefit from adj angles.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [spectrum5825] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Iā€™m putting the TR scoops on mine when itā€™s built, at least thatā€™s the plan. I eyeballed it when the frame came in last week, and there appears to be plenty of room to set them up, but I do run a middle width pad setup, so if you want super narrow maybe thatā€™s an issue. Unfortunately I am waiting on wheels until late Jan or early Feb so I wonā€™t be able to confirm the pad fit until itā€™s fully built, but at the moment it doesnā€™t look like an issue.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [lenny07] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Oh did you just get frame and build it up?

What wheels did you end up going with?

Yea I try to get pads / arms as close as possible while still maintaining a BTA set up. This leaves about 65-70mm btw closest edges of the pads (I should have checked this before buying). Not measured what the closest you can get pads but my guess is maybe 90-100mm unless you use super narrow mounts that then dont give any room to run a BTA.

I wont be able to add water to the fuel cell while racing do to having my seat slammed against the fuel cell, so only way to get more water while racing is BTA. Guess I could run a bottle on seat tube but that would start negating aero benefits of the bike.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yeah just got the frame to build up as I have a nearly new Ultegra Di2 set I bought last year for my P2. Moving everything but the brakes over to the Shiv to keep the cost somewhat down lol. Swapping the old 6800 Di2 components back onto the P2 as my backup ride.

Went with the 7.8ā€™s plus a Roval disc as I ride 7.8 now and have been very happy with them. The 321 was a no brainer at like 200g lighter than other discs considering I race hilly courses. Probably will only use the 8 rear for training though. Thought about Roval 64ā€™s but decided I wanted to stay with 7.8ā€™s after much deliberation despite the mismatched front and rear. The 7 front and 321 rear doesnā€™t look too bad though, my shop just built out two other bikes with those wheels and had some pictures.

I donā€™t have the need for BTA as I only race HIM and the rear fuelcell will be fine for my needs as I am usually off the bike around 2:30. I believe I saw someone offering spacers for BTA bottles to elevate them over the pads if needed, might have been TR but I canā€™t seem to find it. That may be an aero issue depending on your extension rise and if the bottle sticks out above the extension profile though.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [lenny07] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Good call on Enve I think; Spec is saying those wide forks work best with wide wheel.

Minus the mismatched front and rear wheel sounds like a good set up.

I am finding the sram red hydraulic disk break to have such tight tolerances hard to keep it from slightly rubbing; my other dis. break bike with ultegra disk much easier.

Spacers to elevate a BTA not seen those either, would solve one of my two issues!

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yeah, took me a minute to get over the mis-matched wheels when my shop suggested it. Looks aside it made the most sense to me and after seeing the same combo on brand new P5D and FRD builds, the look didnā€™t bother me as much as I thought it would.

These may work for your bottle problem: https://xlab-usa.com/...66-aero-spacers.html if it gets you enough height. Might even be able to stack more than 1 to get .9ā€ if needed. Best of luck.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
Spacers to elevate a BTA not seen those either, would solve one of my two issues!

I cant find pictures either, but I think Fibrelyte makes them and you can get any height you want.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
Question: if we put base bar at up or down angle does it effectively make the bar a little less wide / skinner?

It has to. The lengh from the pivot point will be length*cos(angle)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BigBoyND] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thats what I was thinking. The base bar measures 17in wide now, which is seems very wide, not measurement doing a up or down angle but figured would make the effective length smaller.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What cranks are you using with your frame? I currently run Shimano cranks which won't work without an adapter or new BB of some sort since the OSBB is for 30mm spindles.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [lenny07] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Iā€™m using the quarq Dfour91 BB30 crank. The axle is pretty big to be use in BB30, BB86 and BBright frames. I would say is not the best solution because at some point it might cause the infamous creak issue, but currently is working pretty solid with the current BB30 ceramic speed bearings, so Iā€™m happy so far.

The bomb proof solution I think is a Dura Ace crank plus the BB30 ceramic speed adapter. Same as the pro teams use.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Did you have to buy any adapters or anything to use the DFour91 BB30, that works straight out of the box with the frame? If you moved to the CS BB30 adapter for Shimano you are basically throwing away the CS bearings that came with the frame right? The "financially responsible" part of me doesn't want to throw away those bearings lol. Wondering if using S-works cranks or something like that may make sense, although not sure on the shifting with the Di2 derailleur and Praxis or some other brand chain rings. Gotta talk to my shop mechanic I suppose.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [lenny07] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The quarq BB30 crank comes with spacers and washers for the different type of frames and it works out of the box in with specialized frame and original bearings, so I didnā€™t buy any adapter but I had to buy a pair of Sram BB30 shields ($15) because did not come with the frame or quarq. Usually these shields come with sworks cranks but for some reason not included with quarq.

I had the same financial responsible thinking and thatā€™s why I choose quarq in order to keep the original bearings, but the shimano option will be better in my opinion. The BB30 adapter will put the bearing outside the frame and closer to the cranks, making the whole BB much stiffer and better power transfer. Also maintenance will be easier. And I know itā€™s a pain to get rid of a perfect pair of new bearings but you can also sell it here or eBay and recover part of the finance hit.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
True. Thanks for the info
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [lenny07] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thinking about picking up the non-S-works version. Are folks paying sticker for this? Any deals or upcoming sales that anyone has heard about?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [rhodes42] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rhodes42 wrote:
Thinking about picking up the non-S-works version. Are folks paying sticker for this? Any deals or upcoming sales that anyone has heard about?
be aware this bike doesnā€™t have shifters for the di2 on the handle bars, just the extensions. iā€™ve tried to figure out what junction box this version has and how easy it would be to add the appropriate shifters after the fact and i havnt had any luck.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for the heads-up. I thought that would be standard at even this low price point.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
a question for current owners regarding the fuel cell...

are you able to eliminate all the fluids from the fuel cell? in other words, does the liquid in the hydration "bag" in the rear cell gravity feed with an air gap forming at the top working its way as you lower the level until youre just sucking air, or does the bag collapse as you suck in, leaving some of your hydration / fuel mixture in the bag?

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [lenny07] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
lenny07 wrote:

I donā€™t have the need for BTA as I only race HIM and the rear fuelcell will be fine for my needs as I am usually off the bike around 2:30. I believe I saw someone offering spacers for BTA bottles to elevate them over the pads if needed, might have been TR but I canā€™t seem to find it.

https://www.revolverwheels.co.uk/...ono-tribar-arm-rest/

this is the only thing ive seen that sounds like what you're talking about.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This would work well, its going to allow the rider to get arms elbows as close together as possible and still get a BTA. You would have to get them to or would need to yourself drill holes for it to fit.

Still amazes me with such a well designed aerodynamic bike it was forgotten that a rider creates the most wind resistance and having arms close together is going to be an aerodynamic advantage, yet this bike does not allow that out of the box! Re design this in 2020 please!

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
my pure guess is the idea of this bikes design was to completely rely on the rear hydration and ditch any sort of BTA.

i personally really like the idea of this as it removes weight from the front end of the bike, but in reality long distance riders need some sort of BTA solution. i could see myself relying solely on the rear hydration for up to a 70.3 (no full distance experience here at all) but i think it was a missed opportunity if they didnt take into account that some will want a BTA. again this is all pure speculation from what yall are saying.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
In Reply To:
Be aware this bike doesnā€™t have shifters for the di2 on the handle bars, just the extensions.

What were you basing this off of? Just saw the bike in person and bought it. The non-Shimano shifters do actually have electronic shifting. It appears that specialized added buttons to them afterwards.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
maarten.claes wrote:
pingu wrote:
WhittleFit wrote:
pingu wrote:

Works well! Rode it on IM Barca


How did the Shiv handle on the flat, fast roads of Calella?


Great, me at 65kg avg 230w and 39,5km/h..

I had the "old" shiv last year, this one is stiffer and I think it feels more like my tarmac than my old shiv.
That's fast! I dragged my 69kg body to T2 in 4u45' - 174W 37.5kmh.


I just feel good on the bike and it showed in IM barcelona. Nothing more I can say really as I don't test a bunch of other bikes nor have 20y experience or so. I was retul fitted on my old Shiv and with that data, we've set up the new Shiv so i'd think 'the fit' can be left out of the equation here.

About fueling strategies for a full ironman on the Shiv Disc.. here's how I did it:
* Hydration unit filled with 1.3liters of Maurten 320 + extra Precision Hydration electrolytes: +- 80gram Carbs + 1000mg salts/ per hour for three hours. So for the first three hours, i used the hydration unit + some extra water from the aid stations in my BTA (xlab torpedo).
* One bottle on the downtube filled with 9x liquid gels (Maxim - 28gram carbs 60ml ) and also added PH electrolytes. I dont like to fiddle with pulling out gels, opening it etc.. Again, carbs and electrolytes for like 3 hours (previous ironman bike pb was 5u30). Of course i need to supplement that more with water from aidstations but that went fine.
* Fuel cell: 2x spare gels (just in case I lose my bottle) plus an extra inner tube. Didnt use it.

I think this makes for a clean nutrition setup for Ironman distances if you dont need solid food. It was the first time that my nutrition strategy worked on the bike and that I arrived in T2 relatively fresh despite of the massive PB 4u45' (OK, as a lousy swimmer, i catch *alot* of people on the first lap and I honestly think riding from group to group is sort of 'legal drafting' :-) )

Did see 2x fellow Shiv Disc owners, one guy with a limited edition bike + roval disc wheel and another athlete with a black shiv disc if I recall correctly. Left me wondering what a roval disc wheel would have meant for me on such a fast course ;-) I didnt went for the disc wheel as I didnt have any expectations going into the race injured... saved 2k euro but maybe lost 5' haha

The one with the LTD and 321disc could have been me...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [rhodes42] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rhodes42 wrote:

What were you basing this off of? Just saw the bike in person and bought it. The non-Shimano shifters do actually have electronic shifting. It appears that specialized added buttons to them afterwards.

early reports were there were only shifters on the extentions, not on the base bars.

also, pic directly off specialized site has no base bar shifters, only on the extentions.

https://s7d5.scene7.com/...IL_FDSQ?$hybris-hd$}

(i hope that link works)

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [rhodes42] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rhodes42 wrote:
Just saw the bike in person and bought it. The non-Shimano shifters do actually have electronic shifting. It appears that specialized added buttons to them afterwards.

can you post pics of the setup on your new bike, and would it be possible to post the model number of the di2 junction box? its info i havnt been able to get on the "cheap" shiv. thanks!

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
rhodes42 wrote:


What were you basing this off of? Just saw the bike in person and bought it. The non-Shimano shifters do actually have electronic shifting. It appears that specialized added buttons to them afterwards.


early reports were there were only shifters on the extentions, not on the base bars.

also, pic directly off specialized site has no base bar shifters, only on the extentions.

https://s7d5.scene7.com/...IL_FDSQ?$hybris-hd$}

(i hope that link works)

The Shiv Disc Expert DOES have shifting on the basebar. Its just all on the Drive side so you cant see the button in the 3/4 angle picture you see.

The TRP levers have a window that you can remove, and insert a shimano "climbing" satellite shifter to control from the basebar.

The stock configuration only allows you to shift the Rear Derailleur but you can add front if you want to the Non-Drive Side shifter
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
The Shiv Disc Expert DOES have shifting on the basebar. Its just all on the Drive side so you cant see the button in the 3/4 angle picture you see.

The TRP levers have a window that you can remove, and insert a shimano "climbing" satellite shifter to control from the basebar.

The stock configuration only allows you to shift the Rear Derailleur but you can add front if you want to the Non-Drive Side shifter

thanks a lot for that clarification.

what junction box model does the expert use?

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Toothengineer wrote:
Still amazes me with such a well designed aerodynamic bike it was forgotten that a rider creates the most wind resistance and having arms close together is going to be an aerodynamic advantage, yet this bike does not allow that out of the box! Re design this in 2020 please!

Hey Toothengineer, sorry for the delayed response but I've been traveling and took some personal time around the holidays. You bring up some good points about the bike so I wanted to take the time to address them for all to see:

Firstly, thanks for the compliments on the bike, and I assure you that we did not forget about the riders position and how it impacts aerodynamics! I hope you are enjoying yours even with the challenges you've found.

Secondly, let me give some background...We agree that a BTA is critical to an IM nutrition plan. The narrow position was never really intended to be an IM position. The narrowest position was set to allow the left and right armcup to just kiss. In reality, for most people, this is not sustainable for a full IM, but this position could be very aero for a Sprint, Olympic, and maybe a HIM in which the need for a BTA is lower due to the integrated hydration of the fuelcell. For training, where aerodynamics arent a concern you have the ST bosses and the TT bosses.

There ARE some work-arounds however if you REALLY want this position and need a BTA:
  1. BTA Vertical Spacers - this is not a guarantee but can work in some situations - The spacers (with longer bolts) could potentially allow the 3 diameters (Left and Right arm + Bottle) to nest like a Vin diagram
  2. Aftermarket Cups - I know users dont like to hear this, but when there are AM options that can help alleviate this issue
  3. Molded Cockpit - Not a realistic option for most but it can be done
  4. Lateral Offset Spacers - If you run a high hand position, brands like Cinq offer an offset adapter for their cups that can gain ~20mm of clearance or so
  5. Mounting Plate - Threaded plates can be used to fine tune the width https://i0.wp.com/.../2019/10/c.jpg?ssl=1

I have not personally done option 1 or option 2 but I know that some people have. Option 3 is used by 2 of our Pro Athletes (Lucy and Tim). Option 4 is used by Zwift Tri Athlete Levi. Option 5 is used by Zwift Tri Athlete Natia.

For context, I agree arms braced against the bottle are best. But with so many different shapes of fore arms and bottles we cant make it perfect for everyone in the design style we used. A sliding cup was considered but it had impacts on the frontal area we did not want to accept. Having said that, having fit MANY athletes in the tunnel, only 1 had a measurable CdA difference when going from the narrowest position not touching the BTA to the custom solution touching the BTA and that was Natia mentioned above. She is EXTREMELY small individual and her fit was a challenge on many fronts so I consider this an outlier fit. Given her participation in the Zwift Tri Academy though we went full-in to get her as aero as possible. I would not worry to much about the arms not touching the BTA and focus more on how that movement effects your shoulder blades (width & height) and your ability to tuck your neck. You would be surprised how many times wider is faster in the Wintunnel! Consider the solutions above but dont dwell on it!

Now on to some of your "small complaints"

Toothengineer wrote:
-- Small complaints:
1. I wish the bike came with both seat posts, just had to spend more money to get different offset for fit; at this price point give the consumer everything they need and not have to buy more stuff.
2. The arm pads / cups its comes with are super small and its best if you just change them out to bigger ones; I struggle to understand why companies dont make better arm cups and forces the consumer to go to secondary market (general gripe about standard cups that come on new bikes).
3. Different extension options: once again at this price point would be great if you had different options for different degrees of hand rise.

  1. I hear ya on this one. I dont really influence this type of decision but the good thing is that we have an option for you! I think most shops do a good job of helping out riders if this is a REAL issue. I know there were some availability issues but I think this is resolved.
  2. We actually spent a lot of time on the arm cup and personally (obviously) I am very happy with them. I agree that not everyone will feel the same, but generally the feedback has been quite positive. Coming from the old cup, other than riders who run the newer high hand position, the general feeling was that the size was good, but they were too flat. More people wanted the locked in feeling of the Shiv TT cups that improved lateral support when turning or riding 1 handed (grabbing a bottle for example). Due to this feedback we developed many sampled and ultimately picked one that is quite high laterally, but low profile for performance and weight. Remember we have to accommodate Toothpick thin arms all the way to Hulk hogan arms so we ended up with high outer lip with a smaller inside lip to give support but offer wide range of comfort. We doubled down and did a dual density foam core (not done by anyone else that I am aware of) to get the softness where wanted it and finished it off with a very aesthetic dimpled cover that increases tackyness with a little moisture for a nice locked in feel. Of course, this is a touch point, and just like a saddle, we wont make everyone happy! We are also aware of the trend of larger arm cups for more support, but we will leave that to personal preference and the aftermarket as its just too individual at our current manufacturing methods.
  3. I fought for this one but ultimately got shot down. We did redesign the extension during development to be able to be run in both directions so you can run a high hand position. This orientation DOES limit your reach adjustment though so it cant be taken advantage of by everyone. As a result, we kept to the industry standard 22.2mm diameter to make sure the customer has options out there. You lose the window when going aftermarket for internal routing but if its what you need, then its what you need.

Toothengineer wrote:
Question: if we put base bar at up or down angle does it effectively make the bar a little less wide / skinner?

Yes it Does. At 0deg the bar is 420mm center-to-center and in the angle position it is ~403mm center-to-center

Most of your issues are highly personal, but they are real, so thanks for sharing. I hope I could help you and others who are interested in the bike. Once you get it dialed in, enjoy the sailing!

PS We will not redesign for 2020 ;)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
rhodes42 wrote:
Just saw the bike in person and bought it. The non-Shimano shifters do actually have electronic shifting. It appears that specialized added buttons to them afterwards.

can you post pics of the setup on your new bike, and would it be possible to post the model number of the di2 junction box? its info i havnt been able to get on the "cheap" shiv. thanks!

Can do once I take possession.

On that picture you posted, the electronic buttons should be ion the right shifter, hence not in view.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
Most of your issues are highly personal, but they are real, so thanks for sharing. I hope I could help you and others who are interested in the bike. Once you get it dialed in, enjoy the sailing!

and every rider is going to have highly personal issues with ANY halo level bike. those that drop the coin on such a bike want it pretty much perfect.

i for one really appreciate your and other specialized reps being here to answer questions. i know your presence here has taught me a lot about the bikes.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Here is our new arm pad during a first ride of a beta tester in Taiwan.

He rides quite narrow and yes cups do run wide, 123 mm to fit the masses.

Foam is hand cut. Foam Molds being opened as we speak.

https://ibb.co/LJKzxZJ

Joshua
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:

The Shiv Disc Expert DOES have shifting on the basebar. Its just all on the Drive side so you cant see the button in the 3/4 angle picture you see.

