Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Prev Next
Re: Iran attacks Israel [chaparral] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
chaparral wrote:
DavHamm wrote:
ThisIsIt wrote:
Endo wrote:
Seems like a very inefficient/low success rate to launch a bunch of drones at your target and they know they're coming, but will take "hours" to get there and thus have loads of time to prepare and enact countermeasures on drones that relatively speaking, are pretty slow moving targets themselves.



.


I've heard it argued that the real value of these cheap drones is that they are meant to exhaust the much more expensive resources that may be used to shoot them down. And of course you send enough some are going to get through, and the whole psychological and political angle of using of them.


So if we get the okay from Jordan, could this be a turkey shoot for and some gunfire practice for our fighters?

I mean bullets are cheap, could you just start shooting at them from a jet? (I guess you risk them exploding so need to keep some distance).

This seems to be an area, we need improved defenses. I mean some kind of drag behind netting to just scoop them up would be cool, if it could be done.


Still not a turkey shoot. You need to know where the drones are. And then have guns in the right place to shoot them.

I assume since we knew they were in the air, they are detectable on radar, I assume our jets have radar, and I thought our jets have guns and can fly anywhere in Jordan if given approval. Seems knowing where they are and flying the guns there should not be that hard.

Just Triing
Triathlete since 9:56:39 AM EST Aug 20, 2006.
Be kind English is my 2nd language. My primary language is Dave it's a unique evolution of English.
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [DieselPete] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Iranians seized a Portuguese flagged ship earlier today. That's an act of war. Portugal is in NATO. Keep an eye on Barksdale
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [DavHamm] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DavHamm wrote:
chaparral wrote:
DavHamm wrote:
ThisIsIt wrote:
Endo wrote:
Seems like a very inefficient/low success rate to launch a bunch of drones at your target and they know they're coming, but will take "hours" to get there and thus have loads of time to prepare and enact countermeasures on drones that relatively speaking, are pretty slow moving targets themselves.



.


I've heard it argued that the real value of these cheap drones is that they are meant to exhaust the much more expensive resources that may be used to shoot them down. And of course you send enough some are going to get through, and the whole psychological and political angle of using of them.


So if we get the okay from Jordan, could this be a turkey shoot for and some gunfire practice for our fighters?

I mean bullets are cheap, could you just start shooting at them from a jet? (I guess you risk them exploding so need to keep some distance).

This seems to be an area, we need improved defenses. I mean some kind of drag behind netting to just scoop them up would be cool, if it could be done.


Still not a turkey shoot. You need to know where the drones are. And then have guns in the right place to shoot them.

I assume since we knew they were in the air, they are detectable on radar, I assume our jets have radar, and I thought our jets have guns and can fly anywhere in Jordan if given approval. Seems knowing where they are and flying the guns there should not be that hard.

You understand how difficult it is to pickup low flying drones like this? It is not trivial with radar, especially ground based radar.

This is a best case scenario though, there were hours of warning, so you can get airborne assets that are much better at detecting them. But Jordan and Iraq don’t really have those assets. I am going to assume Israel’s newer awecs would be pretty capable at this (that is just an assumption there could have not be capable of this, but I think a safe one).

It is not like missile launches where the US space based systems and the predictable flight of ballistic missiles would be helpful.

Iran is also saying this attack means the matter is deemed concluded:

https://x.com/...XKV1ghhjJ-gpfjpVyTqg

Which makes sense. This is a pretty calibrated response from Iran for an attack on their embassy. They get to blame the US for not condemning. As long as Israel doesn’t keep poking the bear, this shouldn’t escalate.

I do wonder how much do this attack was less about actually striking Israel, than costing Israel a ton of money and reducing their supply of precision weapons at a time where their support from countries like the US, which they need to fully restock, is very weak.

In other words the message may be “the next attack, you won’t have the interceptors for, so maybe slow your roll.”
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [DieselPete] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DieselPete wrote:
Probably deserves its own thread.

Where does this go, and how fast does it go there?

Does the U.S. get involved? Perhaps shooting down drones and rockets?

https://www.bbc.com/...middle-east-68810053


This has been in the cards since 1979, we could have changed history back then and we have been half assing for too long of time.
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [chaparral] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Could the US fire some missiles at them that go rouge and blow up the bridge between Crimea and Russia.. oops sorry.

Just Triing
Triathlete since 9:56:39 AM EST Aug 20, 2006.
Be kind English is my 2nd language. My primary language is Dave it's a unique evolution of English.
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [DavHamm] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It is a bit early but I don't see how this is not a major miscalculation by Iran. 

