Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Prev Next
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [gplama] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Dear Garmin, just make the 515 with a bigger battery and a USB-C charging port and I will give you even more money.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [elf6c] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Watch Garmin come out with a 515+ next month.

Jokes aside I am actually in the market for one right now, I will likely buy the TL 515 but maybe I should actually wait to see if Garmin does in fact release a updated version soon.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [elf6c] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
elf6c wrote:
Dear Garmin, just make the 515 with a bigger battery and a USB-C charging port and I will give you even more money.

The 715 has USB-C charging.

Pink? Maybe. Maybe not. You decide.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [gplama] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
gplama wrote:
I'm all over it. They didn't supply a media unit. I had to find one in store the day after release. I've since tested it extensively.

Firstly, the media reviews missed so much information I'm pretty peeved after having spent money on one only to have to find out all the finer points myself. It's the first radar to use 77GHz, that's a big change from the standard 24GHz all other radars currently use. NO review tested the extraordinary detection distance claims. No mention of the flashing pattern not changing on a detection. No mention the post mount was shitty on aero posts. No mention of the ANT+ Radar spec limitation of 196m maximum distance reporting that would/could possibly screw with head units.

All that aside, I set out to verify their claims of 240m detection distance. They'd hung their hat on this in their promo videos, every media review was parroting the same specs. HUGE if true. I couldn't. Not with an Edge and ConnectIQ app that shows vehicle distance. Putting that aside, visually I couldn't see it pick up cars any earlier than 140-150m with a rough measurement, it was definitely not 240m. After obsessing about what I screwed up with my testing overnight, the next morning I was out testing the unit side-by-side with the Bryton Gardia R300L then the Garmin Varia RTL515. I observed NO difference in the detection times/distances in what I would consider near perfect conditions. That was all captured in full 4k... along with someone flipping me off and mouthing something at me for standing on the roadside looking like a speed trap. Nice.

Road Test:


Side-by-Side Test:


I had to put in WAY too much work in an attempt to have this device prove itself. It never did. 240m is a BIG claim. BIG.

I've since had two calls with Trek (Friday and Monday). Kudos to them for answering my queries and wanting to discuss my testing protocol/conditions. They're confident in the measurements/testing they'd done, which is great. I can't replicate their results with the unit I purchased.

I'll give it a little more time.. but not much. Stay tuned. I'm in the states for a week and have the unit with me. I might pick up another while I'm here and do more testing before putting up a review in full.

Thanks for this! My takeaways were that detection is as good as garmin, battery life is a weak spot, but it has the attention grabbing flash pattern I like and usb c. I hate dishonest or optimistic marketing claims, but if garmin doesn’t have something better by end of May I’m ordering one of these for sure.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [commendatore] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I use the radar without a light and the bontrager flare.rt. No camera but the best of both imo. My u it is 4yrs old I guess and still lasts 5hrs plus.

http://www.TriScottsdale.org
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [The GMAN] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I love their math example of the benefit of their extended detection range. Who rides 25kph on a road with 100kph car traffic?

----------------------------------
"Go yell at an M&M"
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [klehner] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
klehner wrote:
I love their math example of the benefit of their extended detection range. Who rides 25kph on a road with 100kph car traffic?

Anyone riding on an open road with a headwind and or slightly hillier terrain?
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [Sbernardi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sbernardi wrote:
I use the radar without a light and the bontrager flare.rt. No camera but the best of both imo. My u it is 4yrs old I guess and still lasts 5hrs plus.

After having my second Flare RT die in wet conditions – which was a warranty replacement of my first Flare RT that also died in wet conditions – I would never touch them again. Since this can leave you in the dark and rain without a rear light, IMHO it is a major problem with this product.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [duncan] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
duncan wrote:
Sbernardi wrote:
I use the radar without a light and the bontrager flare.rt. No camera but the best of both imo. My u it is 4yrs old I guess and still lasts 5hrs plus.


After having my second Flare RT die in wet conditions – which was a warranty replacement of my first Flare RT that also died in wet conditions – I would never touch them again. Since this can leave you in the dark and rain without a rear light, IMHO it is a major problem with this product.