The TRP levers have a window that you can remove, and insert a shimano "climbing" satellite shifter to control from the basebar.

The stock configuration only allows you to shift the Rear Derailleur but you can add front if you want to the Non-Drive Side shifter


thanks a lot for that clarification.

what junction box model does the expert use?


Hi Damon,

The Shiv Expert Disc uses the same junction boxes as the S-Works model. So you have the EW-RS910 just above the Nutrition Fuelcell in the downtube (Built-in type Junction A) and the SM-JC41 (4-port Junction B) in the nosecone area.

EDIT: Also, here is a photo of the right TRP lever that houses a Climber Switch to control the RD (or however you chose to set it up).

Last edited by: Cam Piper: Jan 10, 20 9:56
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cam Piper wrote:
Hi Damon,

The Shiv Expert Disc uses the same junction boxes as the S-Works model. So you have the EW-RS910 just above the Nutrition Fuelcell in the downtube (Built-in type Junction A) and the SM-JC41 (4-port Junction B) in the nosecone area.

thanks a lot Cam. That tells me i can pick up an expert model so i get "training wheels", and just get my LBS i buy the shiv through to swap out all the shifters for a DI2 synchro shift setup... correct?

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
Cam Piper wrote:

Hi Damon,

The Shiv Expert Disc uses the same junction boxes as the S-Works model. So you have the EW-RS910 just above the Nutrition Fuelcell in the downtube (Built-in type Junction A) and the SM-JC41 (4-port Junction B) in the nosecone area.


thanks a lot Cam. That tells me i can pick up an expert model so i get "training wheels", and just get my LBS i buy the shiv through to swap out all the shifters for a DI2 synchro shift setup... correct?

Depends on what you prefer - you can still set up the stock buttons as SyncroShift without actually having to change any physical parts. This can all be done through the e-Tube software.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cam Piper] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cam Piper wrote:
damon.lebeouf wrote:

Depends on what you prefer - you can still set up the stock buttons as SyncroShift without actually having to change any physical parts. This can all be done through the e-Tube software.
my current bike has the "new" shimano DI2 shifers... just a single button on the left and right side of the aero and base bar. im used to it so its cool knowing i could swap the buttons out and be ready to roll like im used to.

thanks man!

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi!im going to buy this bike. Im tall 1,80m and my insane 89cm my sadle is at 80,9 cm from the center of BB. Do you think i need L size? Specialized shiv finder recomend m L size. Thsnks and sorry about my english
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thank you for this response.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [igor46] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
igor46 wrote:
Hi!im going to buy this bike. Im tall 1,80m and my insane 89cm my sadle is at 80,9 cm from the center of BB. Do you think i need L size? Specialized shiv finder recomend m L size. Thsnks and sorry about my english

Hi igor46

Yes you definitely need a LRG. The max saddle height for a MED is 872mm. Enjoy!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Here is my update with this bike (if I can ever get my shit together will do a video on it all): I am by no means a bike expert and this is just my honest no bias takeaways from this bike.

This is my 7th TT Bike Since 2013: 1st Gen Shiv, Felt IA FRD, 4 trek speed concepts.

First ride on it was this weekend. 75 miles, mild to med winds (cross tail head) all day.

Bike handles very well. Just feels very stable at all speed in all wind conditions. Hit 48-49mph 2x during this ride and Shiv felt incredibly stable.

Was able to fit 2 tubes and 3 co2s into the frame tube with no issues.

Had to do 2 small fit adj while riding to dial in fit both very easy to do.

I still find even with the 15 degree shims and using 51ss extensions very front and is not how I personally would like it (I would also say I am extremely picky and OCD in this regard. With the 51ss pads was able to move the arms closer to where I am actually touching the BTA bottle.

The down tube storage area is a bit cumbersome to reach to, but sure I will get more used to this with time.

I still really dont like how wide that base bar is and wonder how people smaller then me would feel about it. I have not tilted it down yet which as mentioned above should decease the width some.

With current set up and mounting a Garmin I have to turn the BTA bottle backwards as well something I dont like, working on a workaround now.

I was very surprised how good the wheels where in wind, was really not expecting them to be as stable as they where since reviews I had seen seemed mixed. I can't believe I am writing this considering I have been a zipp and Enve junky the past 5 years, but I would say that felt every bit as good in the wind as a pair Enve 7.8 or Zipp 858's.

Overall its a very sexy bike that handles and rides well. Will continue to work on the front end to get it how I want it. I currently have a wattshop extensions system reserved for their next orders.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks for that awesome review. its great to hear some more user feedback from the bike.

did you fiddle at all with the rear hydration setup to see how that would work "real life"? or is that one of the features you're going to test down the road?

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
thanks for that awesome review. its great to hear some more user feedback from the bike.

did you fiddle at all with the rear hydration setup to see how that would work "real life"? or is that one of the features you're going to test down the road?

No that next up as well. Gone next 2 weekends so will report back in 3 weeks.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Another question...

Does it have the road bike feel like everyone is saying, or does it still have the tri bike feel? Handling wise I should qualify I guess.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
Another question...

Does it have the road bike feel like everyone is saying, or does it still have the tri bike feel? Handling wise I should qualify I guess.

Who says its feels like a road bike! lol. No its feels like a TT bike 100%. Having the base bar so wide does throw me off though as well. Trek and Cevelo base bars must be at min 1in less wide. Having this wide base bar also affects handling and climbing I found since when you put a lot of pressure (when climbing) it seems to torque the bike more. Would have loved to see more interchangeable parts on base bar to make it not as wide.

That being sad I think it handles superior to the Felt FRD I had and feels less tank like compared to the Trek.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cool! All the pros at release were saying it handled a lot like the venge and not like the old shiv. Marketing I guess.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Now I was not riding it with the hydration in the back guess that could affect handling some.

I am also comparing to my other TT bikes, a gen 1 venge and a new madone. Itā€™s just comparing apples to oranges to look at this vs a road bike in handling.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi all.

My seat post according to retul is 758mm. Would somebody be able to tell me the amount of space I would have between my seat and the top of the water reservoir cover at the back. Would I be able to have a bottle fitted in between the two? ( similar set up as on this webpage https://www.triathlete.com/...rks-shiv-disc_377645.

Also
Any news on Shimano 12 for tt bikes by any chance?
Last edited by: Andyukr: Feb 2, 20 3:44
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andyukr] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Andyukr wrote:
Hi all.

My seat post according to retul is 758mm. Would somebody be able to tell me the amount of space I would have between my seat and the top of the water reservoir cover at the back. Would I be able to have a bottle fitted in between the two? ( similar set up as on this webpage https://www.triathlete.com/...rks-shiv-disc_377645.

Hi Andyukr,

On a size Medium frame with your saddle height, you would have ~6mm depending on type of saddle, etc...A bottle would technically fit like you show on Tim Don's bike but it would take some mounting creativity as a cage may be difficult to fit in there.

You could do a more upright bottle position, but this makes leg swing over a bit more tricky

Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Are you trying to come up with a solution for a rear water bottle? I saw some of the Zwift academy folks and a few other guys at Kona do this like Tim Don, but I think it's pretty temporary. You hit bumps or get some strong winds and that bottle won't stay.

Lucy Charles had a set up at Kona this year from Vision that allowed for two bottles on either side of the sail. I've set it up on my bike and it works for extra water at IM distance, however it does make filling the bladder a bit tricky. It can be done without issue, you just need to have good aim!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [spectrum5825] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
spectrum5825 wrote:
Are you trying to come up with a solution for a rear water bottle? I saw some of the Zwift academy folks and a few other guys at Kona do this like Tim Don, but I think it's pretty temporary. You hit bumps or get some strong winds and that bottle won't stay.

Lucy Charles had a set up at Kona this year from Vision that allowed for two bottles on either side of the sail. I've set it up on my bike and it works for extra water at IM distance, however it does make filling the bladder a bit tricky. It can be done without issue, you just need to have good aim!

i think this is the one she was using.

https://shop.visiontechusa.com/...ear-hydration-system

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
yes. I confirmed with Vision and is also the one I purchased. They make a carbon and not carbon version. Both fit.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [spectrum5825] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Huge thanks!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thank you very much for your reply!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andyukr] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have just ordered a Shiv TT disc and Iā€™m very excited for this! I have noticed that stack is 495 mm in all size (S M L) and maybe is a little bit low. I notice that handlebar have a slight tilt up so maybe it compensate a little bit the low stack. Do you think it could be possible to put a 1cm spacer under the stem (that is a traditional stem)
Sorry for my english!



[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]

[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]

[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]
Last edited by: enricobraglia: Feb 9, 20 12:41
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
I have just ordered a Shiv TT disc and Iā€™m very excited for this! I have noticed that stack is 495 mm in all size (S M L) and maybe is a little bit low. I notice that handlebar have a slight tilt up so maybe it compensate a little bit the low stack. Do you think it could be possible to put a 1cm spacer under the stem (that is a traditional stem)
Sorry for my english!

Hi enricobraglia, no you cannot do this. The steerer is cut from the factory as-designed to be flush...if you were to try and space the cockpit system up, you would not have enough steerer to efficiently clamp the system.

The bike is designed to stack from the pedestals, and not the basebar.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
No.

The cockpit is designed around the flush stem/bar combination. You can adjust stack using the plethora of included spacers

I'm really enjoying my Shiv TT, but have a few recommendations.
1) the Stock arm pads/cups are genuinely awful - 51 Speedshop or Aerocoach replacements are much better, IMHO
2) I really wish the basebar width was significantly narrower, and dropped away from the rider.
3) If you're going to rebuild it with Di2, the inside of the basebar gets awfully cramped, and it can be hard to get everything in there and get the stem cap down. Instead of following the specialized recommended Di2 eTube length recommendations, measure it and get the size you actually need.
4) It should have come with Di2 from the factory.
5) The website shows that it comes with an extra Turbo Cotton tire for the disc - it does not.
6) The Sitero will probably not work for you. I went to Boulder and had a fit at the Specialized center, and the guy that fit me said that nobody he's fit to one has kept the saddle.
7) Disc Brakes on a TT bike are the greatest thing ever.
8) It will clear 32 Road tires, barely.
9) But seriously, Disc brakes on a TT bike are the greatest thing ever.
10) There aren't many out there. I had a specialized store tell me that the bike was counterfeit and that Specialized wasn't making a Shiv TT any more, much less one in Disc. So...best to make sure whomever you have service/build it has a factory manual for the bike.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
I have just ordered a Shiv TT disc and Iā€™m very excited for this! I have noticed that stack is 495 mm in all size (S M L) and maybe is a little bit low. I notice that handlebar have a slight tilt up so maybe it compensate a little bit the low stack. Do you think it could be possible to put a 1cm spacer under the stem (that is a traditional stem)
Sorry for my english!


Hi enricobraglia, no you cannot do this. The steerer is cut from the factory as-designed to be flush...if you were to try and space the cockpit system up, you would not have enough steerer to efficiently clamp the system.

The bike is designed to stack from the pedestals, and not the basebar.

Thank you! Maybe the handlebar can gain some mm of stack?

[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [RKW] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RKW wrote:
No.

The cockpit is designed around the flush stem/bar combination. You can adjust stack using the plethora of included spacers

I'm really enjoying my Shiv TT, but have a few recommendations.
1) the Stock arm pads/cups are genuinely awful - 51 Speedshop or Aerocoach replacements are much better, IMHO
2) I really wish the basebar width was significantly narrower, and dropped away from the rider.
3) If you're going to rebuild it with Di2, the inside of the basebar gets awfully cramped, and it can be hard to get everything in there and get the stem cap down. Instead of following the specialized recommended Di2 eTube length recommendations, measure it and get the size you actually need.
4) It should have come with Di2 from the factory.
5) The website shows that it comes with an extra Turbo Cotton tire for the disc - it does not.
6) The Sitero will probably not work for you. I went to Boulder and had a fit at the Specialized center, and the guy that fit me said that nobody he's fit to one has kept the saddle.
7) Disc Brakes on a TT bike are the greatest thing ever.
8) It will clear 32 Road tires, barely.
9) But seriously, Disc brakes on a TT bike are the greatest thing ever.
10) There aren't many out there. I had a specialized store tell me that the bike was counterfeit and that Specialized wasn't making a Shiv TT any more, much less one in Disc. So...best to make sure whomever you have service/build it has a factory manual for the bike.


Thank you!
1) I like so much (in photo) Shiv arm pad but Iā€™m ready with Aerocoach armpad and D2Z extensions;
3) I will mount Sram AXS 12v
6) I like so much Sitero but I have also ISM PN 3.0
7) I think that disc brakes are great in road bike but also for TT in roads like Lanzarote, Nice etc

Which size have you?

[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]
Last edited by: enricobraglia: Feb 10, 20 13:46
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
I have just ordered a Shiv TT disc and Iā€™m very excited for this! I have noticed that stack is 495 mm in all size (S M L) and maybe is a little bit low. I notice that handlebar have a slight tilt up so maybe it compensate a little bit the low stack. Do you think it could be possible to put a 1cm spacer under the stem (that is a traditional stem)
Sorry for my english!


Hi enricobraglia, no you cannot do this. The steerer is cut from the factory as-designed to be flush...if you were to try and space the cockpit system up, you would not have enough steerer to efficiently clamp the system.

The bike is designed to stack from the pedestals, and not the basebar.


Thank you! Maybe the handlebar can gain some mm of stack?



Hi enricobraglia,

Since this is the SHIV Tri thread and NOT the Shiv TT thread, it would be helpful to others to move this conversation to the other thread. Anyway, the information you are looking for is as follows:


The basebar only offers 2mm of rise...the distance from the upper bearing is ~45mm shown below. You cannot change the stack of the basebar so it doesnt really matter.


Last edited by: GatorRacer: Feb 10, 20 14:13
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thank you Gatorracer and sorry for my posts in the wrong thread šŸ‘šŸ»
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
The basebar only offers 2mm of rise...the distance from the upper bearing is ~45mm shown below. You cannot change the stack of the basebar so it doesnt really matter.

Were there any basebars made that were narrower and lower? Prototype purposes or whatever? Just curious why the decision was made just for no-rise 40's.

also, idk if you are the person to thank for this, but thank you for going to a BSA BB. Oh so much. (and for once, not being sarcastic).
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [RKW] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RKW wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:

The basebar only offers 2mm of rise...the distance from the upper bearing is ~45mm shown below. You cannot change the stack of the basebar so it doesnt really matter.


Were there any basebars made that were narrower and lower? Prototype purposes or whatever? Just curious why the decision was made just for no-rise 40's.

also, idk if you are the person to thank for this, but thank you for going to a BSA BB. Oh so much. (and for once, not being sarcastic).

Different bar shapes were evaluated in prototyping but the last generation TT was fixed also (other than a few custom bars) and the feedback from Pro Tour riders was generally positive in this regard.

TT is not tri and the time spent in the basebar if quite minimal. The focus on the TT was Aero and Weight so having the most efficient structure as possible was priority. Also in TT you can routinely be sprinting at the start and finish unlike in Tri, so the stiffness does come into play...the Aggressive position is preferred for aerodynamic reasons mainly, and offering bars of multiple stacks is not feasible on a low volume bike. Being lower is better for technical descents at high speeds when the extensions may not be enough

The TT bike is quite a specialist tool and admittedly doesnt offer as much fit flexibility...this is evident by the limited stack range offering which reduce frontal area, and the bikes only varying in reach.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I change my order and I switch to Shiv Triathlon disc instead Shiv TT disc. Too low stack for me.
Now I am in topic šŸ˜„
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andyukr] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Andyukr wrote:
Hi all.

My seat post according to retul is 758mm. Would somebody be able to tell me the amount of space I would have between my seat and the top of the water reservoir cover at the back. Would I be able to have a bottle fitted in between the two? ( similar set up as on this webpage https://www.triathlete.com/...rks-shiv-disc_377645.

Also
Any news on Shimano 12 for tt bikes by any chance?

I donā€™t understand how the bottle is fixed! šŸ§
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
Andyukr wrote:
Hi all.

My seat post according to retul is 758mm. Would somebody be able to tell me the amount of space I would have between my seat and the top of the water reservoir cover at the back. Would I be able to have a bottle fitted in between the two? ( similar set up as on this webpage https://www.triathlete.com/...rks-shiv-disc_377645.

Also
Any news on Shimano 12 for tt bikes by any chance?


I donā€™t understand how the bottle is fixed! šŸ§

That bottle isnt actually a "bottle"...its cut open on the top and secured to the hydration system to act as a funnel for refilling on the fly.

I dont recommend it for most people due to the possibility of contamination coming out of the water, or from perspiration in general
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Looks like others have tried the same. Search for levi hauwert

Or here https://www.instagram.com/...igshid=1qsysql4srkzm
Last edited by: Andyukr: Feb 14, 20 13:36
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks Gator šŸ‘šŸ»
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andyukr] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Andyukr wrote:
Looks like others have tried the same. Search for levi hauwert

Or here https://www.instagram.com/...igshid=1qsysql4srkzm

Tim Don is his coach ;)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Which is the most simple solution to angled the extensions? I found this wonderful solution from Ride Sync but itā€™s expensive and no available in short time

[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
Andyukr wrote:
Hi all.

My seat post according to retul is 758mm. Would somebody be able to tell me the amount of space I would have between my seat and the top of the water reservoir cover at the back. Would I be able to have a bottle fitted in between the two? ( similar set up as on this webpage https://www.triathlete.com/...rks-shiv-disc_377645.


Hi Andyukr,

On a size Medium frame with your saddle height, you would have ~6mm depending on type of saddle, etc...A bottle would technically fit like you show on Tim Don's bike but it would take some mounting creativity as a cage may be difficult to fit in there.