Global public opinion has shifted against Israel in the last month. This attack will remind the world that Israel is always a target and needs to defend itself.  "Never interrupt your enemy when he's making a mistake"

U.S. and British will take down Iranian drones as they fly over Iraq. Jordan will take them down as they fly over Jordan. Israel will take care of the rest. Iran will look weak and incompetent. 
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [DavHamm] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
DavHamm wrote:
chaparral wrote:
DavHamm wrote:
ThisIsIt wrote:
Endo wrote:
Seems like a very inefficient/low success rate to launch a bunch of drones at your target and they know they're coming, but will take "hours" to get there and thus have loads of time to prepare and enact countermeasures on drones that relatively speaking, are pretty slow moving targets themselves.



.


I've heard it argued that the real value of these cheap drones is that they are meant to exhaust the much more expensive resources that may be used to shoot them down. And of course you send enough some are going to get through, and the whole psychological and political angle of using of them.


So if we get the okay from Jordan, could this be a turkey shoot for and some gunfire practice for our fighters?

I mean bullets are cheap, could you just start shooting at them from a jet? (I guess you risk them exploding so need to keep some distance).

This seems to be an area, we need improved defenses. I mean some kind of drag behind netting to just scoop them up would be cool, if it could be done.


Still not a turkey shoot. You need to know where the drones are. And then have guns in the right place to shoot them.

I assume since we knew they were in the air, they are detectable on radar, I assume our jets have radar, and I thought our jets have guns and can fly anywhere in Jordan if given approval. Seems knowing where they are and flying the guns there should not be that hard.

We can fly anywhere in Jordan without approval
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [Nutella] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Nutella wrote:
It is a bit early but I don't see how this is not a major miscalculation by Iran.

Global public opinion has shifted against Israel in the last month. This attack will remind the world that Israel is always a target and needs to defend itself. "Never interrupt your enemy when he's making a mistake"

U.S. and British will take down Iranian drones as they fly over Iraq. Jordan will take them down as they fly over Jordan. Israel will take care of the rest. Iran will look weak and incompetent.

Iran had to do something. Israel attacked their consulate in Damascus. No country can let that go without a response. That attack was surely executed with the expectation and acceptance of an Iranian retaliation as the cost of doing business.

Best case is that the attack does little damage but Iran feels like it’s met its need to stand up for themselves and the temperature goes back down to a low boil instead of bubbling over.

Slowguy

(insert pithy phrase here...)
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
slowguy wrote:
Nutella wrote:
It is a bit early but I don't see how this is not a major miscalculation by Iran.

Global public opinion has shifted against Israel in the last month. This attack will remind the world that Israel is always a target and needs to defend itself. "Never interrupt your enemy when he's making a mistake"

U.S. and British will take down Iranian drones as they fly over Iraq. Jordan will take them down as they fly over Jordan. Israel will take care of the rest. Iran will look weak and incompetent.

Iran had to do something. Israel attacked their consulate in Damascus. No country can let that go without a response. That attack was surely executed with the expectation and acceptance of an Iranian retaliation as the cost of doing business.

Best case is that the attack does little damage but Iran feels like it’s met its need to stand up for themselves and the temperature goes back down to a low boil instead of bubbling over.

Totally agree.
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
slowguy wrote:
Nutella wrote:
It is a bit early but I don't see how this is not a major miscalculation by Iran.

Global public opinion has shifted against Israel in the last month. This attack will remind the world that Israel is always a target and needs to defend itself. "Never interrupt your enemy when he's making a mistake"

U.S. and British will take down Iranian drones as they fly over Iraq. Jordan will take them down as they fly over Jordan. Israel will take care of the rest. Iran will look weak and incompetent.


Iran had to do something. Israel attacked their consulate in Damascus. No country can let that go without a response. That attack was surely executed with the expectation and acceptance of an Iranian retaliation as the cost of doing business.

Best case is that the attack does little damage but Iran feels like it’s met its need to stand up for themselves and the temperature goes back down to a low boil instead of bubbling over.

Correct, but not accurate. what was attacked was a building in the consulate compound, but the people killed were soldiers, not diplomats. The head guy that was hit was in charge of running Hizballah, not really there on a humanitarian peace keeping task.