That was my problem with Cycliq (camera, not radar). I bricked like 6-7 units in the rain. Warranty service was decent, but finally I just gave up on them.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [klehner] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
klehner wrote:
I love their math example of the benefit of their extended detection range. Who rides 25kph on a road with 100kph car traffic?

https://forum.slowtwitch.com/...ost=5555031#p5555031
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [gplama] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have a Varia RTL515 and mu buddy just got the Trek CarBack. Both of us use a Garmin 530 as a head unit. While riding yesterday, we tested the Trek vs. the Garmin and we got the radar warning at the same time; a few times he got it before me, but also a few times, I got the warning slightly ahead of him.

I would say the range is pretty much identical.

"Suddenly the thought struck me. My floor is someone elses ceiling"-Nils Ferlin
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [gplama] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks for the review. personally, if i have 140yd or thereabouts that's fine for me. if somebody actually comes out with a radar that'll alert me if the car is going to run up the rear of me, that i'd be interested in. i recognize that would probably require some granularity that doesn't exist in the tech.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowman wrote:
thanks for the review. personally, if i have 140yd or thereabouts that's fine for me. if somebody actually comes out with a radar that'll alert me if the car is going to run up the rear of me, that i'd be interested in. i recognize that would probably require some granularity that doesn't exist in the tech.
That is a camera unit akin to what most automotive LKA and lane centering systems use. The nut is the camera needs to see the lane lines and an object's relative position within those lanes to know if you are at risk. Radar cannot do that - it is far too low resolution. Radar can only really "see" an approaching object in general. LiDAR could also see an object's relative position to lanes, but that might be a bit bulky for a bike...

When I get an alert, it reminds me to ride true and listen. Also, when group riding, we all drop to single-file with an alert. So, while these radar-driven behaviors do not eliminate run-up-the-rear risk, they greatly reduce it.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Do you have one of these, Dan?

I used to think the same as you - this this isn’t “good enough”. But my varia is far and away my favorite cycling purchase I’ve ever made. I don’t like riding without it
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [mvenneta] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mvenneta wrote:
Do you have one of these, Dan?

I used to think the same as you - this this isn’t “good enough”. But my varia is far and away my favorite cycling purchase I’ve ever made. I don’t like riding without it

i'm naked without a varia on my road bike. i have a pair of varias and i don't know when i first got mine but probably 5 years ago? it's almost up there with my helmet as a must-have or won't-ride. i don't have the trek radar yet.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
For bikes that don't have an easy way to attached a rear radar - has anyone successfully attached to a jersey pocket for a ride?

the world's still turning? >>>>>>> the world's still turning
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [Callin'] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Callin' wrote:
For bikes that don't have an easy way to attached a rear radar - has anyone successfully attached to a jersey pocket for a ride?

You have me really curious as to how unique this bike is as there are so many options out there.

I have one of these for my road bike:
https://neat-components.com/collections/frontpage

One of these for my triathlon bike that has a threaded insert in the seat post:
https://k-edge.com/...avity-top-cap-mount/

A lot of people I ride with use this one on a wide range of bikes:
https://komcycling.com/...s/garmin-varia-mount

I've seen this one once out in the wild but it doesn't work well with saddle bags or rear hydration systems so it's probably not a good fit for you either:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CBL9J67N
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [exxxviii] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
  




Quote:
So, while these radar-driven behaviors do not eliminate run-up-the-rear risk, they greatly reduce it.


I can maybe envision hearing some way-too-high-revving engine approaching rapidly from behind and then make the decision to immediately ditch off the road. But in 40 years of cycling I've never ditched. Except once due to a speeding car coming at me head-on on a 1-lane road. Of course many times I've heard speeding cars coming rapidly from behind. But I usually just hope they're just some jackass speeding and not someone aiming for me. So far I'm batting 1000 in that hope. The day I have to start ditching offroad more than about once per decade is the day I go full MTB/gravel.

Radar is absolutely a great tool. I use it all the time. Just don't think it does anything to reduce the naked risk of being run up from behind. There is absolutely no way to know if the car approaching from behind is going to suddenly veer and take you out or not. It's just pure hope.

Autonomous car tech won't help much, I don't think. Car actuation system can respond very quickly, brake and steer in sub-millisecond response to sensor data. We, as cyclists can't respond much at all.