You could do a more upright bottle position, but this makes leg swing over a bit more tricky

My saddle height is 718/720 mm. I am also between sizes (S & M). Given that saddle height, would there be any problem with an M size regarding clearance with the reservoir? Could you please give this measurement for size M? ->



Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
Which is the most simple solution to angled the extensions? I found this wonderful solution from Ride Sync but itā€™s expensive and no available in short time

[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]

i ran across these guys a little before they started posting the pics of their shiv product. their setup looks VERY nice. im digging it a lot. they have also said they are going to develop their own BTA hydration system to address the needs of those doing more than a 70.3

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i need some help from those that have done fits on this bike and the specialized reps.

the shiv finder doesnt seen to work in any browser... when i get to the last measurement i cant even put the full number in and it just jumps to the recommendation, which is a small. which doesnt seem right to me at all. im 5'10'' and ive never been recommended in a small bike... always in between a M and L.

my reach from BB to back of pad is 495.
stack from BB is 625
BB to seat center is right at 750.

this is a screen shot of the shiv finder, using my bike NOT on a trainer.



that 0 for the arm pad width should be 190, what i currently have on my bike. that accommodates a BTA setup.


another note... the shiv bike finder doesnt allow measurements of anything more than 300 on the stack and reach if you know those numbers and choose that fit route to take.

another note... im in either a 56 or 58 in a P5Disc (right on the edge) and pretty firmly in a large PX bike per their fit charts.

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Last edited by: damon.lebeouf: Feb 15, 20 14:41
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
Which is the most simple solution to angled the extensions? I found this wonderful solution from Ride Sync but itā€™s expensive and no available in short time


Hi enricobraglia,

The simplest solution is the included 10degree arm cup wedges. These potentially add a few mm's in stack and can limit your fit range a bit, but it typically is not an issue, and is the easiest.

While I think the Sync solution is clean and effective, please note that this concept dramatically limits your fit range. Their design adaptation does not allow pass through of the extensions, and allows you to only run a reach that is quite forward. You do get to move the arm cup a little bit, but where the original design has a near "infinite" reach adjustment, the Sync setup is nearly fixed. If you have a longer reach, this is a cool solution though!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [duduardoman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
duduardoman wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
Andyukr wrote:
Hi all.

My seat post according to retul is 758mm. Would somebody be able to tell me the amount of space I would have between my seat and the top of the water reservoir cover at the back. Would I be able to have a bottle fitted in between the two? ( similar set up as on this webpage https://www.triathlete.com/...rks-shiv-disc_377645.


Hi Andyukr,

On a size Medium frame with your saddle height, you would have ~6mm depending on type of saddle, etc...A bottle would technically fit like you show on Tim Don's bike but it would take some mounting creativity as a cage may be difficult to fit in there.

You could do a more upright bottle position, but this makes leg swing over a bit more tricky


My saddle height is 718/720 mm. I am also between sizes (S & M). Given that saddle height, would there be any problem with an M size regarding clearance with the reservoir? Could you please give this measurement for size M? ->

Hi duduardoman,

You are very much a candidate for a SM or XS frame...Unless your reach is very very long, You would never be a medium. Who has advised you that you are between a SM and MD?

Your saddle height requires a XS frame, or a SM frame with the Forward offset seatpost to clear the reservoir without cutting.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
i need some help from those that have done fits on this bike and the specialized reps.

the shiv finder doesnt seen to work in any browser... when i get to the last measurement i cant even put the full number in and it just jumps to the recommendation, which is a small. which doesnt seem right to me at all. im 5'10'' and ive never been recommended in a small bike... always in between a M and L.

my reach from BB to back of pad is 495.
stack from BB is 625
BB to seat center is right at 750.


Hi damon.lebeouf,

You are definitely a medium...no uncertainty based on what you have provided. You will have a very tight clearance to the Fuelcell but you are clear
Last edited by: GatorRacer: Feb 18, 20 14:43
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks so much for the help!!!

iā€™m assuming no way i could move up to a large for the bigger hydration cell due to the seat being so tight?

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damon.lebeouf wrote:
thanks so much for the help!!!

iā€™m assuming no way i could move up to a large for the bigger hydration cell due to the seat being so tight?

It is technically possible, but I would not recommend it. You would need to go to the FWD post and/or cut & you would be at the very bottom of the fit range for LG and have less flexibility. The Medium doesnt sacrifice much capacity and it will handle better for you.

Have confidence in the Medium. We went from 5sizes to 4sizes with the new bike so its good that people are paying attention to the fit and not assuming based on past experience!

As always, a RETUL fit is going to be the best assurance you can have to the best fit due to a variety of factors that we dont always have available to us here
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
Which is the most simple solution to angled the extensions? I found this wonderful solution from Ride Sync but itā€™s expensive and no available in short time



Hi enricobraglia,

The simplest solution is the included 10degree arm cup wedges. These potentially add a few mm's in stack and can limit your fit range a bit, but it typically is not an issue, and is the easiest.

While I think the Sync solution is clean and effective, please note that this concept dramatically limits your fit range. Their design adaptation does not allow pass through of the extensions, and allows you to only run a reach that is quite forward. You do get to move the arm cup a little bit, but where the original design has a near "infinite" reach adjustment, the Sync setup is nearly fixed. If you have a longer reach, this is a cool solution though!

Thank you Gator for your reply. The 10 degrees arm cup wedges angle only the arm cups and not the extension. I would like to assume a mantis posizion and I have an Drag2Zero Hi Rise extensions that can reach 35 degrees. I would like to tilt at 50 degrees
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You will get 5mm of adj with the ride synch pads, this is that last the told me. They also dont have a solution yet for running a BTA in term of a fixed mount thats integrated, but they are working on this.

I am looking currently at:

Ride Synch

Wattshop

Speed bar

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I swapped for the Sync Ergo high rising extensions, and installed the wedge at arm pads. Works like a charm, apart from some wires sticking out (which I should be able to fix once I drill some holes into the extensions)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [melvody] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
melvody wrote:
I swapped for the Sync Ergo high rising extensions, and installed the wedge at arm pads. Works like a charm, apart from some wires sticking out (which I should be able to fix once I drill some holes into the extensions)
can you post pics if your setup?

80/20 Endurance Ambassador
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hello.
I am new on the forum. I am French excuse me for my English.
I would like to have information on the shiv disc (in France it is very complicated to have information concerning this bike).
I would like to know the weight of the bike?
Is the hydration system easy to remove and clean?
I would like a bike that is not too complicated to ride in the mountains.
I hesitate between the P5 disc which is certainly lighter and more "going everywhere".
If you can help me.
Thank you in advance
Roman
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Romain] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Romain wrote:
Hello.
I am new on the forum. I am French excuse me for my English.
I would like to have information on the shiv disc (in France it is very complicated to have information concerning this bike).
I would like to know the weight of the bike?
Is the hydration system easy to remove and clean?
I would like a bike that is not too complicated to ride in the mountains.
I hesitate between the P5 disc which is certainly lighter and more "going everywhere".
If you can help me.
Thank you in advance
Roman

Hey Roman,

Depending on size and spec the bike is ~9.2kg...Fully loaded ready to race, my medium is ~9.7kg with a disc wheel, pedals, cages, computer, etc...no water

I will let others comment on the ease of hydration system since I am biased, but usability was a high priority in the design and why cleaning attachments and accessories are provided. Generally, if you're running just water, I think its quite manageable...If running nutrition mix its obviously much more tedious.

Having said that, usually the internal bladder is a "race day" feature and for training rides a BTA is sufficient

The bike climbs exceptionally well in my opinion, and the disc brakes and associated through axle stiffness make descending and out of saddle climbing much better than legacy tri bikes.

P5 is also a nice bike but they are in slightly different classes...It depends on how you race to know which is better. Good luck!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hello,
Thank you for your reply.
I have to think again.
Thank you
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Romain] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Do you think is possible (and safe) to cut the shim to angle the handlebars?

[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
Do you think is possible (and safe) to cut the shim to angle the handlebars?

[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]

100% not ok and wonā€™t work
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If anyone is looking to buy a shiv let me know, not posted for sale yet but its coming. Have red frame with Sram 1x and power meter. Have some 51ss extension and a disc wheel as well. Not sure on pricing but will be well below MSRP. Ridden bike 3x outside. Longest ride 115 miles.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If you are based in Europe I am looking for size M
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andyukr] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Texas sorry.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andres] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Do the bars(and elbow pads) tilt up like you thought they might?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DBF] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
They do have a pretty nice tilt to them.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DBF] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have no idea, sorry... havenā€™t seen one of these in person.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Toothengineer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How does it achieve a tilt of the pad, does the spacer have an angle?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DBF] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yes.... I have listing out for this bike on tri and sell it and few other FB sites, if have a good pic of this there.

2024: Bevoman, Galveston, Alcatraz, Marble Falls, Santa Cruz
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DBF] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DBF wrote:
Do the bars(and elbow pads) tilt up like you thought they might?

10degree arm cup spacers are included in the fit kit.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ericMPro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Do you happen to know how many centimeters of spacer That thing could accomodate? I think I would need seven, and that just seems a bit janky.
83cm saddle height with 12cm drop.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DBF] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DBF wrote:
Do you happen to know how many centimeters of spacer That thing could accomodate? I think I would need seven, and that just seems a bit janky.
83cm saddle height with 12cm drop.

The # of spacers is dependent of frame size. What is your stack height?

There is 115mm of stack adjust per size.

The included spacers are:
2x40mm
1x20mm
1x10mm
1x5mm
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi all.

Looking at purchasing a hydration bladder from the current 2020 shiv for a project. Only catch some far is that this link;

https://www.certini.co.uk/...fuelcell--clear.aspx

lists 4 sizes. Are there actually 4 sizes of bladder or only 1?

Ie volume and dimensions.

Cheers ahead of time.

Stay safe everyone.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [tileman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tileman wrote:
Hi all.

Looking at purchasing a hydration bladder from the current 2020 shiv for a project. Only catch some far is that this link;

https://www.certini.co.uk/...fuelcell--clear.aspx

lists 4 sizes. Are there actually 4 sizes of bladder or only 1?

Ie volume and dimensions.

Cheers ahead of time.

Stay safe everyone.

There is of course 4 sizes, 1 per frame size
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cheers. Anyone have an idea of the volume difference?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [tileman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
tileman wrote:
Cheers. Anyone have an idea of the volume difference?

Its not linear but between 100-150ml between each size
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hello,

I am about to buy s-works shiv disc. I cannot decide which size I should buy. I feel that I might be a bit big for medium and a bit small for large. What do you think based on my data below?

LENGTH 180cm / 5.11
REACH TO CENTER OF PAD 505
STACK TO PAD HOLDER 655
SADDLE HEIGHT 750
CRANK LENGHT 170

Do you know the amount of space I would have between my seat and the top of the water reservoir cover at the back in size L? I wonā€™t be using any bottle holders at the back and I am using ISM Adamo Prologue saddle.

Based on my figures, my saddle would be 40mm above the water reservoir cover at the back (size M, tested it at the local bike shop) and just under 10mm (size L) if the water reservoir cover will be similar size in relation to the Large frame? The Large frame will be 32mm higher, do you have idea how much bigger / higher the water reservoir is? The local bike shop were not able to answer this...

Will that space (10mm) be enough to use the water reservoir properly?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mizzipp] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mizzipp wrote:
Hello,

I am about to buy s-works shiv disc. I cannot decide which size I should buy. I feel that I might be a bit big for medium and a bit small for large. What do you think based on my data below?

LENGTH 180cm / 5.11
REACH TO CENTER OF PAD 505
STACK TO PAD HOLDER 655
SADDLE HEIGHT 750
CRANK LENGHT 170

Do you know the amount of space I would have between my seat and the top of the water reservoir cover at the back in size L? I wonā€™t be using any bottle holders at the back and I am using ISM Adamo Prologue saddle.

Based on my figures, my saddle would be 40mm above the water reservoir cover at the back (size M, tested it at the local bike shop) and just under 10mm (size L) if the water reservoir cover will be similar size in relation to the Large frame? The Large frame will be 32mm higher, do you have idea how much bigger / higher the water reservoir is? The local bike shop were not able to answer this...

Will that space (10mm) be enough to use the water reservoir properly?

Hello mizzipp,

Given the information provided, I would suggest a MD frame. The Size LRG will not support your saddle height without hassle. You are in the middle of the fit range for the MD so I think you will be very happy with this decision.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hello,

Thank you for your reply. Very much appreciated!

I am worried about the reach in size Medium. I would like to have a similar set up what is in the pictures attached. If you put the extensions "the wrong way around" (15 degree angle) you do not really have too much room to increase reach? In this case, the maximum reach will be around 500mm or am I missing something?

Do you know what would be the "minimum" saddle height in size Large? Could you advise me what kind hassle I have with my saddle height if I end up buying size Large?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mizzipp] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mizzipp wrote:
Hello,

Thank you for your reply. Very much appreciated!

I am worried about the reach in size Medium. I would like to have a similar set up what is in the pictures attached. If you put the extensions "the wrong way around" (15 degree angle) you do not really have too much room to increase reach? In this case, the maximum reach will be around 500mm or am I missing something?

Do you know what would be the "minimum" saddle height in size Large? Could you advise me what kind hassle I have with my saddle height if I end up buying size Large?

You are correct that flipping the extensions greatly reduces the reach adjustment. What is your reach to end of extension in this arrangement?

What I am trying to help with now is making sure a medium will work since you are using the bike in a very specific arrangement. On a MD with 505mm pad reach, you will be able to run the reversed extensions. It actually may be harder on the LRG because your reach will require the crossbar to go in the rearward position which may be problematic with the flipped extension.

The bottom line is that you are definitely not a LRG based on your saddle height (you are pushing MD fitment). To fit a LRG you MUST use the +25mm offset post, and you will need to cut that post to get it low enough in the frame, and even so you will be very close to the hydration system meaning servicing it will be more challenging. This is not a recommending configuration, and I would not pursue this without having a detailed discussion with your fitter and shop, because the risk of wasted $$ is high.

I would recommend a heart2heart with your fitter and go for a medium!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks again for your guidance! Very helpful!

Luckily, I have time to solve this issue as there are no races happening in the meantime (and the edition of Kona 2020 postponed until Feb 2021).

Flipping the extensions or using other extension with high angle 35 or higher will reduce the reach capacity too much. The maximum we were able to get with the flipped extensions was 470mm (BB to center of the pads, Size Medium). Whereas I would hope to have 480-490mm reach, depending the race (IM 70.3 or IM 140.6). I do not want to compromise my saddle position (now 50mm from to BB). The flat part of the extensions is the limiting factor of having the wanted reach.

I kind of feel that I need to challenge your opinion about the size and that Large frame seem to be the only option? The local bike shop has promised to cut the water reservoir at the back that much that I am able to utilize the hydration system without touching the saddle/seatpost.

However, I am stressed the fact what you said in your earlier post that it could be harder to run the reversed extensions in Large frame. Based on my calculations, it does not require the crossbar to go in the rearward position, but I might have errors in my calculations. Could you advise if I am missing something?

The local dealer has been super helpful and thanks to the bike fitter there, I have the luxury of running the set up the Medium Size bike. I want to go ahead with this bike/model, but figuring out the right size seem to take more time what I expected.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [mizzipp] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mizzipp wrote:
Thanks again for your guidance! Very helpful!

Luckily, I have time to solve this issue as there are no races happening in the meantime (and the edition of Kona 2020 postponed until Feb 2021).

Flipping the extensions or using other extension with high angle 35 or higher will reduce the reach capacity too much. The maximum we were able to get with the flipped extensions was 470mm (BB to center of the pads, Size Medium). Whereas I would hope to have 480-490mm reach, depending the race (IM 70.3 or IM 140.6). I do not want to compromise my saddle position (now 50mm from to BB). The flat part of the extensions is the limiting factor of having the wanted reach.

I kind of feel that I need to challenge your opinion about the size and that Large frame seem to be the only option? The local bike shop has promised to cut the water reservoir at the back that much that I am able to utilize the hydration system without touching the saddle/seatpost.

However, I am stressed the fact what you said in your earlier post that it could be harder to run the reversed extensions in Large frame. Based on my calculations, it does not require the crossbar to go in the rearward position, but I might have errors in my calculations. Could you advise if I am missing something?

The local dealer has been super helpful and thanks to the bike fitter there, I have the luxury of running the set up the Medium Size bike. I want to go ahead with this bike/model, but figuring out the right size seem to take more time what I expected.

I would trust your fitter. You have not given me all of your fit dimensions and you say you want to change the dimensions given, so obviously much more goes into a quality fit than stack, reach, and saddle height...for example the saddle offset that you mention.

I still think your saddle height is not good for a LRG. Yes, you can cut the reservoir, but then you lose capacity, etc...Why cut the reservoir when you can just get the medium that is already shorter? I would go with an Aftermarket high rise extension before I did all of that but if your fitter thinks it can work, go for it!

If you have a medium, why not set it up as close as possible to your fit with the extensions the traditional way, and find out EXACTLY how much you need?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hello All !!

My seat post is 700 mm, I'm between size XS and S but I read in this forum "better big size".....

For this 700mm is available in size S for enough space for Fuelcell reservoir?

Thanks for this site and all collaborations .


Note for Tileman: I know for repository XS : 1 litre / for S: 1.15 litre (38.8 oz) I hope help you with this dates.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [bomond] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi. Anyone her tryed 28mm tires on this one?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Likeglad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Anyone got any views or reviews of the bike theyā€™d like to share ?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [UK Gearmuncher] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Is there really no aero data put out still on this bike ? Iā€™m interested in both this and the tt but I want to see some form of comparison through the yaw angles to at least their old bikes.

Will there be some kind of tilt kit for the extensions coming ? That would be really helpful and whilst I love Specializeds quality, thatā€™s a contemporary requirement really.
Last edited by: UK Gearmuncher: Jun 7, 20 3:10
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [bomond] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bomond wrote:
Hello All !!

My seat post is 700 mm, I'm between size XS and S but I read in this forum "better big size".....

For this 700mm is available in size S for enough space for Fuelcell reservoir?