Looks like (for now) Teheran does not want escalation beyond this, so trying something that Israel could shoot down and accept without response. The big question is what will Israel do, there's a whole spectrum between nothing all the way down to tactical nukes. We'll see.
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [chaparral] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
Iran is also saying this attack means the matter is deemed concluded:
https://x.com/...XKV1ghhjJ-gpfjpVyTqg

Well they used CAPS so the USA should take that very seriously!
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [Tylertri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tylertri wrote:
DieselPete wrote:
Probably deserves its own thread.

Where does this go, and how fast does it go there?

Does the U.S. get involved? Perhaps shooting down drones and rockets?

https://www.bbc.com/...middle-east-68810053


Nutella has a good buddy at the Tel Aviv airport. As long as his good buddy gets out of this OK I'm sure the impact(s) of this on the rest of the world aren't that important.

After all, Iran has never directly attacked Israel before. Nutella is an expert on the region and will be happy to tell you exactly where this goes from here. In fact, if you question anything he says he will immediately call you a liar and ignorant. So..... relax, sit back, and let Nutella "talk" you through this situation.

And for God's sake whatever you do, don't mis type the word "Cow-Tow" and take whatever opportunity you can to distract from how weak the US has been under Biden in this region if the last 3 years by bringing up Trump as much as you can. Bonus points if you can loop "putin" and "russia" into the conversation (you know, another country and region of the world that's now on fire that never was under Trump).

I try not to respond to you but seriously, what the fuck is wrong with you?
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [50+] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
He makes Comer look smart.
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [Tylertri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Tylertri wrote:
DieselPete wrote:
Probably deserves its own thread.

Where does this go, and how fast does it go there?

Does the U.S. get involved? Perhaps shooting down drones and rockets?

https://www.bbc.com/...middle-east-68810053


Nutella has a good buddy at the Tel Aviv airport. As long as his good buddy gets out of this OK I'm sure the impact(s) of this on the rest of the world aren't that important.

After all, Iran has never directly attacked Israel before. Nutella is an expert on the region and will be happy to tell you exactly where this goes from here. In fact, if you question anything he says he will immediately call you a liar and ignorant. So..... relax, sit back, and let Nutella "talk" you through this situation.

And for God's sake whatever you do, don't mis type the word "Cow-Tow" and take whatever opportunity you can to distract from how weak the US has been under Biden in this region if the last 3 years by bringing up Trump as much as you can. Bonus points if you can loop "putin" and "russia" into the conversation (you know, another country and region of the world that's now on fire that never was under Trump).


I don't usually wade into these threads, but this might be among the top 5 shittiest responses I've ever seen...
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [jeffa] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jeffa wrote:
Tylertri wrote:
DieselPete wrote:
Probably deserves its own thread.

Where does this go, and how fast does it go there?

Does the U.S. get involved? Perhaps shooting down drones and rockets?

https://www.bbc.com/...middle-east-68810053


Nutella has a good buddy at the Tel Aviv airport. As long as his good buddy gets out of this OK I'm sure the impact(s) of this on the rest of the world aren't that important.

After all, Iran has never directly attacked Israel before. Nutella is an expert on the region and will be happy to tell you exactly where this goes from here. In fact, if you question anything he says he will immediately call you a liar and ignorant. So..... relax, sit back, and let Nutella "talk" you through this situation.

And for God's sake whatever you do, don't mis type the word "Cow-Tow" and take whatever opportunity you can to distract from how weak the US has been under Biden in this region if the last 3 years by bringing up Trump as much as you can. Bonus points if you can loop "putin" and "russia" into the conversation (you know, another country and region of the world that's now on fire that never was under Trump).


I don't usually wade into these threads, but this might be among the top 5 shittiest responses I've ever seen...

Top 5?? That's a bit harsh. I would have said Top 3 for sure!! Seemed a really shitty reply to make.

In terms of these events, Iran had to do something given what Israel had done. It was well anticipated in that it was all over the news media that something was likely to happen in the preceding 72 hours.
Be interesting to see now what the response from Israel will be, I would imagine the USA will be pushing hard to prevent Israel from escalating things further to avoid a more widespread conflict.
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [jeffa] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jeffa wrote:
Tylertri wrote:
DieselPete wrote:
Probably deserves its own thread.

Where does this go, and how fast does it go there?

Does the U.S. get involved? Perhaps shooting down drones and rockets?

https://www.bbc.com/...middle-east-68810053
Nutella has a good buddy at the Tel Aviv airport. As long as his good buddy gets out of this OK I'm sure the impact(s) of this on the rest of the world aren't that important.

