Ted0ne wrote:
Hi,
I am interested in a shiv disc and need your help !
Here I went through the forum and it turns out that I have to make a choice between the size XS and S.
Normally you advise to take the size S and after several discussions with owners and despite a postural study which recommends the size S screw compared to the XS, looking at the manual and talking to someone who owns a SHIV in size S, I'm not sure the saddle extension is adequate with my measurements and the rear foil.
I measure 1.68cm with 82cm inseam and my saddle exit is 72cm.
When I check at the specific geometry:
- The seat post length is
350mm in both XS and S size
- The seat tube length is
490mm in XS size and
522mm in S size.
In the manual, it was mentioned that the reservoir may limit the seatpost insertion and the minimum insertion of seat post is
75mm and the maximum is
200mm.
So if I calculate the saddle extension on the two frame sizes, we get to this :
- the maximum saddle extension for the XS is : 490 + 275 (seat post length - minimum insertion) =
765mm - the minimum saddle extension for the S is : 522 + 150 (seat post length - maximum insertion) =
672mm
But the problem is that these measurements do not take into account the height of my saddle (Prologo T-Gale) from the rails = 50mm.
So if I add my saddle height at the previous dimensions, I get this :
- the maximum saddle extension for the XS is : 765 + 50 =
815mm - the minimum saddle extension for the S is : 672 + 50 =
722mm (so bigger for my own saddle height)
Which would mean that Specialized (and my postural study) advise me an S frame where I could not put my correct saddle height unless I cut the rear foil ? Are you agree with my calcul ?
So If I am not wrong, I therefore have no choice to take a size XS (or go to S size and change my saddle).
Hey Ted0ne
Nice thorough review!
You are correct that the min saddle height for the SM is 723mm (based on a POWER Saddle). If you use the +25mm offset post (available at your dealer) you gain an additional ~43mm of seat post depth, allowing you to go down to a minimum of 683mm.
You would need to make sure the +25 post is OK with your saddle setback & reach, but if so, then I recommend you go with a SM and cut your Seat Post ~10mm and then you will have no issues.
If you do not want to cut your post, or you do not want to go with a Forward offset Seat Post, then your options are to find a saddle with a rail height that is a bit lower, adjust your crank arm length to sit higher, or go with an XS...Since we are only talking a few MMs here i think its easy to find a way to make SM work
I