700mm will work on a SM frame if you use the forward offset post. It will work on the XS with either post

Consider your reach as the next most important figure (Stack is same between SM and XS)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Likeglad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Likeglad wrote:
Hi. Anyone her tryed 28mm tires on this one?

A measured 28mm will fit. An actual 28c usually fits but it will depend on the rim selection. The frame will clear but some situations can be quite close to the fuelcell
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
Likeglad wrote:
Hi. Anyone her tryed 28mm tires on this one?


A measured 28mm will fit. An actual 28c usually fits but it will depend on the rim selection. The frame will clear but some situations can be quite close to the fuelcell

GatorRacer, can you state what 'optimised for Kona' means in terms of specifics ? Many of us won't be racing there and I want to know what yaw angle this bike was designed for so I can make an informed decision based upon what I typically ride and race over. Saying its designed for cross winds isn't sadly specific enough in this day and age.

Do you also have anything you can share about how this bike performs at low yaws ?

Many thanks in advance.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Specialized's website only mentions the size of the front axle, what is the size of the rear axle? 12x142?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [bigsas] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bigsas wrote:
Specialized's website only mentions the size of the front axle, what is the size of the rear axle? 12x142?

Correct
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
There are obviously a few owners of these now. Has anyone had an aerofit done on one in either the windtunnel or the velodrome and have any anecdotal feedback they can share ?

It would be great if they offered a non folding basebar aftermarket part for those of us that don't travel as this would refine the front end a lot by thinning out the hinge frontal area (which is the only part of the whole bike I dislike).
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is really interesting. Shiv Finder tells me that I could go Small or XS. More specifically, it says I can use a 25mm setback seatpost. If my BB to top of seat is 710mm and BB to seat clamp is 665mm, do you know if there is enough clearance for a bottle? Thanks in advance for the mockup.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [shinacmaha] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
shinacmaha wrote:
This is really interesting. Shiv Finder tells me that I could go Small or XS. More specifically, it says I can use a 25mm setback seatpost. If my BB to top of seat is 710mm and BB to seat clamp is 665mm, do you know if there is enough clearance for a bottle? Thanks in advance for the mockup.

Hey shinacmaha

You are right at the borderline. On a size SMALL you can utilize the system without modification as long as you use the forward offset (+25mm) seatpost. If you use the Standard 0mm offset post you would have slight interference.

On size XS you can use either post.

As long as your saddle setback and reach are OK with the +25mm post, I would recommend the SMALL. Make sure your dealer knows you will want this post because availability during COVID-19 may be varied
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Dan wrote in his review that the L size of the new Shiv is really only large and people taller than 6ā€™3 may find the bike too tight. I am between 6ā€™3 and 6ā€™4. I can fit on the bike with my pad X and Y (475 and 690, but I will likely move a bit longer and lower with time) according to Shivā€™s specs, but I wonder whether the frame may be too small for me and lacking in handling as a result. It has unusual specs: its front center in L is 627mm which is normal for L/56 and is probably on the short side for me, however its wheelbase is 1031mm which is more XL/58 territory. Any ideas on whether this can be a good bike for me? Thanks.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks for the quick response. really appreciate the information and service.... really helpful when deciding b/t options.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Couple of questions that I couldn't find on the website.

Do you know if the Shiv Disc can do 140mm brake rotors front and rear? Tim Don in an interview said his were 160mm front and rear for easier universal on course wheel support. However, I'd like to be able to switch out wheels sets that I have.

What is the maximum tire clearance for the Shiv Disc? I've got 28mm on my Tarmac now which is closer to 30mm inflated. Will those fit in the Shiv Disc?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Dimm] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Dimm wrote:
Dan wrote in his review that the L size of the new Shiv is really only large and people taller than 6ā€™3 may find the bike too tight. I am between 6ā€™3 and 6ā€™4. I can fit on the bike with my pad X and Y (475 and 690, but I will likely move a bit longer and lower with time) according to Shivā€™s specs, but I wonder whether the frame may be too small for me and lacking in handling as a result. It has unusual specs: its front center in L is 627mm which is normal for L/56 and is probably on the short side for me, however its wheelbase is 1031mm which is more XL/58 territory. Any ideas on whether this can be a good bike for me? Thanks.



Hi Dimm


I think the LRG will be an ideal fit for you. Your pad position will basically be centered on the fork and your stack is mid range so you have plenty of room to adjust your fit and handling should be as designed.

Remember the new shiv went to 4 sizes from a previous 5, and the design philosophy largely transitioned to get fit through adjustment in the cockpit and not in the frame. This allows for lower frontal area for most riders and improved aero.

Handling of this bike I would describe as stable, and unless you have a really long reach, it should not be a factor.
Last edited by: GatorRacer: Jul 16, 20 7:56
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [shinacmaha] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
shinacmaha wrote:
Couple of questions that I couldn't find on the website.

Do you know if the Shiv Disc can do 140mm brake rotors front and rear? Tim Don in an interview said his were 160mm front and rear for easier universal on course wheel support. However, I'd like to be able to switch out wheels sets that I have.

What is the maximum tire clearance for the Shiv Disc? I've got 28mm on my Tarmac now which is closer to 30mm inflated. Will those fit in the Shiv Disc?

Hey shinacmaha,

Yes you can choose your rotor size. Shiv works with 28s and should clear the measured 30 inflated. The clearance "pinch" is at the fuelcell to wheel top-dead-center and not the frame actually.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
Dimm wrote:
Dan wrote in his review that the L size of the new Shiv is really only large and people taller than 6ā€™3 may find the bike too tight. I am between 6ā€™3 and 6ā€™4. I can fit on the bike with my pad X and Y (475 and 690, but I will likely move a bit longer and lower with time) according to Shivā€™s specs, but I wonder whether the frame may be too small for me and lacking in handling as a result. It has unusual specs: its front center in L is 627mm which is normal for L/56 and is probably on the short side for me, however its wheelbase is 1031mm which is more XL/58 territory. Any ideas on whether this can be a good bike for me? Thanks.



Hi Dimm


I think the LRG will be an ideal fit for you. Your pad position will basically be centered on the fork and your stack is mid range so you have plenty of room to adjust your fit and handling should be as designed.

Remember the new shiv went to 4 sizes from a previous 5, and the design philosophy largely transitioned to get fit through adjustment in the cockpit and not in the frame. This allows for lower frontal area for most riders and improved aero.

Handling of this bike I would describe as stable, and unless you have a really long reach, it should not be a factor.

Thank you. Very helpful.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [shinacmaha] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
shinacmaha wrote:
Couple of questions that I couldn't find on the website.

Do you know if the Shiv Disc can do 140mm brake rotors front and rear? Tim Don in an interview said his were 160mm front and rear for easier universal on course wheel support. However, I'd like to be able to switch out wheels sets that I have.

What is the maximum tire clearance for the Shiv Disc? I've got 28mm on my Tarmac now which is closer to 30mm inflated. Will those fit in the Shiv Disc?


I have both 140 rotors
Last edited by: enricobraglia: Jul 22, 20 14:21
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Any word on whether there will be new colors released any time soon?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Dimm] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey guys, I have a couple of issues with my Shiv Disc Tri and wanted to check if you have the same.

Any of you has a clicking noise while using the Shiv on the smart trainer. I have a clicking noise while Iā€™m on my Tacx Neo 2 and so far Iā€™ve been able to isolate the noise around the rear derailleur, hanger or axle area but not exactly sure what it is.
It only happens sometimes on the hard efforts. It feels like the chain/seat stays flexed a bit (this does not happen with my Venge).
I was thinking of replacing the hanger for a direct drive hanger, but not sure if I should order the wheels manufacturing 374 or 380.

And the other issue is that I found that sweat is able to leak in the frame through the Fuelcell borders even if the container is in place and sweat is pooling at the bottom bracket. This could potentially damage the BB bearings if left with sweat inside. I workaround this by sealing the fuelcell area with plastic for indoor workouts.

Any suggestions are appreciated.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
guillermoD wrote:
And the other issue is that I found that sweat is able to leak in the frame through the Fuelcell borders even if the container is in place and sweat is pooling at the bottom bracket. This could potentially damage the BB bearings if left with sweat inside. I workaround this by sealing the fuelcell area with plastic for indoor workouts.

Any suggestions are appreciated.

Hi guillermoD,

There should be a drain hole in the BB to allow for any moisture to evacuate the frame. Can you see if this is clogged?

I dont think you are at risk of the bearings being contaminated because they are elevated within the shell; it would take a significant amount of liquid to fill but I do agree you do not want pooling.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have a problem for routing my Sram etap shift cable in the base bar. Is it possible to route them? It seem the holes are is small for sram etap cable pins and I had to pass the outside
Last edited by: enricobraglia: Jul 24, 20 5:23
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks GatorRacer! I found the drain hole, in fact it was still silicone sealed from manufacturing I guess, but no clogged.
It should be fine now.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
I have a problem for routing my Sram etap shift cable in the base bar. Is it possible to route them? It seem the holes are is small for sram etap cable pins and I had to pass the outside

Hi enricobraglia,

Yes it is possible, but the size of the SRAM pin definitely makes it tricky. There is a SRAM spec bike so it clearly is possible.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
I have a problem for routing my Sram etap shift cable in the base bar. Is it possible to route them? It seem the holes are is small for sram etap cable pins and I had to pass the outside


Hi enricobraglia,

Yes it is possible, but the size of the SRAM pin definitely makes it tricky. There is a SRAM spec bike so it clearly is possible.

Thank you GatorRacer ;)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
A follow up question for you GatorRacer in similar fashion...

I noticed that the central tower where wires and hydration hose goes in only has wire ports at the front of the tower. With the included extensions you run wire out side of extension and into center piece.
If you were to use aftermarket aero extensions where di2/SRAM cable exits the rear of the extension, how does one maintain the clean cable routing?

I'm hoping that the tower itself is reversible so that you can run the cable out of the back of the extension and then into the holes on the center piece turned around.
I"m afraid that your only options to drill holes in the aero extensions in front of the tower where the cable go in?
Or is there really no clean option for aftermarket extensions that do not have holes pre molded or drilled in the side of the extensions?

Thanks
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [shinacmaha] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
shinacmaha wrote:
A follow up question for you GatorRacer in similar fashion...

I noticed that the central tower where wires and hydration hose goes in only has wire ports at the front of the tower. With the included extensions you run wire out side of extension and into center piece.
If you were to use aftermarket aero extensions where di2/SRAM cable exits the rear of the extension, how does one maintain the clean cable routing?

I'm hoping that the tower itself is reversible so that you can run the cable out of the back of the extension and then into the holes on the center piece turned around.
I"m afraid that your only options to drill holes in the aero extensions in front of the tower where the cable go in?
Or is there really no clean option for aftermarket extensions that do not have holes pre molded or drilled in the side of the extensions?

Thanks

This is correct. If you do not use the provided extensions, then you must route external out the back of the extension...the tower is not reversible. Wiring is designed to enter through the front.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [guillermoD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Iā€™m curious to hear how people are getting along with this bike now that itā€™s been out for a while.

How is the badder working out? Presumably most would only use it for race days (and no one is racing) but is it leaky?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey Everyone!

I would like to ask your opinion. Is it worth to switch from a fully loaded Speci Shiv Pro to the new Shiv disc (expert frame + DA)? Is it worth about 3-4k to upgrade from the older shiv (and selling it) to the new one?

That's a fairly frugal estimate considering that I can get a frameset at 2-2.5k more, a wheelset at 500 more, a dura-ace di2 disc brake groupset about another 500 more than the price I can sell the stuff I have on my current bike. I feel it's not worth the hassle and the disc brake is not that important on a triathlon bike, but sometimes I get squealing from my brakes downhill and the braking power vanishes. That's why I'd like to hear about your opinion! Cheers!

Happy riding!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [shinacmaha] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
shinacmaha wrote:
A follow up question for you GatorRacer in similar fashion...

I noticed that the central tower where wires and hydration hose goes in only has wire ports at the front of the tower. With the included extensions you run wire out side of extension and into center piece.
If you were to use aftermarket aero extensions where di2/SRAM cable exits the rear of the extension, how does one maintain the clean cable routing?

I'm hoping that the tower itself is reversible so that you can run the cable out of the back of the extension and then into the holes on the center piece turned around.
I"m afraid that your only options to drill holes in the aero extensions in front of the tower where the cable go in?
Or is there really no clean option for aftermarket extensions that do not have holes pre molded or drilled in the side of the extensions?

Thanks

With Sync Ergonomics handlebars all the cables pass inside the extensions

[url=https://postimg.cc/bGcRgy4v][/url]
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
today I have installed the rear drinking sacket but I have a lot of problem to drink water, it doesn't arrive well the water at the drinking valve and I have to suck a lot (impossible when I am pedalling hard). What I did wrong installing it? Or is normal?
(sorry for my english I'm italian)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
today I have installed the rear drinking sacket but I have a lot of problem to drink water, it doesn't arrive well the water at the drinking valve and I have to suck a lot (impossible when I am pedalling hard). What I did wrong installing it? Or is normal?
(sorry for my english I'm italian)

This is definitely not normal

Check that the bladder did not fold over within the hydration fuel cell. This can sometimes happen especially at the mounting point cutout. The 2nd place to check is to make sure the straw is not kinked behind the nosecone area
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
today I have installed the rear drinking sacket but I have a lot of problem to drink water, it doesn't arrive well the water at the drinking valve and I have to suck a lot (impossible when I am pedalling hard). What I did wrong installing it? Or is normal?
(sorry for my english I'm italian)


This is definitely not normal

Check that the bladder did not fold over within the hydration fuel cell. This can sometimes happen especially at the mounting point cutout. The 2nd place to check is to make sure the straw is not kinked behind the nosecone area

Thank you GatorRacer, it was the second problem in the nosecone. Now it works very well !! What a bike the Shiv disc
Thank you thank you thank you
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [wintershade] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Are you after anything specific? I came from an entry level bike which was enough no question about that but upgraded to the Shiv Disc Expert version. I never thought I woudl actually feel that much of a difference. The saddle was the only thing that did not work for me but the rest was great from my first ride. I only got to race a 70.3 at the start of the year and I was much faster than the year before (but also trained a whole year more I guess).

For the 70.3 I only added the bottle between my arms and that with gels and electrolyte tables was all i needed for the bike. So the bladder was filled with water. I found it very easy to have 2 straws at the front for hydration and nutrition. You don't have to come out of your position at all. For a full IM my strategy woudl change and I woudl fill the bladder with carbs (maurten packs a lot of carbs in there) and have gels and electrolyte tablets. Then I can either have additional bottles at the back or just take water from aid stations.

Overall I find this bike very comfortable and have no issue with it. My bike fitter was extremely stoked on how easy it was to adjust it and for travel it is great as well.

I am only 62kg and when it gets windy I have no issues with bike handling at all. Something I was actually nervous about and very surprised once I rode the bike even with deeper wheels. I would even say that at least it feels like you are going faster (but have nothing to proof you actually do).

I hope this helps!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [maarten.claes] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The link doesn't work anymore.

I am a bit struggling right now to reconnect it on mine...
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Has any used an aftermarket aero extensions yet? Something like the Drag2Zero Ergo Hi-Rise. Just wondering if they function well with the base bar and the 10-degree pad shim (or after market shims)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [iainbanks1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
iainbanks1 wrote:
Has any used an aftermarket aero extensions yet? Something like the Drag2Zero Ergo Hi-Rise. Just wondering if they function well with the base bar and the 10-degree pad shim (or after market shims)

Hey iainbanks1

They will of course fit and work, but they drastically reduce the fit range due to short straight section on the tubing. If your reach is within that narrow range they can work just fine.

The Ride Sync extensions offer a similar rise without as much compromise to the reach adjustment if you are not 100% dialed with your fit.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:

PS We will not redesign for 2020 ;)


Hello GatorRacer
May I just suggest for 2021, new basebar wings. We are 6 in my squad to own a Shiv Disc and 5 of us are touching the basebar with the knees when standing on the pedals (and I am not talking about a pure sprint, just a common "relaunch" or steep section where you need to go off the saddle).
I don't know if others here have also to complain about it but for us, it is really a shame as this bike (especially when you train in a hilly area) is otherwise close to perfect.
I tried to attach a picture with quick draw of what I am meaning (a design directly more forward after the tilting bolt to offer clearance for the knees).

Thanks for the reply.
Last edited by: NTQ237: Nov 6, 20 14:00
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [NTQ237] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
NTQ237 wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:

PS We will not redesign for 2020 ;)


Hello GatorRacer
May I just suggest for 2021, new basebar wings. We are 6 in my squad to own a Shiv Disc and 5 of us are touching the basebar with the knees when standing on the pedals (and I am not talking about a pure sprint, just a common "relaunch" or steep section where you need to go off the saddle).
I don't know if others here have also to complain about it but for us, it is really a shame as this bike (especially when you train in a hilly area) is otherwise close to perfect.
I tried to attach a picture with quick draw of what I am meaning (a design directly more forward after the tilting bolt to offer clearance for the knees).

Thanks for the reply.

Thanks for your feedback. I understand that this can be an issue for some people...I know this is not an option for most, but would you fit on the next size up (longer)?

While we dont wish for knee clearance to be a problem, we expect nearly all riding to be while seated for aero purposes.

I am sorry you are dealing with this and I will make sure it is noted to our product team
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for the reply, GatorRacer. Appreciate a lot.
Actually the Size Finder was suggesting me a S and I went for the Medium (1m80 with 578mm saddle height) with in mind the trouble of my friends with their knee clearance (one measuring 1m75 having to change his S directly).
Indeed, on the L, I might would be better even I would have the mandatory use of the 25mm forward seatpost (I already use) and no more spacer under the armpadplate. But if I have with my 86cm inseam /1m80 height to go on L size, I wonder how can big guys fit on this jewel (I repeat that apart of that, I love it, coming from Marquise Disc, Marquise, P5, TSC,.. all on M or 54).