After all, Iran has never directly attacked Israel before. Nutella is an expert on the region and will be happy to tell you exactly where this goes from here. In fact, if you question anything he says he will immediately call you a liar and ignorant. So..... relax, sit back, and let Nutella "talk" you through this situation.

And for God's sake whatever you do, don't mis type the word "Cow-Tow" and take whatever opportunity you can to distract from how weak the US has been under Biden in this region if the last 3 years by bringing up Trump as much as you can. Bonus points if you can loop "putin" and "russia" into the conversation (you know, another country and region of the world that's now on fire that never was under Trump).
I don't usually wade into these threads, but this might be among the top 5 shittiest responses I've ever seen...

Agreed. And there is an easy pattern to see here: when a LR poster is completely at a loss, or has become an endless consumer of tribal propaganda, they spend much of their time on here doing whatever possible to avoid addressing content and instead focus on just attacking the messenger. It never gets anywhere, but it's always an easy and cowardly way out.

Advanced Aero TopTube Storage for Road, Gravel, & Tri...ZeroSlip & Direct-mount, made in the USA.
DarkSpeedWorks.com.....Reviews.....Insta.....Facebook

--
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [Amnesia] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
US UK and Jordan have all shot down drones.

Only one injury so far

The video over Amman and Tel Aviv is stunning. What's weird to me (comparing to start of air war in Desert Storm) is no AA, just missles.
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [windywave] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The terrorist government of America is warned that any support and participation in harming Iran's interests will result in a decisive and regretful response

Sounds like Iran wants to FAFO.

The response from the US would be similar to bombing Libya except sustained and absolutely debilitating to Iran.
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [windywave] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote Reply
Post deleted by just jack [ In reply to ]
Re: Iran attacks Israel [just jack] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
just jack wrote:
windywave wrote:
US UK and Jordan have all shot down drones.

Only one injury so far

The video over Amman and Tel Aviv is stunning. What's weird to me (comparing to start of air war in Desert Storm) is no AA, just missles.


Can you share a link?


Post immediately preceding yours
Last edited by: windywave: Apr 13, 24 22:16
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [windywave] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks. I missed that.

*****
"In case of flood climb to safety"
Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [Nutella] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
yes dumb move by Iran

They constantly try to escape from the darkness outside and within
Dreaming of systems so perfect that no one will need to be good T.S. Eliot

Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
slowguy wrote:
Nutella wrote:
It is a bit early but I don't see how this is not a major miscalculation by Iran.

Global public opinion has shifted against Israel in the last month. This attack will remind the world that Israel is always a target and needs to defend itself. "Never interrupt your enemy when he's making a mistake"

U.S. and British will take down Iranian drones as they fly over Iraq. Jordan will take them down as they fly over Jordan. Israel will take care of the rest. Iran will look weak and incompetent.


Iran had to do something. Israel attacked their consulate in Damascus. No country can let that go without a response. That attack was surely executed with the expectation and acceptance of an Iranian retaliation as the cost of doing business.

Best case is that the attack does little damage but Iran feels like it’s met its need to stand up for themselves and the temperature goes back down to a low boil instead of bubbling over.

I am thinking Israel does not do much. I think tactically Israel is interested in rooting Hamas out of Gaza above all. Any response against Iran complicates things immensely

They constantly try to escape from the darkness outside and within
Dreaming of systems so perfect that no one will need to be good T.S. Eliot

Quote Reply
Re: Iran attacks Israel [spockman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
spockman wrote:
slowguy wrote:
Nutella wrote:
It is a bit early but I don't see how this is not a major miscalculation by Iran.

Global public opinion has shifted against Israel in the last month. This attack will remind the world that Israel is always a target and needs to defend itself. "Never interrupt your enemy when he's making a mistake"

U.S. and British will take down Iranian drones as they fly over Iraq. Jordan will take them down as they fly over Jordan. Israel will take care of the rest. Iran will look weak and incompetent.


Iran had to do something. Israel attacked their consulate in Damascus. No country can let that go without a response. That attack was surely executed with the expectation and acceptance of an Iranian retaliation as the cost of doing business.

Best case is that the attack does little damage but Iran feels like it’s met its need to stand up for themselves and the temperature goes back down to a low boil instead of bubbling over.


I am thinking Israel does not do much. I think tactically Israel is interested in rooting Hamas out of Gaza above all. Any response against Iran complicates things immensely

And yet, they attacked first. So ...

Just Triing
Triathlete since 9:56:39 AM EST Aug 20, 2006.
Be kind English is my 2nd language. My primary language is Dave it's a unique evolution of English.
Quote Reply

Prev Next