Well I take that back. Autonomous car tech will help a *ton* just in different ways. Cheap "5G" transponders built into a head unit or watch will one day transmit to all nearby cars that you, a cyclist/runner, are in the vicinity, with location as accurate as today's geolocation systems. And the cars will then prepare to avoid you before you even show up in the sensor data. And the sensors will just confirm what the car already knows.

I think long-term, it makes far more sense to put the expensive sensors on cars. And the cheap transponders on our bodies or bikes.
Last edited by: trail: Apr 24, 24 14:14
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
Radar is absolutely a great tool. I use it all the time. Just don't think it does anything to reduce the naked risk of being run up from behind.
I could not ride outside without it now...

I did a long ride with a friend Saturday, and my Garmin was dead. So, I had no radar. Fortunately he did. I felt a little exposed not knowing whether a car was approaching except by trying to discern from his Garmin's beeping. I found I like knowing what is going on behind me without having to look.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [exxxviii] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
exxxviii wrote:
trail wrote:
Radar is absolutely a great tool. I use it all the time. Just don't think it does anything to reduce the naked risk of being run up from behind.
I could not ride outside without it now...

I did a long ride with a friend Saturday, and my Garmin was dead. So, I had no radar. Fortunately he did. I felt a little exposed not knowing whether a car was approaching except by trying to discern from his Garmin's beeping. I found I like knowing what is going on behind me without having to look.

Ha, yeah now that I mostly cycle on remote mountain roads where radar makes the most sense, I feel utterly naked without it.

It's brilliant descending down the Sierra mountains when the wind noise at 50MPH is so loud you can't hear cars. I could take the lane and descend like a madman, but still find places to let the rare cars pass with ease due to radar. At 50MPH actually turning to look back can be terrifying on twisty roads.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [Lehrn2Lose] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks for those links to alternative mounts.
i'm pretty new to the varia verse (this year) - but I do like it and i REALLY want my wife to have one.
she rides a smaller frame (and not a lot of extra seat post sticking out/ and is loathe to get a smaller seat bag (I'm trying!)), so...
a mount that would extend from the back of the saddle makes sense to me.
that amazon one on your link looks to extend back from the saddle a bit (leaving some room for that seat bag).

I suspect, just like me (and a lot of others), once she gets in tune with what the varia is telling her - it's hard not to see it's usefulness.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [fredericknorton] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
fredericknorton wrote:
a mount that would extend from the back of the saddle makes sense to me.

One more for you :)
https://komcycling.com/products/saddle-bag
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [fredericknorton] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
fredericknorton wrote:
a mount that would extend from the back of the saddle makes sense to me.
that amazon one on your link looks to extend back from the saddle a bit (leaving some room for that seat bag).

https://buplabs.com/...fizik-gen-mount-base

If you have a fizik saddle, this seems like the nicest option.

I've got a variation of the Amazon one - it's pretty hard to get a saddle bag under it so I've mostly shifted to keeping a wrap in my jersey pocket instead. I tried extending it with an aluminum GoPro extension, but ended up snapping it due to the added stress from it bobbing.
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [Callin'] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Callin' wrote:
For bikes that don't have an easy way to attached a rear radar - has anyone successfully attached to a jersey pocket for a ride?


https://www.garmin.com/en-US/p/874032 Saddle mount from Garmin.

Kiwami Racing Team
Quote Reply
Re: Trek CarBack radar light. Looks like Garmin has a serious competitor for the Varia. [andrewjshults] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks for all the links to saddle mounts. wisdom of the crowd is helpful.
i ordered a seat rails mount to try - we'll see.
my wife and I both have selle smp saddles (finding a go to saddle is a WHOLE other conversation!).
selle smp have their selle brand plate attached to the back of the saddle with 4 bolts on each side.

i think the name plate is somewhat functional as it also serves to fix the rails in place against the body of the saddle.

because there are fixes for trek/specialized/fizik/others? saddles, i wonder if there isn't one for selle?
or... how hard would be to 3D print the top piece selle uses WITH a garmin mount?

again, many thanks for the wisdom, links, and ideas - sincerely, rick
Quote Reply

Prev Next