No definetely the best solution is just building new wings for the base bar to buy as an upgrade ;-)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [NTQ237] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It appears, unless Iā€™m mistaken, that the Shiv has just had a price jump in the UK at least. Is this the same everywhere? I think the standard Shiv used to be Ā£10.5K with the remaining stock of the Ltd version Ā£11K, but now the 2021 Shiv is Ā£11.5K.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DhobiWanKenobi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SL7 models have had a price increase too I noticed this morning ... +800 euros (BE)..
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [NTQ237] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
NTQ237 wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:

PS We will not redesign for 2020 ;)


Hello GatorRacer
May I just suggest for 2021, new basebar wings. We are 6 in my squad to own a Shiv Disc and 5 of us are touching the basebar with the knees when standing on the pedals (and I am not talking about a pure sprint, just a common "relaunch" or steep section where you need to go off the saddle).
I don't know if others here have also to complain about it but for us, it is really a shame as this bike (especially when you train in a hilly area) is otherwise close to perfect.
I tried to attach a picture with quick draw of what I am meaning (a design directly more forward after the tilting bolt to offer clearance for the knees).

Thanks for the reply.


I have to agree with this. I want to buy this bike - I really do. I love something that looks a little different to the norm and has had the hard yards spent on it. However, I test rode one and currently rejected it based purely on the basebar design (and I have owned every tri/tt Specialized made).

1) The bike itself is great but that basebar is too deep rearwards for my liking. I need a bike that is better suited to occasional out of the saddle activity (for what this bike now costs). I know aero is king but this is the only bike I've had this problem with and I don't want compromises like this at this price point.

2) When you look at other bikes (like the new Scott plasma 6 or cervelo's P5d), I have to wonder what aero penalty the Shiv's folding wings have. It's extremely fat and I do wonder if the form was compromised too much as the expense of obtaining the travelling ability. Not all of want or need the folding wings so I'd like to see a one piece aftermarket alternative that is more aero. At this price point, we have to see something close to perfection.
Last edited by: UK Gearmuncher: Nov 14, 20 1:05
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You are mentioning "There is a custom extension based mount that allows a bottle cage between the arms or a computer mount."- Where would you get this mount from?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tomaz021 wrote:
You are mentioning "There is a custom extension based mount that allows a bottle cage between the arms or a computer mount."- Where would you get this mount from?

Hey Tomaz021,

Itā€™s included with the SWorks version only. You can see if your local dealer can order one
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm searching this seatpost for my Shiv, it has zero offset, I can't find it. Could you link me a webshop where to buy it? TXS

https://www.triathlete.com/gear/bike/kona-pro-bike-lucy-charles-barclays-specialized-shiv/
Last edited by: enricobraglia: Dec 8, 20 14:24
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It has a zero offset but ... it is weirdly named for this bike : the 25mm forward. It put a mess with many european retailers asking for a 0 offset (like the one of LC on your link) receiving a 25mm rearward one. And eventually the one you are looking is named 25mm forward or something like that. I gonna check tomorrow.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [NTQ237] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
NTQ237 wrote:
It has a zero offset but ... it is weirdly named for this bike : the 25mm forward. It put a mess with many european retailers asking for a 0 offset (like the one of LC on your link) receiving a 25mm rearward one. And eventually the one you are looking is named 25mm forward or something like that. I gonna check tomorrow.


It's strange, in Specialized website there is only one seatpost and they say 0/25Ā° offset ...

https://www.specialized.com/it/it/reggisella-shiv-disc-carbon/p/174197?color=278162-174197&searchText=28119-3600

Thank you ;)
Last edited by: enricobraglia: Dec 8, 20 14:47
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [NTQ237] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
NTQ237 wrote:
It has a zero offset but ... it is weirdly named for this bike : the 25mm forward. It put a mess with many european retailers asking for a 0 offset (like the one of LC on your link) receiving a 25mm rearward one. And eventually the one you are looking is named 25mm forward or something like that. I gonna check tomorrow.

Hi NTQ237 and enricobraglia

I see your concerns of confusion. The SHIV Disc has 2 offsets available. Spec is 0mm offset, which LOOKS like a traditional -20mm offset or so, because the Seat Post head is hung off the back of the post body.

Aftermarket, the +25mm seat post is available for those who need it for fit, or in some cases where the saddle height is so low, the standard post interferes with the hydration system.

The +25mm post, LOOKS like a traditional 0mm offset post (directly on top of the tube), but it is not. The reason for this, is that the bike's seat tube is moved forward relative to the axis of the BB, to allow additional room for the hydration system.

Unfortunately the picture on that Italian website is incorrect
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The ref you are looking for is 28119-3605 ;-)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
NTQ237 wrote:
It has a zero offset but ... it is weirdly named for this bike : the 25mm forward. It put a mess with many european retailers asking for a 0 offset (like the one of LC on your link) receiving a 25mm rearward one. And eventually the one you are looking is named 25mm forward or something like that. I gonna check tomorrow.


Hi NTQ237 and enricobraglia

I see your concerns of confusion. The SHIV Disc has 2 offsets available. Spec is 0mm offset, which LOOKS like a traditional -20mm offset or so, because the Seat Post head is hung off the back of the post body.

Aftermarket, the +25mm seat post is available for those who need it for fit, or in some cases where the saddle height is so low, the standard post interferes with the hydration system.

The +25mm post, LOOKS like a traditional 0mm offset post (directly on top of the tube), but it is not. The reason for this, is that the bike's seat tube is moved forward relative to the axis of the BB, to allow additional room for the hydration system.

Unfortunately the picture on that Italian website is incorrect

now it's all clear thank you GatorRacer ;)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [NTQ237] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
NTQ237 wrote:
The ref you are looking for is 28119-3605 ;-)

thank you very much ;)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
NTQ237 wrote:
The ref you are looking for is 28119-3605 ;-)


thank you very much ;)

Piacere ;-)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [NTQ237] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi,

I am interested in a shiv disc and need your help !

Here I went through the forum and it turns out that I have to make a choice between the size XS and S.
Normally you advise to take the size S and after several discussions with owners and despite a postural study which recommends the size S screw compared to the XS, looking at the manual and talking to someone who owns a SHIV in size S, I'm not sure the saddle extension is adequate with my measurements and the rear foil.
I measure 1.68cm with 82cm inseam and my saddle exit is 72cm.

When I check at the specific geometry:
- The seat post length is 350mm in both XS and S size
- The seat tube length is 490mm in XS size and 522mm in S size.

In the manual, it was mentioned that the reservoir may limit the seatpost insertion and the minimum insertion of seat post is 75mm and the maximum is 200mm.

So if I calculate the saddle extension on the two frame sizes, we get to this :
- the maximum saddle extension for the XS is : 490 + 275 (seat post length - minimum insertion) = 765mm
- the minimum saddle extension for the S is : 522 + 150 (seat post length - maximum insertion) = 672mm


But the problem is that these measurements do not take into account the height of my saddle (Prologo T-Gale) from the rails = 50mm.

So if I add my saddle height at the previous dimensions, I get this :
- the maximum saddle extension for the XS is : 765 + 50 = 815mm
- the minimum saddle extension for the S is : 672 + 50 = 722mm (so bigger for my own saddle height)


Which would mean that Specialized (and my postural study) advise me an S frame where I could not put my correct saddle height unless I cut the rear foil ? Are you agree with my calcul ?

So If I am not wrong, I therefore have no choice to take a size XS (or go to S size and change my saddle).
Last edited by: Ted0ne: Dec 16, 20 8:35
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Ted0ne] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ted0ne wrote:
Hi,

I am interested in a shiv disc and need your help !

Here I went through the forum and it turns out that I have to make a choice between the size XS and S.
Normally you advise to take the size S and after several discussions with owners and despite a postural study which recommends the size S screw compared to the XS, looking at the manual and talking to someone who owns a SHIV in size S, I'm not sure the saddle extension is adequate with my measurements and the rear foil.
I measure 1.68cm with 82cm inseam and my saddle exit is 72cm.

When I check at the specific geometry:
- The seat post length is 350mm in both XS and S size
- The seat tube length is 490mm in XS size and 522mm in S size.

In the manual, it was mentioned that the reservoir may limit the seatpost insertion and the minimum insertion of seat post is 75mm and the maximum is 200mm.

So if I calculate the saddle extension on the two frame sizes, we get to this :
- the maximum saddle extension for the XS is : 490 + 275 (seat post length - minimum insertion) = 765mm
- the minimum saddle extension for the S is : 522 + 150 (seat post length - maximum insertion) = 672mm


But the problem is that these measurements do not take into account the height of my saddle (Prologo T-Gale) from the rails = 50mm.

So if I add my saddle height at the previous dimensions, I get this :
- the maximum saddle extension for the XS is : 765 + 50 = 815mm
- the minimum saddle extension for the S is : 672 + 50 = 722mm (so bigger for my own saddle height)


Which would mean that Specialized (and my postural study) advise me an S frame where I could not put my correct saddle height unless I cut the rear foil ? Are you agree with my calcul ?

So If I am not wrong, I therefore have no choice to take a size XS (or go to S size and change my saddle).

Hey Ted0ne

Nice thorough review!

You are correct that the min saddle height for the SM is 723mm (based on a POWER Saddle). If you use the +25mm offset post (available at your dealer) you gain an additional ~43mm of seat post depth, allowing you to go down to a minimum of 683mm.

You would need to make sure the +25 post is OK with your saddle setback & reach, but if so, then I recommend you go with a SM and cut your Seat Post ~10mm and then you will have no issues.

If you do not want to cut your post, or you do not want to go with a Forward offset Seat Post, then your options are to find a saddle with a rail height that is a bit lower, adjust your crank arm length to sit higher, or go with an XS...Since we are only talking a few MMs here i think its easy to find a way to make SM work

I
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
@GatorRacer Many thanks for your answer !

So it will be better to go to the S size even if I will be in the "small settings" of this size rather than the XS which could perhaps favor a more aerodynamic position with my size ?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Ted0ne] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ted0ne wrote:
@GatorRacer Many thanks for your answer !

So it will be better to go to the S size even if I will be in the "small settings" of this size rather than the XS which could perhaps favor a more aerodynamic position with my size ?

Well thats a different story...I assumed your fit coordinates you asked for would be the same for both bikes.

Usually saddle height is "fixed". If you can get lower on the XS for some reason then it may be more aero but you havent provided and cockpit fit info and this is unlikely.

The stack on the XS and SM is the same and this is what would impact aerodynamics...the reach is different between the SM and XS, but this doesnt have much effect unless your body cant get to the coordinates you need (i.e. too short could cause you to arch your back and this increase your frontal area)

The decision between XS and SM on the SHIV DIsc is almost always the saddle height since the stack is the same between them and the reach adjustment on this bike is huge
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
@GatorRacer Thanks you again for your detailed explanation !
I will go for the S size ;)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [BayDad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
1.5L is a good amount. (That is, until you run out.)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Salhalo93] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi everyone,

Will you have an idea of the next colors of the frameset and when they will be available ?

Many thanks !
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Ted0ne] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ted0ne wrote:
Hi everyone,

Will you have an idea of the next colors of the frameset and when they will be available ?

Many thanks !

I think the new framesets are coming in white and black.
The black one can be found on their website but I am sure i have seen the white one also already.

The black one is for sure already available but i guess most of the bikes are sold out currently.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Ted0ne wrote:
Hi everyone,

Will you have an idea of the next colors of the frameset and when they will be available ?

Many thanks !


I think the new framesets are coming in white and black.
The black one can be found on their website but I am sure i have seen the white one also already.

The black one is for sure already available but i guess most of the bikes are sold out currently.

But the white (Abalone color) is only in complete build. Only the Black Mat and the Green Spectaflair color is available for the frameset (shiv disc module). Perhaps the white color will be available on the shiv module at the end of the year ?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Has anyone managed to swap the rear disc to a 140 rotor? What, if any, parts would I need? Iā€™d like to be able to share rear wheels between my Venge (which has a 140 rear rotor) and my Shiv.

Also, I second the knee clearance issue. First time I stood out of the saddle for a steep climb I smashed my knees so hard I had to pull of the road and take a breather..... granted I was kind of between sizes and sizes down.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi Keith,

Not sure if you remember, but you were a huge help to me last year with sizing me up on a shiv tri- you even mocked out my fit coordinates on a diagram, for which I was hugely grateful! Thank you.
I managed to get an incredible deal on a brand new Small with a +25mm seatpost, and 165mm cranks for no extra cost -I have about 4cm of clearance of the rear foil.

I finally took delivery of my S-works Shiv Tri yesterday- red with Sram red etap AXS, and took it out for it's first 4 hour ride today.

What a machine!!!

I am coming across from another 'superbike' and the difference between them is huge.

The shiv is just so so stable in all situations. It doesn't move about at all regardless of the wind, whether there are lorries passing me etc. I wasnā€™t fighting the bike at all, which I sometimes do as I weigh 63kg.
Even at high speed it felt super stable.
It also handles extremely well, the disc brakes on a TT bike is a game changer for me in the UK with our roads and road surfaces. I had so much more confidence on the bike than I did on my previous bike. It handles at least as well as my Venge.
Once it's up to speed it just continues, feels like I'm being pushed along without having to put out much power at all, and it definitely climbs better than I expected it would.
With regards to the rear hydration, it fits about 2 bottles in there, absolutely no trouble at all using it or getting the fluid out, didnā€™t have to suck hard at all, the bite valve works well.

A few things I wanted to ask you-
1. Are there any videos available of inserting the straw through the frame etc and how to do it properly? I saw you mentioned that it takes you 5mins, one handed! But it took me like half an hour!

2. Have you seen any rear mounts that allow a garmin varia to be used with the shiv? I have not enough seatpost there to mount anything. A varia is really essential in the UK.

3. Is there a way to have a BTA bottle cage and a garmin mount? Am I missing something with the installation? I canā€™t seem to find a close up of the BTA cage and garmin on together.

4. Am I right in thinking I can flip the extensions round? So that I have the high rise using the current extensions that came with the bike?

Thanks for your hard work and design!! I love the bike.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [shammad10] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
hi shammad10, just sharing some of my experiences:

1) Routing the water tube is a pain if it's too dry as it will get stuck sometimes. I normally just wet the tube before routing and it moves alot easier and 5 mins is really do-able. would like to hear more tips from others nonetheless!

2) i also struggled with finding a varia mount for my Fizik Tritone saddle, but i guess the solution depends on what saddle you're using. if using Spesh saddle with SWAT storage, can use something like this:
https://www.amazon.com/Trigo-Cycling-Camera-Specialized-Saddle/dp/B07VPFDFLQ


3) BTA with gopro is not possible with the Shiv's stock parts, but many solutions from Xlab and the likes


4) flipping extensions is possible but i believe you won't have the cable routing holes at the longer end, so will have your di2 cables sticking out

Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [melvody] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for your tips and tricks!

I'll keep practicing on the straw then!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [melvody] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
On the straw.... it takes me maybe 1 minute. I never cut the straw down though as i put it around by BTA bottle when i am racing which fits perfectly and snug. So i actually put the straw through the top down and then connect it to the bladder. I manage to just get it far enough up to get to the bladder. This is on a size S bike so maybe on larger sizes the straw would not be long enough for that approach.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cool, I have a small also.
So you're putting the straw in from the front with the wire attachment? then feeding through and attaching the bladder at the end out of the top of the reservoir?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [shammad10] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
shammad10 wrote:

A few things I wanted to ask you-

1. Are there any videos available of inserting the straw through the frame etc and how to do it properly? I saw you mentioned that it takes you 5mins, one handed! But it took me like half an hour!

2. Have you seen any rear mounts that allow a garmin varia to be used with the shiv? I have not enough seatpost there to mount anything. A varia is really essential in the UK.

3. Is there a way to have a BTA bottle cage and a garmin mount? Am I missing something with the installation? I canā€™t seem to find a close up of the BTA cage and garmin on together.

4. Am I right in thinking I can flip the extensions round? So that I have the high rise using the current extensions that came with the bike?

Thanks for your hard work and design!! I love the bike.

Hey shammad10


Happy to hear you are enjoying your SHIV!

Here are some responses to your questions:
  1. There was a video for this, but I cant seem to find it! But here are some tips:

    • Always try to insert the hydration straw from front to rear. The bend is easier to make in this direction.
    • If the straw is completely out, with the nosecone off, route the straw through the Downtube and to the rear first. It is beneficial to route to the cockpit last. This will give extra slack to get through the frame and help with connection.
    • Assuming you have not cut your straw too closely, you can push enough straw through the entire bike to become exposed at the top of the fuel cell where you can make your connection. Be careful to not pull so much through to the rear that you pull into the frame in the front. This will allow you to use the exposed tubing in the front area to pull the whole bladder into the frame. (Easy way to think of this: ALWAYS have some straw at the front. Except in a deep cleaning situation where you remove the entire system, the straw should always remain in place; If the straw needs to come out, thats why we have the routing/cleaning tool)
    • After the bladder is pulled into place and you are sure there are no folds, then route the front portion of the straw, up through the tower
    • Fill your bladder while in the bike for maximum capacity
  2. Its hard to generically recommend a saddle mount, because it depends on your post height and frame size, but for really tight situations, we have modified the profile design holders to work. Basically a more vertical mount works, or a saddle with vertical rails at the back such as an ISM Adamo

    • Making an adapter that fits the threaded accessory mounts on the bottom of Specialized saddles works
    • Some have epoxy or silicone adhesive a mount to the trailing edge of their reservoir
  3. The BTA Mount is design to hold a Garmin OR a Bottle

    • If you want bottle and Garmin, it is assumed you would set the BTA in bottle configuration, and then run a TT style mount off of the extension, or some people use the bottle cages with an integrated mount
  4. Yes you can flip the extensions around but there are 2 things to note about this:

    • Your reach range will be significantly reduced in this configuration, so be sure to check your fit before doing this. If you want high hand position and cant get the reach with the included extensions, there are aftermarket brands that have a longer straight section such as RideSync
    • You Will not have fully internal cable routing in this configuration due to the exit of the Di2 wire.

Hope this helps!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [shammad10] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I dont even use the wire attachemtn i literally put it through the hole and thats it. Never had any issues doign it that way....
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
shammad10 wrote:


A few things I wanted to ask you-

1. Are there any videos available of inserting the straw through the frame etc and how to do it properly? I saw you mentioned that it takes you 5mins, one handed! But it took me like half an hour!

2. Have you seen any rear mounts that allow a garmin varia to be used with the shiv? I have not enough seatpost there to mount anything. A varia is really essential in the UK.

3. Is there a way to have a BTA bottle cage and a garmin mount? Am I missing something with the installation? I canā€™t seem to find a close up of the BTA cage and garmin on together.

4. Am I right in thinking I can flip the extensions round? So that I have the high rise using the current extensions that came with the bike?

Thanks for your hard work and design!! I love the bike.


Hey shammad10


Happy to hear you are enjoying your SHIV!

Here are some responses to your questions:
  1. There was a video for this, but I cant seem to find it! But here are some tips:

    • Always try to insert the hydration straw from front to rear. The bend is easier to make in this direction.
    • If the straw is completely out, with the nosecone off, route the straw through the Downtube and to the rear first. It is beneficial to route to the cockpit last. This will give extra slack to get through the frame and help with connection.
    • Assuming you have not cut your straw too closely, you can push enough straw through the entire bike to become exposed at the top of the fuel cell where you can make your connection. Be careful to not pull so much through to the rear that you pull into the frame in the front. This will allow you to use the exposed tubing in the front area to pull the whole bladder into the frame. (Easy way to think of this: ALWAYS have some straw at the front. Except in a deep cleaning situation where you remove the entire system, the straw should always remain in place; If the straw needs to come out, thats why we have the routing/cleaning tool)
    • After the bladder is pulled into place and you are sure there are no folds, then route the front portion of the straw, up through the tower
    • Fill your bladder while in the bike for maximum capacity
  2. Its hard to generically recommend a saddle mount, because it depends on your post height and frame size, but for really tight situations, we have modified the profile design holders to work. Basically a more vertical mount works, or a saddle with vertical rails at the back such as an ISM Adamo

    • Making an adapter that fits the threaded accessory mounts on the bottom of Specialized saddles works
    • Some have epoxy or silicone adhesive a mount to the trailing edge of their reservoir
  3. The BTA Mount is design to hold a Garmin OR a Bottle

    • If you want bottle and Garmin, it is assumed you would set the BTA in bottle configuration, and then run a TT style mount off of the extension, or some people use the bottle cages with an integrated mount
  4. Yes you can flip the extensions around but there are 2 things to note about this:

    • Your reach range will be significantly reduced in this configuration, so be sure to check your fit before doing this. If you want high hand position and cant get the reach with the included extensions, there are aftermarket brands that have a longer straight section such as RideSync
    • You Will not have fully internal cable routing in this configuration due to the exit of the Di2 wire.

Hope this helps!

I think this is the video | https://player.vimeo.com/video/350210418
@gatorracer
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [badiejb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I ride my Shiv without the rear fin. Today I rode a long bike train with a lot of wind. My bike was difficult to handle for the hard wind. Maybe the fin help to stabilize the bike in the wind?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi everyone. I have a hydration problem when not using the blather. And I donā€™t have room for a bottle between my arms and also I canā€™t fit a bottle behind the seat because of the wing.

How have you guys solved this problem?


Chris
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Likeglad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Likeglad wrote:
Hi everyone. I have a hydration problem when not using the blather. And I donā€™t have room for a bottle between my arms and also I canā€™t fit a bottle behind the seat because of the wing.

How have you guys solved this problem?


Chris

It is imperative that you find a way to use a bottle between the arms. This is the best place for hydration and race flexibility and having the user utilize this position was part of the design concept.

What is the reason you cannot have a bottle between the arms?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
I ride my Shiv without the rear fin. Today I rode a long bike train with a lot of wind. My bike was difficult to handle for the hard wind. Maybe the fin help to stabilize the bike in the wind?

By not using the fin, you have throw the centre of pressure forwards and that certainly wonā€™t help the stability. I know from many years experience that use of a rear disc certainly stabilises the bike even though youā€™ve reduced the surface area.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have the pads as close as possible so that Iā€™m narrow. My forearms therefore are together. In race itā€™s now problem butt I donā€™t use the blather at training
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Likeglad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Likeglad wrote:
I have the pads as close as possible so that Iā€™m narrow. My forearms therefore are together. In race itā€™s now problem butt I donā€™t use the blather at training

Unless you do not need the water, the fastest solution would be to widen your cups a notch or 2...

Alternatively, you can make BTA risers that allow the BTA to cradle above your touching forearms
Quote Reply
Post deleted by enricobraglia [ In reply to ]
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:

[url=https://postimg.cc/f3ckSq1v][/url]
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
@GatorRacer, I had to cut the wing down due to a different saddle I used and the need to drop the seat stay by 2cm. I have the 1.15L bladder in there but at my last race i realised it is not the ideal size anymore. What is the next size down and where would I be able to order one from in Australia?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tomaz021 wrote:
@GatorRacer, I had to cut the wing down due to a different saddle I used and the need to drop the seat stay by 2cm. I have the 1.15L bladder in there but at my last race i realised it is not the ideal size anymore. What is the next size down and where would I be able to order one from in Australia?

The bladders are not interchangeable and neither are the fuelcells. If you cut yours down, you have to deal with the longer bladder scrunched up which results in reduced capacity (and poor fit sometimes)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks for the quick response. However, how would you ever achieve the a fit range if there is only one size fuelcell fits one size bike? I have a size S bike and my seat stay is not as low when compared to other riders but the fuelcell just fitted when i got the bike. So now saddle wasn't working for me unfortunately despite a 6 month commitment. What would have been the right approach to achieve the fit I required?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tomaz021 wrote:
thanks for the quick response. However, how would you ever achieve the a fit range if there is only one size fuelcell fits one size bike? I have a size S bike and my seat stay is not as low when compared to other riders but the fuelcell just fitted when i got the bike. So now saddle wasn't working for me unfortunately despite a 6 month commitment. What would have been the right approach to achieve the fit I required?

Generally speaking you should pick your bike size based on saddle height...itā€™s adjustable enough that this is usually acceptable.

XS and SM have the same stack height so as long as reach is OK thereā€™s no issue usually
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What is everyone using for a rear light? Assuming the light is going on the chain stays?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DashLash] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DashLash wrote:
What is everyone using for a rear light? Assuming the light is going on the chain stays?

The stays are possible but the angle is shallow and you may have heel clearance issues. I would suggest off the back of the saddle and if you are using a rear cage then off of that.

If your saddle height is such that there is no room between then the stays may be the only option
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I echo previous concerns about needing some kind of plug when the hydration Fuel cell is not in place. Had my first ride in the weekend, I had taped over the hole between the seat stays as I naively thought this would keep water out. It was a pretty wet and water still managed to fill up I guess the internal cavity right up to the top, turning the bike upside down a lot of water came out!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cookies] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Cookies wrote:
I echo previous concerns about needing some kind of plug when the hydration Fuel cell is not in place. Had my first ride in the weekend, I had taped over the hole between the seat stays as I naively thought this would keep water out. It was a pretty wet and water still managed to fill up I guess the internal cavity right up to the top, turning the bike upside down a lot of water came out!

Check to be sure the drainhole under the BB is clean and free. Sometimes excess grease from the crank can clog this region, or debris from the downtube region can as well...

Unless you are in a pretty heavy rain, it should drain out the BB if clear.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Cookies] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
what do people do with bladder (removal, cleaning, attaching/detaching) post their rides?

I used it on a ride, only drank half the liquid and really struggled to get the rest out. ended up spending a good 15 min trying to suck it out through the straw....

there has to be a better way
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andyukr] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I just flipp it on the backwheel. It all pours out. Use the hose to fill it up. Two tree times is ok
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andyukr] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Andyukr wrote:
what do people do with bladder (removal, cleaning, attaching/detaching) post their rides?

I used it on a ride, only drank half the liquid and really struggled to get the rest out. ended up spending a good 15 min trying to suck it out through the straw....

there has to be a better way

Is there a reason you are not just removing the bladder and dumping it out? Or are you having trouble getting the bladder out of the reservoir?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Just to be clear, the frameset on the Shiv Expert is the same as on the Shiv S-Works, other than the "Specialized" vs "S-Works" logo on the downtube and the paint, right?

Amateur recreational hobbyist cyclist
https://www.strava.com/athletes/337152
https://vimeo.com/user11846099
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [refthimos] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
refthimos wrote:
Just to be clear, the frameset on the Shiv Expert is the same as on the Shiv S-Works, other than the "Specialized" vs "S-Works" logo on the downtube and the paint, right?

Frame set geometry is the same, but the carbon layup is much different (lighter and I believe more stiff). If you are buying the complete bike, the components are different as well.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The bladder is connected at the bottom so to disconnect it, I would need to pull it out until I can see the connection. But I cannot pull it as the mouth piece on the other side is blocking it.
In Reply To:
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Andyukr] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Andyukr wrote:
The bladder is connected at the bottom so to disconnect it, I would need to pull it out until I can see the connection. But I cannot pull it as the mouth piece on the other side is blocking it.
In Reply To:

  1. Pull off the bite valve
  2. Plug hydration straw with the included plug
  3. Pull off the nose cone front
  4. From the nose cone area, pull the upper section of the hose through the spacer stack

    • Unless your straw was cut extremely short, you should now have a long section of free tubing to work with
  5. Pull the bladder out of the fuel cell

    • If its stubborn, pushing from the front at the same time helps
  6. Once the bladder is high enough, you can disconnect the tube from the bottom for complete removal

    • Leave the straw in the frame as much as possible as this makes reinstallation easier

Last edited by: GatorRacer: Jun 29, 21 11:57
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [DashLash] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i don't think you are right ... they are both the same carbon layer fact 11 which is used on Sworks bikes. The only difference between the bikes are components and and the writing on the frame.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yes, the reason I ask is that the framesets are described identically on the Specialized website...



and I see this blurb on a retailer's website...

If you just want to get out and ride the Expert looks like an excellent option. The frameset uses the same FACT 11r carbon as the S-Works models, and shares their design, geometry and features. The differences are in the finishing kit, but we're still talking Ultegra Di2, so that's no real hardship. Wheels are Roval C38 carbon disc, a little shallower and less aero than their CLX cousins. The Sitero Expert Gel saddle has Ti rather than carbon rails, but the all-important Shiv Aerobar is still present and correct, providing excellent adjustability alongside the aero performance.

With that said, I haven't seen anything from Specialized clearly stating that the framesets are the same, and maybe there is a difference in layup or something else that is not captured in the "Frame" description above.

Amateur recreational hobbyist cyclist
https://www.strava.com/athletes/337152
https://vimeo.com/user11846099
Last edited by: refthimos: Jun 29, 21 15:53
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [refthimos] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I researched it before I bought the Expert version and in an interview at the zwift tri academy in Kona Tim Don actually said it is the exact same frame. That together with what is on the Specialized website should be enough to trust that it is the exact same frame (at least to me).
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thx, yes I agree that if you take the Specialized website at face value, it would seem they are indeed the same, other than the logo and paint. And let's not kid ourselves, to the median tri consumer, that holographic S-Works logo and paint options is worth at least $1K.

Amateur recreational hobbyist cyclist
https://www.strava.com/athletes/337152
https://vimeo.com/user11846099
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [refthimos] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
refthimos wrote:
Thx, yes I agree that if you take the Specialized website at face value, it would seem they are indeed the same, other than the logo and paint. And let's not kid ourselves, to the median tri consumer, that holographic S-Works logo and paint options is worth at least $1K.

The frame and fork itself are the same. The SWorks does use a lighter weight paint however.

The difference in levels is all in the group, wheels, and some accessories.

If you are piecing together your own SHIV, feel free to choose either variant based on the color you like. Although getting all of the small bits would be a major challenge so consider it in full!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Does anyone know Specialized's annual refresh timing on the Shiv? Wondering if the current configuration will get updates for 2022 at some point this year?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey there,
I was wondering if there is a way to adjust a disc wheel within the frame.
I am running the 321 Disc with 26-622 S-Works Turbo tires and it seems that the tire touches the fin/fuelcell when i am going hard on the bikes.
The paint came already a bit off. Is there a way to adjust this or do i simply have to run smaller tires on the back wheel?

THANKS A LOT!!!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'd love an answer too. I'm thinking about cutting the hydration compartment and regluing the whole thing, whatever it takes so I can run my 28's
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hey there,
I was wondering if there is a way to adjust a disc wheel within the frame.
I am running the 321 Disc with 26-622 S-Works Turbo tires and it seems that the tire touches the fin/fuelcell when i am going hard on the bikes.
The paint came already a bit off. Is there a way to adjust this or do i simply have to run smaller tires on the back wheel?

THANKS A LOT!!!

I have a size L and my girlfriend a small I believe. We have that 321 Disc wheel with the Sworks Turbo Tubless 26mm and have run it on both our bikes without any contact points and plenty of clearance room between the tire and the sail. Are you sure that tire is seated properly? I cant think of anything else that would cause it to rub of the top of my head....
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [teixido] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chris_Mint wrote:
Hey there,
I was wondering if there is a way to adjust a disc wheel within the frame.
I am running the 321 Disc with 26-622 S-Works Turbo tires and it seems that the tire touches the fin/fuelcell when i am going hard on the bikes.
The paint came already a bit off. Is there a way to adjust this or do i simply have to run smaller tires on the back wheel?

THANKS A LOT!!!

That combination should clear. Since its only rubbing on "hard" efforts then it seems like there is clearance, and contact only during flex. This could be possible depending on a lot of factors such as rider weight, bike weight, tire pressure, etc...There is no way to adjust the wheel position since it is thru-axle, but the reservoir position may possibly be able to be tweaked a bit. Are you able to loosen the reservoir, hold it further from the wheel, and then tighten it in place?


teixido wrote:
I'd love an answer too. I'm thinking about cutting the hydration compartment and regluing the whole thing, whatever it takes so I can run my 28's

This would be an extreme measure! 28s are hit or miss depending on the rim and tire. The 321 is going to be better with 26s but i understand the desire for 28s. Before cutting the reservoir, I would slot the attachment hole and slide it up. With an open underside you will collect debris and run the risk of cutting a tire
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sorry if this has been asked before but iā€™ve not had much luck with the searchā€¦

Where do people store their spares? Tube & a gas canister?

Iā€™ve read online some people put them in front of the fuel cell but the di2 module is in the way for that? Itā€™s an XS frame in case that makes a difference. At the moment i see two options, use the fuel cell for that or a rear bottle cage?

Any links or photos would be much appreciated
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [danderton] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
danderton wrote:
Sorry if this has been asked before but iā€™ve not had much luck with the searchā€¦

Where do people store their spares? Tube & a gas canister?

Iā€™ve read online some people put them in front of the fuel cell but the di2 module is in the way for that? Itā€™s an XS frame in case that makes a difference. At the moment i see two options, use the fuel cell for that or a rear bottle cage?

Any links or photos would be much appreciated

Below the fuel cell toward the BB. An old sunglasses sock works well
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
does anyone have more info to share on ride experience?
  1. that seat tube/post looks straight off the tarmac, combined with the low stays i'd expect a compliant ride - is that the case (at least releative to other TT/tri bikes)?
  2. on the other hand, those forks look rigid as hell - is the front end rough?
  3. how practical is the hydration - is is easy to suck fluid through all the way from the back? is it practical to refill on the go?
  4. what is that base bar like to ride with? it looks incredibly chunky leading to awkward climbing positions for knees and hands.

Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pk1 wrote:
does anyone have more info to share on ride experience?
  1. that seat tube/post looks straight off the tarmac, combined with the low stays i'd expect a compliant ride - is that the case (at least releative to other TT/tri bikes)?
  2. on the other hand, those forks look rigid as hell - is the front end rough?
  3. how practical is the hydration - is is easy to suck fluid through all the way from the back? is it practical to refill on the go?
  4. what is that base bar like to ride with? it looks incredibly chunky leading to awkward climbing positions for knees and hands.

My view is surely biased but I will offer it anyway:
  1. The rear end is quite compliant. I havent heard any feedback about a harsh ride over the years, and generally the ride quality is better than traditional tri-bikes
  2. The fork is extremely rigid but the cockpit design minimizes any roughness in the front end. If you are slammed then it may get a tad harsher but generally the stiffness in the front leads to a more stable ride and precise steering
  3. This is a very person dependent question, but a lot of time was spent to ensure sufficient flow and to incorporate a backflow resistant bite valve. Refilling on the go is not practical, but some have come up with unique solutions.
  4. The basebar is comfortable from the "pistol" position. if you like to hold the bar like the tops of a drop bar, it wouldnt be that comfortable. I personally dont use this postion on this bike, and i prefer to grip the arm cups when sitting up. This is very comfortable (its padded) and unless are super narrow, is also very stable. If racing and climbing i would just continue to use the grips

Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Is it true that Shiv disc tri will not be produced in 2022? My seller say that it will not be replaced but not produced due lack of materials
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That seems unlikely, but interested in the answer as well. Been keeping an eye on inventory here in the U.S., as you can't find the Shiv disc anywhere.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
Is it true that Shiv disc tri will not be produced in 2022? My seller say that it will not be replaced but not produced due lack of materials

yes, that is what i have heard too. or rather that is has not been produced this year so there won't be new stock for next year. i believe it will return.
they're focussing on the big growth areas - gravel, road, mtb. even more so than usual, tri is not currently where the money is at
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pk1 wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
Is it true that Shiv disc tri will not be produced in 2022? My seller say that it will not be replaced but not produced due lack of materials

yes, that is what i have heard too. or rather that is has not been produced this year so there won't be new stock for next year. i believe it will return.
they're focussing on the big growth areas - gravel, road, mtb. even more so than usual, tri is not currently where the money is at

For whatever it's worth (probably very little) here is what Specialized US RiderCare had to say: "We have seen production returning to expected levels but are still experiencing supply chain bottlenecks that continue to be an ongoing challenge. While the release of next model years bikes is intended to go on as expected, I unfortunately do not have dates of when these releases are expected to take place."
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Dugansposse] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Dugansposse wrote:
pk1 wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
Is it true that Shiv disc tri will not be produced in 2022? My seller say that it will not be replaced but not produced due lack of materials


yes, that is what i have heard too. or rather that is has not been produced this year so there won't be new stock for next year. i believe it will return.
they're focussing on the big growth areas - gravel, road, mtb. even more so than usual, tri is not currently where the money is at


For whatever it's worth (probably very little) here is what Specialized US RiderCare had to say: "We have seen production returning to expected levels but are still experiencing supply chain bottlenecks that continue to be an ongoing challenge. While the release of next model years bikes is intended to go on as expected, I unfortunately do not have dates of when these releases are expected to take place."


I guess the design is quite polarising too and the lack of an affordable model (as they've had in the past) probably has decapitated their tri market apart from the very wealthy. I actually really like this bike and would have bought one but they made the mistake of optimising it for 10 degrees of yaw and an event I never plan to do. So, you've got a really expensive frame, designed for Kona or for yaw's that aren't optimal for my races anywhere else and then wonder why its not a big seller for them. A real shame as I love their products generally and own/have owned a lot of them.
Last edited by: UK Gearmuncher: Sep 23, 21 23:55
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Looking for some trainingwheels and Zipp 303S with 28mm is in my mind. Will it fit the Shiv ? Innerdim is 23 mm i think. Looks like Paula Findlay is using this combo (or maybe its firecrest with innerdim 25mm?)
Last edited by: Bjarte79: Oct 8, 21 14:58
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I am curious to hear where on the bike people have mounted bottle cages, in light of the shark fin limiting the typical placement. If at the saddle regardless, which mounting solution and cage(s) have you purchased and how was the mounting achieved?

I notice this have been discussed briefly above based on some photos of pros on the web, basically Tim Don and Lucy Charles (google ā€œ specialized shiv 2019 bottleā€)https://m.imgur.com/vVZaNoW[/url]
Last edited by: erik2021: Nov 16, 21 6:49
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Im going with the two-750ml-behind-saddle option, which gives me 3.0L-ish on the bike. With some additional water bottle grabs on course, thats enough for me.

I'm 1.90m and have a Medium Shiv, so just enough space behind the seat for both bottle holders. Don't have any "special" parts, just the regular behind-the-seat Specialized item thats required: https://www.specialized.com/...eserve-rack/p/155838. I do have some sandpaper on the inside of both my bottle holders to hold the bottles in their place.

I've seen many people with a bottle between the aero bars, but I've also seen a guy do this:

https://www.instagram.com/p/CV2aGJNh8Op/
Last edited by: KoningBarry: Nov 16, 21 7:26
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [KoningBarry] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks! The property Specialized solution you point to is the one I am accustomed to and use on my Tarmac, however, the bike retailer said the bottle cages would not fit due to the Fuelcell limiting space (I am 1.9m as well but on a L). Glad to hear that solution is indeed possible without any custom adjustments!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I've seen some other awesome stuff, sadly 3D-printed etc so not really easy to get

Such as this:
https://www.instagram.com/p/CTEssusKgKC/
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I sent the question to Specialized just for manufacturerā€™s confirmation prior to a purchase. Their response, in short, is that it depends on the length of available seat post, which with the benefit of hindsight, should have been quite obvious to me. So, despite the two of us being of the same length, this is also the reason why you @KoningBarry can fit the solution on your Shiv M whilst I, being on a L, cannot.
Last edited by: erik2021: Nov 19, 21 6:31
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Please let me know if you find something :) butt me and all my friends with the shiv (6) have made it custom by them selfā€¦.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [KoningBarry] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
KoningBarry wrote:
Im going with the two-750ml-behind-saddle option, which gives me 3.0L-ish on the bike. With some additional water bottle grabs on course, thats enough for me.

I'm 1.90m and have a Medium Shiv, so just enough space behind the seat for both bottle holders. Don't have any "special" parts, just the regular behind-the-seat Specialized item thats required: https://www.specialized.com/...eserve-rack/p/155838. I do have some sandpaper on the inside of both my bottle holders to hold the bottles in their place.

I've seen many people with a bottle between the aero bars, but I've also seen a guy do this:

https://www.instagram.com/p/CV2aGJNh8Op/

I actually do have this one 3D printed myself. You can find the 3D design file pretty easily on the web. In fact there is a newer one that looks better (I haven't printed it yet...)





BTW, the Specialized reserve rack suc%$. I have it with a 2 bottle cage configuration and I've lost like 4-5 bottles on every 70.3 I've done (Bontrager XXX, an tacx bottle cages). I've bought a pair of Profile Design Kage, And will see...
Last edited by: manuzxr: Nov 19, 21 9:59
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi everyone,

Have been shadowing this thread since the Shiv's launch, finally got the chance to pounce on a well-priced used frameset (size s) but would like to check in on the sizing side of things before i pull the trigger.

Background: Currently using a 2018 Canyon Speedmax CF SLX S fitted with the following coords:

Armpad Stack (BB to top of arm pad): 633mm
Armpad Reach (BB to back of arm pad): 398mm

Would appreciate if I could get any advice on the appropriate frame size I should get!

Thanks in advance and have a good weekend everyone!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [frozzberg] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey all, I am interested in a used L Shiv Disc and trying to figure out if I can fit on it without cutting the hydration unit. My saddle height is 741mm. Does anyone know if that clears?

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Creatre] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Creatre wrote:
Hey all, I am interested in a used L Shiv Disc and trying to figure out if I can fit on it without cutting the hydration unit. My saddle height is 741mm. Does anyone know if that clears?

No It cannot...And your saddle height of 741mm suggests that you might even be best on a Size Small...

Who told you to consider a Lrg? I know your didnt provide all of your fit dimensions, but I would be very concerned with how you are determining what bike is best for you
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
Creatre wrote:
Hey all, I am interested in a used L Shiv Disc and trying to figure out if I can fit on it without cutting the hydration unit. My saddle height is 741mm. Does anyone know if that clears?

No It cannot...And your saddle height of 741mm suggests that you might even be best on a Size Small...

Who told you to consider a Lrg? I know your didnt provide all of your fit dimensions, but I would be very concerned with how you are determining what bike is best for you

Pad reach of 451, pad stack of 680. The shiv cockpit is more adjustable than most, but the frame geometry reach and stack of the Large are on par with every other frame Iā€™m looking at right now. The saddle height is the only thing making me hesitate. The medium would definitely also work, but this Large is about $3k off so obviously is swaying me. With the forward post I should hopefully only have to cut a few cm based on my estimation? Or more and just not worth it?

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Creatre] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Creatre wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
Creatre wrote:
Hey all, I am interested in a used L Shiv Disc and trying to figure out if I can fit on it without cutting the hydration unit. My saddle height is 741mm. Does anyone know if that clears?


No It cannot...And your saddle height of 741mm suggests that you might even be best on a Size Small...

Who told you to consider a Lrg? I know your didnt provide all of your fit dimensions, but I would be very concerned with how you are determining what bike is best for you


Pad reach of 451, pad stack of 680. The shiv cockpit is more adjustable than most, but the frame geometry reach and stack of the Large are on par with every other frame Iā€™m looking at right now. The saddle height is the only thing making me hesitate. The medium would definitely also work, but this Large is about $3k off so obviously is swaying me. With the forward post I should hopefully only have to cut a few cm based on my estimation? Or more and just not worth it?

Its close but it doesnt work. The Min (theoretical) saddle height on LRG, with +25mm offset post is 747mm...So unless you are going to cut the reservoir (bad idea) its not going to fit...not to mention the other issues. Best of Luck
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
Creatre wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
Creatre wrote:
Hey all, I am interested in a used L Shiv Disc and trying to figure out if I can fit on it without cutting the hydration unit. My saddle height is 741mm. Does anyone know if that clears?


No It cannot...And your saddle height of 741mm suggests that you might even be best on a Size Small...

Who told you to consider a Lrg? I know your didnt provide all of your fit dimensions, but I would be very concerned with how you are determining what bike is best for you


Pad reach of 451, pad stack of 680. The shiv cockpit is more adjustable than most, but the frame geometry reach and stack of the Large are on par with every other frame Iā€™m looking at right now. The saddle height is the only thing making me hesitate. The medium would definitely also work, but this Large is about $3k off so obviously is swaying me. With the forward post I should hopefully only have to cut a few cm based on my estimation? Or more and just not worth it?

Its close but it doesnt work. The Min (theoretical) saddle height on LRG, with +25mm offset post is 747mm...So unless you are going to cut the reservoir (bad idea) its not going to fit...not to mention the other issues. Best of Luck

Bah ugh was really hoping this would work. Last questionā€¦Iā€™m okay if I have to cut the reservoir 1-2cm but is there other issues? The rest of the bike seems to line up with my fit needs. Iā€™m 6ā€™, just have a weird fit with short legs and 155mm cranks and a long but high reach/stack.

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Creatre] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i cut 2 cm off mine at the top and it works. the bladder is a bit wrinkled up inside but still holds the fluid just slightly less. i did get a 3d printed refill solution made though so a few ml less doesn't really affect me.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tomaz021 wrote:
i cut 2 cm off mine at the top and it works. the bladder is a bit wrinkled up inside but still holds the fluid just slightly less. i did get a 3d printed refill solution made though so a few ml less doesn't really affect me.

Could you show me your 3d printed refill solution?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
yes i will over the next couple days. i planned on putting it on here a while ago but tested the proto first at an IM even and then we made improvements to it.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
alright there it is. basically it slides onto the attachment on the bottle cage mount. i use the middle one and the funnel is shaped in a way so it is ducked away behind the 2 bottles. for a full IM I use those 2 bottles to fill my bta with carbs and toss them at aid station. i then keep filling up through the funnel with water as i have a salt solution in it so it waters it down a bit but i also take salt tablets. i tested the proto at IM cairns and it worked really well. then we made a couple small changes for the final product.
Last edited by: Tomaz021: Dec 26, 21 16:23
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That's cool. Great idea.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Wonderful idea šŸ‘šŸ»
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Tomaz021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Do you plan to make these to sell? or even the file?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [twirpburrows] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply

It is actually my bike fitter who developed it with me and yes he sells them too. He has not advertised them but if you tell him what you are after he will know (just say you are after the refill mount like Thomas has on his shiv). You can contact him via this email aaron@fusionpeak.com.au and he will help you out.


Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Creatre] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Creatre wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
Creatre wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
Creatre wrote:
Hey all, I am interested in a used L Shiv Disc and trying to figure out if I can fit on it without cutting the hydration unit. My saddle height is 741mm. Does anyone know if that clears?


No It cannot...And your saddle height of 741mm suggests that you might even be best on a Size Small...

Who told you to consider a Lrg? I know your didnt provide all of your fit dimensions, but I would be very concerned with how you are determining what bike is best for you


Pad reach of 451, pad stack of 680. The shiv cockpit is more adjustable than most, but the frame geometry reach and stack of the Large are on par with every other frame Iā€™m looking at right now. The saddle height is the only thing making me hesitate. The medium would definitely also work, but this Large is about $3k off so obviously is swaying me. With the forward post I should hopefully only have to cut a few cm based on my estimation? Or more and just not worth it?


Its close but it doesnt work. The Min (theoretical) saddle height on LRG, with +25mm offset post is 747mm...So unless you are going to cut the reservoir (bad idea) its not going to fit...not to mention the other issues. Best of Luck


Bah ugh was really hoping this would work. Last questionā€¦Iā€™m okay if I have to cut the reservoir 1-2cm but is there other issues? The rest of the bike seems to line up with my fit needs. Iā€™m 6ā€™, just have a weird fit with short legs and 155mm cranks and a long but high reach/stack.

Turns out I had my saddle height wrong, I'm at 764mm and I got it to fit my specs without cutting the reservoir. The only "issue" is I'm pretty much slammed all the way forward with the 0 offset post, but it worked without having to modify my front end specs so can't complain! Got it brand new on ebay for $5100 with a brand new Garmin 1030+ and 4iii power cranks, so very happy lol.

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Chris_Mint] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i'm sure its here somewhere but i can't find it now.
i'm looking for info on the best way to empty, clean and generally maintain the bladder and hose, can't see anything on the specialized site
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Creatre] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What is everyone doing for the bta? Should I just buy the one that comes with the sworks? Or go with an aftermarket solution?

Also has anyone upgraded just their pads?

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Creatre] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi - I've just purchased a Shiv Tri and have upgraded the front end to the AeroCoach angles extensions and carbon arm rests. Has anyone encountered issues with the di2 cabling? The standard poles have cut outs to enable the di2 cables to be fed through the stackers and down to the junction box. Obviously the after market Aerocoach bars don't have these cut outs, so what are people using as a work around?

Identical to the image attached - but I cant quite work out how they've resolved the cabling issue.

Much appreciated
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [8701dg] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
8701dg wrote:
Obviously the after market Aerocoach bars don't have these cut outs, so what are people using as a work around?

Identical to the image attached - but I cant quite work out how they've resolved the cabling issue.

For Shimano, the only option is to route out the back of the extension, and then turn back forward and down thru the hydration passageway. It wont be as elegant but once a BTA Bottle is there, you will forget about it.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
8701dg wrote:
Obviously the after market Aerocoach bars don't have these cut outs, so what are people using as a work around?

Identical to the image attached - but I cant quite work out how they've resolved the cabling issue.


For Shimano, the only option is to route out the back of the extension, and then turn back forward and down thru the hydration passageway. It wont be as elegant but once a BTA Bottle is there, you will forget about it.

Unfortunately my cables aren't long enough for that option, I did think of that. Is it possible to buy connection di2 cables to make them longer?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [8701dg] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
8701dg wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
8701dg wrote:
Obviously the after market Aerocoach bars don't have these cut outs, so what are people using as a work around?

Identical to the image attached - but I cant quite work out how they've resolved the cabling issue.


For Shimano, the only option is to route out the back of the extension, and then turn back forward and down thru the hydration passageway. It wont be as elegant but once a BTA Bottle is there, you will forget about it.


Unfortunately my cables aren't long enough for that option, I did think of that. Is it possible to buy connection di2 cables to make them longer?

Yes, you can get a longer cables...you should double check your setup and the length you need, but because its designed around the Y-cable you may have to get creative.

Another option is to run it external from the hand position (partially under your bar tape) and then you can dive inside the tower from the front as intended
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
8701dg wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
8701dg wrote:
Obviously the after market Aerocoach bars don't have these cut outs, so what are people using as a work around?

Identical to the image attached - but I cant quite work out how they've resolved the cabling issue.


For Shimano, the only option is to route out the back of the extension, and then turn back forward and down thru the hydration passageway. It wont be as elegant but once a BTA Bottle is there, you will forget about it.


Unfortunately my cables aren't long enough for that option, I did think of that. Is it possible to buy connection di2 cables to make them longer?


Yes, you can get a longer cables...you should double check your setup and the length you need, but because its designed around the Y-cable you may have to get creative.

Another option is to run it external from the hand position (partially under your bar tape) and then you can dive inside the tower from the front as intended

Great thanks, the di2 cables on my shifters are hard wired, but looks like I can use the EW-JC200 junction with a couple of EW-SD50 Wires to get the reach down to the junction box. Probably tidier (ableit more $) going for that option rather than running the cabling down the back of the bars. Bars don't need bar tape either so wouldn't be as concealed/tidy. I suppose drilling a couple of holes in the carbon isn't recommended?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [8701dg] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
8701dg wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
8701dg wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
8701dg wrote:
Obviously the after market Aerocoach bars don't have these cut outs, so what are people using as a work around?

Identical to the image attached - but I cant quite work out how they've resolved the cabling issue.


For Shimano, the only option is to route out the back of the extension, and then turn back forward and down thru the hydration passageway. It wont be as elegant but once a BTA Bottle is there, you will forget about it.


Unfortunately my cables aren't long enough for that option, I did think of that. Is it possible to buy connection di2 cables to make them longer?


Yes, you can get a longer cables...you should double check your setup and the length you need, but because its designed around the Y-cable you may have to get creative.

Another option is to run it external from the hand position (partially under your bar tape) and then you can dive inside the tower from the front as intended


Great thanks, the di2 cables on my shifters are hard wired, but looks like I can use the EW-JC200 junction with a couple of EW-SD50 Wires to get the reach down to the junction box. Probably tidier (ableit more $) going for that option rather than running the cabling down the back of the bars. Bars don't need bar tape either so wouldn't be as concealed/tidy. I suppose drilling a couple of holes in the carbon isn't recommended?

Yes that will work, but just plan ahead where in the cable run you want the JC200...since they have some width to them, you dont want them stacked adjacent or in the tower otherwise the hydration hose may have trouble routing. You want to plan the connection to be in the nosecone area where you have easy access
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
8701dg wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
8701dg wrote:
GatorRacer wrote:
8701dg wrote:
Obviously the after market Aerocoach bars don't have these cut outs, so what are people using as a work around?

Identical to the image attached - but I cant quite work out how they've resolved the cabling issue.


For Shimano, the only option is to route out the back of the extension, and then turn back forward and down thru the hydration passageway. It wont be as elegant but once a BTA Bottle is there, you will forget about it.


Unfortunately my cables aren't long enough for that option, I did think of that. Is it possible to buy connection di2 cables to make them longer?


Yes, you can get a longer cables...you should double check your setup and the length you need, but because its designed around the Y-cable you may have to get creative.

Another option is to run it external from the hand position (partially under your bar tape) and then you can dive inside the tower from the front as intended


Great thanks, the di2 cables on my shifters are hard wired, but looks like I can use the EW-JC200 junction with a couple of EW-SD50 Wires to get the reach down to the junction box. Probably tidier (ableit more $) going for that option rather than running the cabling down the back of the bars. Bars don't need bar tape either so wouldn't be as concealed/tidy. I suppose drilling a couple of holes in the carbon isn't recommended?


Yes that will work, but just plan ahead where in the cable run you want the JC200...since they have some width to them, you dont want them stacked adjacent or in the tower otherwise the hydration hose may have trouble routing. You want to plan the connection to be in the nosecone area where you have easy access

Thanks, that's a great point. I think my only option will be to mount it inside the extension poles. The 4 port junction port is in the nosecone. I can't seem to find the width of the JC200 online, it may be the case of try and see.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [8701dg] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
8701dg wrote:
Thanks, that's a great point. I think my only option will be to mount it inside the extension poles. The 4 port junction port is in the nosecone. I can't seem to find the width of the JC200 online, it may be the case of try and see.

That will work! Wrap it with bartape so it doesn't rattle. Good Luck!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [wintershade] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
At me i use a Shimano Ultegra brake caliper and i use it without the adapter, so it fits 140mm. Means you put the caliper directly on to the frame
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ogni] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hey, i'm planing to do an hilly triathlon event (arround 1200m elevation for 90km). I should ride arround 34-36km/h average speed.
I have a specialized shiv disc but in training i never used my back fuel tank ( i prefer standart bottle behind the saddle). So is the fuel tank make the bike faster ? (if yes by how much in a 90KM event with an average speed of 40km/h , or an idea for my specific event?)
Is it a good idea to ride without it during the race (take in consideration i'm very confident in my descending skills without it and also the little weigt gains.)
Thanks for your help :)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [hadrie31] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
hadrie31 wrote:
Hey, i'm planing to do an hilly triathlon event (arround 1200m elevation for 90km). I should ride arround 34-36km/h average speed.
I have a specialized shiv disc but in training i never used my back fuel tank ( i prefer standart bottle behind the saddle). So is the fuel tank make the bike faster ? (if yes by how much in a 90KM event with an average speed of 40km/h , or an idea for my specific event?)
Is it a good idea to ride without it during the race (take in consideration i'm very confident in my descending skills without it and also the little weigt gains.)
Thanks for your help :)

Definitely race with it on in any situation
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GatorRacer wrote:
hadrie31 wrote:
Hey, i'm planing to do an hilly triathlon event (arround 1200m elevation for 90km). I should ride arround 34-36km/h average speed.
I have a specialized shiv disc but in training i never used my back fuel tank ( i prefer standart bottle behind the saddle). So is the fuel tank make the bike faster ? (if yes by how much in a 90KM event with an average speed of 40km/h , or an idea for my specific event?)
Is it a good idea to ride without it during the race (take in consideration i'm very confident in my descending skills without it and also the little weigt gains.)
Thanks for your help :)


Definitely race with it on in any situation

thanks for the reply !
Do you have any data in mind for the advantage of the fuel tank ?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [hadrie31] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
From memroy Ruben was testing it in a video (velodrome) and it was around a 3W saving I think. But then again it will be different for everyone.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi,

Another sizing question here.
I had a Shiv TT rim brake version, size medium. I'm trying to see which size i would need on the Shiv Disc.

If I compare geometry with my former bike, it looks like the frame stack of the TT in medium would match better with the frame stack of Shiv Disc Medium.
However, if I compare the frame reach of the TT medium, this corresponds better with the frame reach of the Shiv Disc Large...

My saddle height is 790 mm (center BB to top of saddle). Drop to the armpads is 129mm.
I know that a Shiv Disc Medium would be perfectly adjustable to match my fit when looking to the armpads. I'm worried however that the reach to the basebar (which cannot be adjusted) will be too short. I've read about some knee clearance issues when standing up, ... . So I would like to avoid that.

On a Large, the armpad reach will also be adjustable, the base bar reach will be more like on my previous shiv TT, and the base bar stack would also be ok when I put the base bar in the low position.
However, I'm not sure if I have enough clearance on the hydration cell with my saddle height, and if I can get my armpads low enough (minimum stack on large is 617mm, so I believe this would work, since I think I have a armpad stack of 640mm more or less...)

Any advice?
Anyone else who made the switch from a medium TT to a Shiv Disc and what size they went?

Thanks.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Likeglad] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Likeglad wrote:
Please let me know if you find something :) butt me and all my friends with the shiv (6) have made it custom by them selfā€¦.


Reporting back in the hydration topic, happy to hopefully help others with the same question. I have tested the below products:

1. Profile design HSF/Aero HC 800+: Does not fit BTA as it is too long. Neither on top tube behind stem works, as the HC 800+ is again too long and touches the stem.

2. PD FC System Bottle Kit 35 oz: Too large as it leaves no space between bars.

My hunch is that differences in stock setup of cockpit will not make a difference, but of course, cannot be 100% certain.

Due to above outcome, I decided to ignore the bike retailer ruling out the SWAT-solution and give it a go and voila, it fitted above the fuselage with the tiniest of margins (I am 190 cm on a size L with 0 offset post and RetĆ¼l fitted bike).

NEW question: How to best decide length of Fuselage straw and placement with magnet to enable drinking in aero position? Happy to hear/see photos how others have done, or if people use it while at base bar?
Last edited by: erik2021: Jun 25, 22 11:09
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [8701dg] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hi! i'm also using the Aerocoach bars, but i reached out to the nice folks at Aerocoach to drill a hole on each bar before sending out. For my setup, it worked if i had the hole placed as close as possible to the bend. Attached pics for reference.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
erik2021 wrote:
Likeglad wrote:
Please let me know if you find something :) butt me and all my friends with the shiv (6) have made it custom by them selfā€¦.


Reporting back in the hydration topic, happy to hopefully help others with the same question. I have tested the below products:

1. Profile design HSF/Aero HC 800+: Does not fit BTA as it is too long. Neither on top tube behind stem works, as the HC 800+ is again too long and touches the stem.

2. PD FC System Bottle Kit 35 oz: Too large as it leaves no space between bars.

My hunch is that differences in stock setup of cockpit will not make a difference, but of course, cannot be 100% certain.

Due to above outcome, I decided to ignore the bike retailer ruling out the SWAT-solution and give it a go and voila, it fitted above the fuselage with the tiniest of margins (I am 190 cm on a size L with 0 offset post and RetĆ¼l fitted bike).

NEW question: How to best decide length of Fuselage straw and placement with magnet to enable drinking in aero position? Happy to hear/see photos how others have done, or if people use it while at base bar?

** UPDATE ** Solved the placement of the straw.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Some pics?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What is the max saddle height of the large size Shiv Disc? My wife is riding a large 2016 Shiv with a height of 82cm from the middle of bottom bracket to seat rail, with a 12cm drop to the bars. Would that work with the new Shiv Disc bike? Thanks.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [tomk407] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How tall is your wife? Thatā€™s 30 mm more seat post than me and Iā€™m damn near 6ā€™1ā€.

Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
She's 6'1", but is all legs. Her inseam is 37". The shiv is the only bike we could find that would fit her. On many bikes the seat post would max out. Don't want to have the seat post inserted past the safety line.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I am considering the Roval 321 disc wheel; would a switch from the stock CLX wheel to the 321 per default require adjustment to the rear derailleur? I am asking to understand how easy it would be to switch back and forth between the wheels post purchase.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
erik2021 wrote:
I am considering the Roval 321 disc wheel; would a switch from the stock CLX wheel to the 321 per default require adjustment to the rear derailleur? I am asking to understand how easy it would be to switch back and forth between the wheels post purchase.

No Issues assuming you are swapping the entire cassette/freehub (the easiest way). You would only need a derailleur adjustment if you change gearing or drivetrains

Where adjustment becomes more "tricky" is if you are sharing wheels with another bike, because your disc brake rotor-to caliper position becomes a point to pay attention to and different bikes are going to have different pad wear (or maybe even rotor size)
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [GatorRacer] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
For avoidance of doubt, do you mean I use 1x hub/cassette for both wheels, or that each wheel keeps its hub/cassette coming on and off the bike? Thanks.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Does anyone have race wheel recommendations for the Shiv Disc? I have been running 60/88's and they have been great but looking to buy a race set. I know generic recommendations based on other bikes but curious if there are specific wheels that are advantageous because of the unique design elements

For instance, is it better to go wider or thinner for the front wheel with the wide gap of the fork blades? Is a tri spoke more advantageous in this design? For the rear, does the sail add any advantage to using a disc wheel vs a deep dish wheel? Is there any other advantages that I haven't considered?

Thanks.

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Last edited by: theyellowcarguy: Apr 4, 23 9:18
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [damon.lebeouf] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Feels like passing your competition as they slow down to grab/drop bottles from aid stations.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So what's the latest now with this bike model ? Is it being deleted, being replaced or merely continuing as it was ?
Last edited by: UK Gearmuncher: Jun 28, 23 6:11
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [UK Gearmuncher] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Specialized has largely exited the triathlon market and they no longer manufacture the Shiv. If you want one, try Facebook, eBay or ST classifieds.

They have quirks but once you figure ā€˜em out itā€™s easy.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [Sparkystiltskin] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sparkystiltskin wrote:
They have quirks but once you figure ā€˜em out itā€™s easy.

What quirks have you found?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
doing my best to dig up the past....

road cyclist here getting back into tri's for the first time in over a decade. could use some insight from folks that have fooled around or owned one of these things.

shiv finder has me almost directly in between sizes - as in, just a 0.25in difference in shin measurement moves me from XS frame to a SM frame.

1) 5'7" and the last tri fit i did (quite a few years ago) had my x,y at 452,505. seems from previous posts that since these figures are within the range of both sizes, that i should pick based on saddle height. is that accurate?
2) saddle height is ~685mm. from a quick eyeball test, that ain't gonna be enough for the hydration fin to work on the SM frame. would this justify sizing down to the XS frame? just looks like a very small bike so having a hard time with that.
3) if i stuck with the SM size, am i able to simply lop off the top of the reservoir so that it will fit underneath the saddle and still be used? i know i'll lose capacity and am ok with it. would i be able to purchase an XS bladder for the newly cut reservoir? or do the dimension of the top change?
4) was planning to run Zipp 303 and 404 FC wheels (the new ones) with 28s. these are pirelli's labeled as 28s for whatever it's worth. will those fit? think erik2021's question is similar to mine because the plan is simply to swap wheels used for road cycling and other bikes onto this one.

thanks in advance for the help!
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [rossdude5] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rossdude5 wrote:
doing my best to dig up the past....

road cyclist here getting back into tri's for the first time in over a decade. could use some insight from folks that have fooled around or owned one of these things.

shiv finder has me almost directly in between sizes - as in, just a 0.25in difference in shin measurement moves me from XS frame to a SM frame.

1) 5'7" and the last tri fit i did (quite a few years ago) had my x,y at 452,505. seems from previous posts that since these figures are within the range of both sizes, that i should pick based on saddle height. is that accurate?
2) saddle height is ~685mm. from a quick eyeball test, that ain't gonna be enough for the hydration fin to work on the SM frame. would this justify sizing down to the XS frame? just looks like a very small bike so having a hard time with that.
3) if i stuck with the SM size, am i able to simply lop off the top of the reservoir so that it will fit underneath the saddle and still be used? i know i'll lose capacity and am ok with it. would i be able to purchase an XS bladder for the newly cut reservoir? or do the dimension of the top change?
4) was planning to run Zipp 303 and 404 FC wheels (the new ones) with 28s. these are pirelli's labeled as 28s for whatever it's worth. will those fit? think erik2021's question is similar to mine because the plan is simply to swap wheels used for road cycling and other bikes onto this one.

thanks in advance for the help!

Recommendations from posts in here in the past have always been to size up. You get a bigger reservoir and you'll have more clearance for your knees (they can sometimes hit the bars) and reach on the front end.

Yes you can cut the reservoir, you just use the same bladder it'll work and you won't lose much or any capacity. You can also run the forward offset seatpost for a little more clearance too if you are able with your fit.

I'd be surprised if 28s won't fit. I have plenty of clearance with my 25s but you won't know until you try. I've heard some people have fit them okay at a standstill but during movement/weight/flexing it can rub the reservoir some.

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [rossdude5] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rossdude5 wrote:
doing my best to dig up the past....

road cyclist here getting back into tri's for the first time in over a decade. could use some insight from folks that have fooled around or owned one of these things.

shiv finder has me almost directly in between sizes - as in, just a 0.25in difference in shin measurement moves me from XS frame to a SM frame.

1) 5'7" and the last tri fit i did (quite a few years ago) had my x,y at 452,505. seems from previous posts that since these figures are within the range of both sizes, that i should pick based on saddle height. is that accurate?
2) saddle height is ~685mm. from a quick eyeball test, that ain't gonna be enough for the hydration fin to work on the SM frame. would this justify sizing down to the XS frame? just looks like a very small bike so having a hard time with that.
3) if i stuck with the SM size, am i able to simply lop off the top of the reservoir so that it will fit underneath the saddle and still be used? i know i'll lose capacity and am ok with it. would i be able to purchase an XS bladder for the newly cut reservoir? or do the dimension of the top change?
4) was planning to run Zipp 303 and 404 FC wheels (the new ones) with 28s. these are pirelli's labeled as 28s for whatever it's worth. will those fit? think erik2021's question is similar to mine because the plan is simply to swap wheels used for road cycling and other bikes onto this one.

thanks in advance for the help!

i wanted to run 28mm G5000TR on swiss side wheels on my medium shiv. the frame clearance is fine but the reservoir doesn't quite follow the same curve - it tightens up on the wheel higher up so it rubs on any slight bump. really annoying
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [theyellowcarguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks for the input. guess i'll give the SM a go.

if i run the same bladder but the foil it sits inside of is missing an inch or so from the top, does it create folds/kinks that make it hard to use while riding? assumed if i cut it, i'd have to use the next size smaller bladder.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [rossdude5] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rossdude5 wrote:
thanks for the input. guess i'll give the SM a go.

if i run the same bladder but the foil it sits inside of is missing an inch or so from the top, does it create folds/kinks that make it hard to use while riding? assumed if i cut it, i'd have to use the next size smaller bladder.

Afaik the bladder's aren't exchangeable so you don't have the option to downsize. I can't speak from experience but others have said they've cut the reservoir and not had an issue with the bladder usage.

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [theyellowcarguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Just a FYI there is also a shiv disc owners group on facebook. There is some good content there you can search or double post your questions there for some second opinions. It's a little more active than this thread sometimes.

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [theyellowcarguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Is there any cons if I will race in Ironman WC in Nice without the fin ? I want to enlight my Shiv and I will not use the bladder for hydration
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
Is there any cons if I will race in Ironman WC in Nice without the fin ? I want to enlight my Shiv and I will not use the bladder for hydration

In theory an aero deficit, however Iā€™ve ridden without it multiple times and never noticed a difference.

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [theyellowcarguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
theyellowcarguy wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
Is there any cons if I will race in Ironman WC in Nice without the fin ? I want to enlight my Shiv and I will not use the bladder for hydration


In theory an aero deficit, however Iā€™ve ridden without it multiple times and never noticed a difference.

Do you find a little less stability downhill with the wind? Like large blades fork could keep much wind respect the rear? The fin give the bike much stability with the wind?
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
theyellowcarguy wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
Is there any cons if I will race in Ironman WC in Nice without the fin ? I want to enlight my Shiv and I will not use the bladder for hydration


In theory an aero deficit, however Iā€™ve ridden without it multiple times and never noticed a difference.

Do you find a little less stability downhill with the wind? Like large blades fork could keep much wind respect the rear? The fin give the bike much stability with the wind?

Not sure, Iā€™ve only ridden on flat without it. I noticed no crosswind difference, it still handled fine for me.

My Strava | My Instagram | Summerville, SC | 35-39 AG | 4:41 (70.3), 10:05 (140.6) | 3x70.3, 1x140.6 | Cat 2 Cyclist
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [theyellowcarguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The Shiv gets new paintworks: https://www.specialized.com/...?color=430654-274934

Specialized doing the bare minimum to keep it away from retirement.
Last edited by: erik2021: Apr 21, 24 13:20
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [erik2021] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Interesting - the USA site doesnā€™t even have the Shiv Tri available - interesting that it seems to be somewhat alive.

___________________________________
MS: Exercise Science
Your speed matters a lot, sometimes you need to be very fast, where sometimes you need to breakdown your speed.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [enricobraglia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
enricobraglia wrote:
theyellowcarguy wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
Is there any cons if I will race in Ironman WC in Nice without the fin ? I want to enlight my Shiv and I will not use the bladder for hydration


In theory an aero deficit, however Iā€™ve ridden without it multiple times and never noticed a difference.


Do you find a little less stability downhill with the wind? Like large blades fork could keep much wind respect the rear? The fin give the bike much stability with the wind?

Bear in mind by not using the hydration storage, you'll then see the centre of pressure acting on the bike move a long way forward which would make the bike less stable in crosswind and alter its handling at speed.
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [UK Gearmuncher] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
UK Gearmuncher wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
theyellowcarguy wrote:
enricobraglia wrote:
Is there any cons if I will race in Ironman WC in Nice without the fin ? I want to enlight my Shiv and I will not use the bladder for hydration


In theory an aero deficit, however Iā€™ve ridden without it multiple times and never noticed a difference.


Do you find a little less stability downhill with the wind? Like large blades fork could keep much wind respect the rear? The fin give the bike much stability with the wind?

Bear in mind by not using the hydration storage, you'll then see the centre of pressure acting on the bike move a long way forward which would make the bike less stable in crosswind and alter its handling at speed.

infact in the descent to Nice my Shiv without the hydration storage was so instable .. Itā€™s not a bike for Ironman Nice
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [IKnowEverything] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
IKnowEverything wrote:
Interesting - the USA site doesnā€™t even have the Shiv Tri available - interesting that it seems to be somewhat alive.

They sold tens of tens of them so makes sense to keep it alive after five years.

Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Quote Reply
Re: S-WORKS SHIV DISC 2019 IS HERE [IKnowEverything] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Recently joined the above mentioned Shiv group on Facebook and saw a third colour scheme posted by a French speaking member, as well as evidence of stock in Japan.
Quote Reply